Faking It: Gourmet Foods to Go

by Melanie Berliet - Citysearch Editor - 98 Reviews - 52 Lists

Updated: March 01, 2009

Everyone knows that true New Yorkers cook less than they take out, but sometimes your body needs a break from MSG. That's when a gourmet dinner party is in order. The problem? You're not a "Top Chef" contestant or a Rachel Ray devotee. The solution? A trip to one of the many specialty markets around town. So long as they're sated, your friends shouldn't question your culinary prowess.

Grab Gourmet

  1. 1 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Zabar's
    Read Reviews

    245 W 80th St, New York, NY 10024 (map)

    This bi-level spot is more than a food shop; it's an institution. When hosting a brunch you can?t go wrong with the grocer?s bagels and whitefish--and your guests will be glad it was you who waited in the eternal line, instead of them.

  2. 2 3 Star Rating: Average Eli's Manhattan
    Read Reviews

    1411 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10028 (map)

    You pay out the nose for the ready-made food options at this Upper East Side gourmet haven, but the check-out lines show it?s well worth it. Design a fancy feast with pastrami and pickles, Asian-glazed salmon with sauteed spinach and a mousse cake to boot (though hopefully not literally).

  3. 3 5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended Whole Foods Market
    Read Reviews

    10 Columbus Cir, New York, NY 10019 (map)

    This enormous warehouse of a grocery market is the mecca of the health conscious set. The good news? The catering department saves you from having to wander among the heart-healthy types. Have hors d'oeuvres like mixed satays and beef crostini delivered along with a main meal of bourbon-molasses-glazed spiral cut ham, and savor your guests' glee over your surprising culinary talent.

  4. 4 4 Star Rating: Recommended Citarella
    Read Reviews

    1313 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021 (map)

    A variety of high-end nuts and dried fruits make for solid snacks during cocktail hour. When all boozed up, your guests won't notice that the tasty pasta sauce--like the pre-made bolognese or tomato marina--came out of a plastic container.

  5. 5 4 Star Rating: Recommended Gourmet Garage
    Read Reviews

    453 Broome St, New York, NY 10013 (map)

    One of the city's more prolific gourmet chains has a full spread of olives, cheeses and caviar, providing options for starters. Follow this with organic greens or crudites, and top it all off with a selection of sushi (and a line at the table about your favorite new investment: The sushi rolling set).

  6. 6 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Russ & Daughters
    Read Reviews

    179 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002 (map)

    Impress your guests with your impeccable taste when you present them with a full party platter from this homey gourmet store. The emphasis here is on the sea, and the fish--whether smoked, raw, or cooked--is fresh. You'll also find oceans of fresh-baked breads, salads starring egg, eggplant, or artichoke and many fine, stinky, imported and domestic cheeses.

  7. 7 4 Star Rating: Recommended Dean & De Luca Inc
    Read Reviews

    560 Broadway, New York, NY 10012 (map)

    Your aim is believability, so pick up pre-grilled chicken breasts and creamy mashed potatoes, or go all the way with a vat of homemade soup and chicken cordon bleu. Just remember to ditch the black-and-white bags--the only telltale sign standing between you and your lie.