| ambiance |
71.4300012588501% positive |
- “
We sat outside so i can't really say what the ambiance or decor was like inside, but i did see that they have a full bar. ”
- “
Third, there is a bit of a wait most nights, but that's more attributed to the great atmosphere and burgers. ”
- “
The ambiance sucks, too. ”
- “
The burger is fantastic as are the salads, the fries, the bloody marys and the atmosphere which harkens back to a better New York. ”
- “
The bar scene is fun which helps because there's usually a wait to get in. ”
- “
It is a small place so it tends to get crowded and noisy during dinner hours but its all part of the experience, have a beer while you wait and enjoy the atmosphere. ”
- “
This is a great neighborhood place with lots of atmosphere. ”
|
| drinks |
68.75% positive |
- “
Fries were tasteless and beer served in 1/3 pint glasses at pint prices. ”
- “
restaurant/bar. JG Melon is a unique establishment and provides a unique experience. ”
- “
Accompanied with a side of cottage fries, a cup of chili and a cold beer, it is the perfect meal. ”
- “
great burgers,maybe the best bar burger in town. ”
- “
The bar scene is fun which helps because there's usually a wait to get in. ”
- “
bar that serves a decent burger - nothing more ”
- “
We sat outside so i can't really say what the ambiance or decor was like inside, but i did see that they have a full bar. ”
- “
It is a small place so it tends to get crowded and noisy during dinner hours but its all part of the experience, have a beer while you wait and enjoy the atmosphere. ”
|
| food quality |
90.2299976348877% positive |
- “
The burgers are excellent: tender, fresh, beefy and cooked to your liking. ”
- “
JG Melon has possibly the best burgers I have ever had in my entire life. ”
- “
Best Burger in NYC, also wonderful cottage fries. ”
- “
Skip Rare and all of the hype and go to JG Melons for really good fries and burgers. ”
- “
While I love the burgers and they're reasonably priced, J.G. Melon does have some downsides. ”
- “
burgers good for past 20 yrs-there are never any surprises! ”
- “
They have the best burgers, cottage fries and bloody marys anywhere. ”
- “
one of the best burgers in manhattan. ”
- “
The fries are expensive at $3.50. ”
- “
Absolutely the best burgers in town ”
- “
great burgers and bloodies! ”
- “
have been going to Melon's for my entire life, and believe me, these ARE the best burgers in the City. ”
- “
The food pricing is what you would expect for any "nice" restaurant here in the city. ”
- “
Great food including burgers, steak tartar and everything that is bad for us. ”
- “
The burgers were good, but the price made me cringe. ”
- “
Only at Melon's can you see a 70-something socialite take off her diamonds and pearls to scarf a juicy bacon cheeseburger and the amazing cattage fries! ”
- “
The best burgers in New York! ”
- “
You CANNOT be the best burger in town if you serve your burger on store-bought-quality wonder bread hamburger buns. ”
- “
good burger fries need work ”
- “
JG Melon is very inexpensive, too -- only $8 for a burger (a huge burger) and $6 for a huge order of fries (split the fries between 2 people). ”
- “
Hands down the best burgers in the Big Apple's five boroughs. ”
- “
The poor service and passable food definitely didn't fit the bill. ”
- “
Love the food, Hate the staff ”
- “
JG Melon's burgers are, without a doubt, up there with Jackson Hole, The Burger Joint (at the Park Meridian), and P.J. Clarke's in midtown and rival those restaurants for the best burger in Manhattan. ”
- “
Thin, flat, dry burger on a thin, wonder-bready bun, with a limp pickle and some wilted lettuce and mealy tomato. ”
- “
And the fries are amazing, too. ”
- “
Call me crazy, but I love their spinach salad, too. ”
- “
JG Melon serves the best burger in NYC, hands down. ”
- “
Possibly the best burger in the world. ”
- “
The menu here is limited, good burgers but that's about it! ”
- “
Took my sister who was in from out of town and she said it was her best meal in the city. ”
- “
the burgers are fresh made, juicy and really simple. ”
- “
like the burgers, even though I think $8.00 is very pricey for a simple burger without fries. ”
