(212) 988-9200
1341 3rd Ave
New York,
NY
10021
40.7725
-73.9584
Neighborhoods: Midtown, Upper East Side
What People Are Saying About Atlantic Grill
The Editor
Contributor
Citysearch
The wraparound dining room and polished wood bar have been slammed since opening in 1998. Swathed in sea-foam green with aquatic photographs, it's a comfortable spot teeming with neighborhood regulars: gussied-up grand dames, first-date couples and raucous groups of friends. Servers are professional and serious, but can only handle so many tables at a time. There's something for fish fans of every stripe on the lengthy menu. Freshly shucked oysters and clams appeal to purists, while classicists order crisp-crusted, all-meat lump crab cakes and chopped iceburg-feta salads. Zippier palates share…
11/15/09
Worst service ever -- WORST EVER!!!
by Cloche at Citysearch
Have gone to AG over past several years, but the service at dinner tonight was so painfully slow that they've lost me as a customer forever. I should have know we were in for the dinner from hell when our family arrived for an early Sunday dinner at 5 p.m. and the place was relatively empty and it still took more than a half hour to get the waitress's attention and get a menue. Hours later, when the place was full, it took much longer to get the bill and finally escape. Never again!
- Cons: Slow service
10/21/09
3 RATS
by agmfoodie at Citysearch
last time I went or early dinner with kids I saw 3 rats nibbling in the corner. can you believe it!!!! I used to go each week for sushi and white wine. gone are those days.
- Pros: OPEN AIR UES destination
- Cons: Filthy
08/12/09
Great Bar Restaurant for Solo Diners
by agiver at Citysearch
The bartender, Dan, was exceptional!
- Pros: Service, Food Quality, Price
- Cons: More bar sitting
The Details on Atlantic Grill
Know Before You Go:
Walk-ins will have a hard time scoring a table, unless they're willing to eat at the noisy front bar.
Save Money:
There aren't many less than $40 wines; by-the-glass options are around $9. The middle-of-the-road pinot grigio is a fine white, and the earthy Rioja fares well with oilier fish, like halibut and sea bass.
Category:
Payment Methods:
American Express, Diners Club, Discover, Visa, MasterCard
Restaurant Special Features:
Brunch, People Watching, Group Dining, Dine At The Bar, Bar Scene, Notable Wine List
Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter