5 to Try: Holiday Pies

/roundup/be/67/39809r1.jpg

Updated: March 12, 2009

Nothing reminds one more of the holidays than the scent of a just-baked pie. Unfortunately, we don't all have time to do our Betty Crocker impression. Here are five pies that'll turn you into the star of your holiday party.

Heavenly Holiday Pies

  1. 1 3.5 Star Rating: Average Sweet Melissa
    Read Reviews

    276 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 (map)

    Cobble Hill's best bakery offers an assortment of seasonal pies--but the chocolate bourbon pecan pie is its most decadent ($32 for a 9-inch).

  2. 2 4 Star Rating: Recommended Billy's Bakery
    Read Reviews

    184 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011 (map)

    OK, so peanut butter chocolate pie isn't the most traditional pie to bring to a holiday party. After one bite of this amazingly decadent dessert ($24), however, nobody will be complaining.

  3. 3 4.5 Star Rating: Recommended Sugar Sweet Sunshine
    Read Reviews

    126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002 (map)

    For a tart treat, this homey bakery's strawberry rhubarb pie ($20) should do the trick.

  4. 4 Umanoff & Parsons
    Write a review

    1704 Boone Avereene 1250, Bronx, NY 10460 (map)

    Try the seasonally available pumpkin pie ($15 for a 10-inch) from this quiet bakery that only accepts cash but delivers right to your home in time for the holidays.

  5. 5 3.5 Star Rating: Average Tea & Sympathy Inc
    Read Reviews

    108 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011 (map)

    For a more old-world holiday celebration, pick up a couple of the small mincemeat pies ($1.95 each) at this English specialty stop.

Advertisement