- “
had been a regualr a corner since I live downtown but I was up visiting a friend so figured I would give mellons a try-it was a nice place, good service, nice people, the burger was almost as good but the fries are the wavy disk type which can be good b ”
- “
JG Melon has some of the best burgers in the city. ”
- “
The person above who reviewed the burger as bad and stringy must be a total idiot. ”
- “
This isn't just the best burger place in the city, it's the best restaraunt in Manhattan. ”
- “
The fries, which are sliced into little rounds are really good as well. ”
- “
If you want a good burger, go somewhere else. ”
- “
this is THE BEST burger in new york city - i've been to each and every spot in manhattan and this is the best tasting of all - HANDS DOWN. ”
- “
Have a great burger and cottage fries. ”
- “
Their fries suck compared to the cottage fried at JG Melon's. ”
- “
The cottage fries are also delicious. ”
- “
have been there before and the burgers are good but not at the quality of 'have to have before you die' burgers. ”
- “
The burgers are good, but there are many better burgers in town and the cottage fries are mediocre (IMHO cottage fries are always mediocre, which is why no one else serves them). ”
- “
great burger, unfriendly service ”
- “
The burger was cooked to perfection and the portion sizes were perfect! ”
- “
It's the best burger ever! ”
- “
love the chicken sandwiches and the fries. ”
- “
The chip-fries are also delicious, and the chili is a great option if you're not in the mood for a burger. ”
- “
Ok, I was recommended J.G. Melon by one of my NY buddies, and he said it's "one of the best burgers ever ”
- “
If you are a burger fan, the Melon is not to be missed as it compensates nicely with the best burger for its spotty service and cramped environs. ”
- “
great burgers,maybe the best bar burger in town. ”
- “
It feels 'old school' and that's because their food is just as delicious today as it was years ago (according to my late grandmother). ”
- “
The food was delicious, but service was a little on the slow side, but i wasn't in a hurry so no big deal. ”
- “
bar that serves a decent burger - nothing more ”
- “
People rave about the burgers. ”
- “
The cottage fries are also amazing and they are very fresh and easily addicting. ”
- “
Great burger, great evening ”
- “
the service is casual but the burgers are the best ive ever had. ”
- “
The burgers here are the best in the City. ”
- “
the best burgers in town ”
- “
Third, there is a bit of a wait most nights, but that's more attributed to the great atmosphere and burgers. ”
- “
Cause like me, LOTS of other people love the food and keep coming back! ”
- “
So, one evening, in dire need of the best burger possible, I sing the second-hand praises of this joint to my companion and drag him up there. ”
- “
The burger is so juicy and delicious that I have yet to stray from my usual order. ”
- “
The burgers are delicious -- fresh, juicy and flavorful. ”
- “
was anxious to try JG Melon after I heard that it had the best burgers in the city and I would have to agree. ”
- “
Best burger, best people, too ”
- “
Also, the bloody bull (a bloody mary modified to include beef broth) is an excellent add on to the burger. ”
- “
Best burgers, worst service ”
- “
Without fail, hands down, no peer best burgers in Manhattan. ”
- “
Hands down best burger in NYC, great fries too. ”
- “
The burgers here are amazing. ”
- “
The burgers are delicious (I get mine medium-rare. ”
- “
Pair is with a spicy Bloody Bull and you've got a perfect meal. ”
- “
Accompanied with a side of cottage fries, a cup of chili and a cold beer, it is the perfect meal. ”
- “
Of all the choices for a great burger in the city, this is the top. ”
- “
The burger is fantastic as are the salads, the fries, the bloody marys and the atmosphere which harkens back to a better New York. ”
- “
Stopped in for late lunch and had a great burger! ”
- “
The best burgers in the city and lots of local charm. ”
|
| menu variety |
100.0% positive |
- “
Of all the choices for a great burger in the city, this is the top. ”
- “
The menu here is limited, good burgers but that's about it! ”
