Goodfellas Brickoven & Pizza
(718) 984-7500
655 Rossville Ave, Staten Island, NY | Directions
View Website
Recommend this business?
Add a Photo
At a Glance
?
100% ambiance
“You will remember your first visit,tell them it's your first visit and they will go out of their way to please,after dining go to shore and take a walk on the boardwalk (short drive from restaurant) nice views of bridge.”
100% dessert
“for me this is the best pizza on the Island and probably the best I have ever had, their fresh cheese pie is amazing, a bit overpriced, well maybe but its really good!”
50% food quality
“Perhaps those who rated Goodfella's as the "the best pizza" need to branch out further than Staten Island.”
0% service
“it has terrible pizza and ok service.”
50% value
“It has the worst pizza I 've tasted and it's overpriced too!”
Write a Tip for
Goodfellas Brickoven & Piz…
Tips for Goodfellas Brickoven & Pizza
September 04, 2006
Very good Pizza. I have tried their New Smoki'n Goodfellas pizza, it is so good and of course we know the Vodka Pie is out of this world. Guess now i know why they were aworded 3 times best Pizza in Las Vegas.
0
Heart
January 13, 2003
goodfellas is not good. i think this pizza place should not be reccomended to anyone. it has terrible pizza and ok service. it is too small and overcrowding a lot of the times that ive went there.
0
Heart
November 27, 2002
this emperor has no clothes. This is the most over-rated, publicity grabbing franchise masquerading as a family run establishment. They should have stayed small and focused on quality rather than expand and lose control. Has definitly lost its edge.
0
Heart
November 27, 2002
Ya wanna leg? Ya wanna wing?. Nah. Have a slice. You talkin to me? Go on. Have a slice.
0
Heart
November 06, 2002
best on SI. rating food is very subjective, especially pizza! for me this is the best pizza on the Island and probably the best I have ever had, their fresh cheese pie is amazing, a bit overpriced, well maybe but its really good!
0
Heart
November 06, 2002
overpriced and overhyped.
Ever notice all the ads and hype surrounding this place? And guess who is doing this? The owner of course! This pizza can be summed up in one word: MEDIOCRE. This place thrives because the people of Staten Island have learned to accept mediocrity. There are so many take out places here and they all do well so many can afford to be substandard. I visited Goodfellas recently. I ordered a lg pepperoni pizza.
First it was overpriced, $15 is ridiculous for a pie. Second, it had the most funny tasting sheese that I have ever tasted. And it was underdone, so much for their great oven, eh?
Needless to say, once was enough for this place. There are better places around here, even frozen!
0
Heart
November 01, 2002
Rate Again. Perhaps those who rated Goodfella's as the "the best pizza" need to branch out further than Staten Island. (Although Staten Island also has it's good share of pizza spots).
0
Heart
November 01, 2002
Pizza hall of fame. You will remember your first visit,tell them it's your first visit and they will go out of their way to please,after dining go to shore and take a walk on the boardwalk (short drive from restaurant) nice views of bridge.The food is excellente!
0
Heart
August 23, 2002
The BEST!. Goodfella's isn't rated as the number one pizza for nothing! Their Pizza Alla Vodka and Sally Pie's are the best and most unique pies created!
0
Heart
Write a Tip for
Goodfellas Brickoven & Piz…
People also viewed
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.