|
| overall |
87.5% positive |
- “
You CANNOT be the best burger in town if you serve your burger on store-bought-quality wonder bread hamburger buns. ”
- “
This is a great neighborhood place with lots of atmosphere. ”
- “
This isn't just the best burger place in the city, it's the best restaraunt in Manhattan. ”
- “
had been a regualr a corner since I live downtown but I was up visiting a friend so figured I would give mellons a try-it was a nice place, good service, nice people, the burger was almost as good but the fries are the wavy disk type which can be good b ”
|
| return potential |
100.0% positive |
- “
had been a regualr a corner since I live downtown but I was up visiting a friend so figured I would give mellons a try-it was a nice place, good service, nice people, the burger was almost as good but the fries are the wavy disk type which can be good b ”
|
| service |
69.0500020980835% positive |
- “
the service is casual but the burgers are the best ive ever had. ”
- “
If you are a burger fan, the Melon is not to be missed as it compensates nicely with the best burger for its spotty service and cramped environs. ”
- “
We didn't encounter any rude wait staff, but the host was rude to other customers. ”
- “
Too rude to stay ”
- “
But the guy who seats you is just aws rude as you've read. ”
- “
The poor service and passable food definitely didn't fit the bill. ”
- “
So the staff might be a bit scratchy from time to time, but they're fair, and once you're seated and move on to the second tier, the service is fast and happy. ”
- “
Cause like me, LOTS of other people love the food and keep coming back! ”
- “
There is no excuse for the horrible service at this place. ”
- “
know this place has been around for a while and is very busy, but I believe in good service and hospitality when I am spending good money, which they do not offer. ”
- “
The seater was so incredibly rude to our party, including snapping at a pregnant woman who politely asked about the wait, that we were too angry to eat there. ”
- “
had been a regualr a corner since I live downtown but I was up visiting a friend so figured I would give mellons a try-it was a nice place, good service, nice people, the burger was almost as good but the fries are the wavy disk type which can be good b ”
- “
The food was delicious, but service was a little on the slow side, but i wasn't in a hurry so no big deal. ”
- “
JG Melon is very inexpensive, too -- only $8 for a burger (a huge burger) and $6 for a huge order of fries (split the fries between 2 people). ”
- “
The bartender sucks and has an attitude. ”
- “
great burger, unfriendly service ”
- “
Love the food, Hate the staff ”
- “
My roomates and I call ahead to place our order, then walk in and pick it up to avoid waiting for a table -- but the staff is always friendly and never obnoxious or pushy, even when it's crowded and crazy. ”
- “
Best burgers, worst service ”
- “
I'm told one of the bartenders is the father of a famous movie star. ”
- “
Best burger, best people, too ”
|
| value |
77.77999877929688% positive |
- “
The fries are expensive at $3.50. ”
- “
JG Melon is very inexpensive, too -- only $8 for a burger (a huge burger) and $6 for a huge order of fries (split the fries between 2 people). ”
- “
Quite frankly, JG Melon is one of my favorite restaurants in Manhattan, and it's not expensive at all. ”
- “
The good news is that they are successful enough that they can afford to charge very reasonable prices. ”
- “
like the burgers, even though I think $8.00 is very pricey for a simple burger without fries. ”
- “
The burgers were good, but the price made me cringe. ”
- “
The food pricing is what you would expect for any "nice" restaurant here in the city. ”
- “
Fries were tasteless and beer served in 1/3 pint glasses at pint prices. ”
- “
know this place has been around for a while and is very busy, but I believe in good service and hospitality when I am spending good money, which they do not offer. ”
|
| wait time |
100.0% positive |
- “
The food was delicious, but service was a little on the slow side, but i wasn't in a hurry so no big deal. ”
|
Deals
share
