(212) 582-2200
359 W 54th St
New York,
NY
10019
40.7656
-73.9859
Neighborhoods: Midtown, Clinton
What People Are Saying About Cosmo Martini Bar
The Editor
Contributor
Citysearch
The Scene – Imagine a less quaint, more gay version of "Cheers" (without all the '80s hairdos). Well-groomed Hell's Kitchen boys bring a date or come alone; the bartender takes care that everybody knows everybody before too long. Throbbing club music, a cool cement floor and a three-sided bar lit blue from underneath make it a fresh neighborhood place that could well be a television-sitcom set. Hunky patrons star in the real-life drama. – – The Draw – Skyy vodka serves as a smooth base for 12 martinis and a classic cosmo. The simplicity of the drink menu, and the…
Great place for quiet conversation.
by cafe_racer
Always one of my favorite places to go in the neighborhood if I am looking for a queit place to chill. The prices are cheap, especially the happy hour. $4 for a martini? Awesome. Plus, the bartenders are always friendly. The only problem is that sometimes they close early on a weekday.
- Pros: Cheap prices, great service.
- Cons: Can get crowded
Had a good time, but not really a gay bar
by jcocnca
Was on a visit and heard through Citysearch about this place. It is small in fact there where 3 other people in there plus the bartender. Being a Californian had a good time since 2 of the people were originally from California as well. Had great drinks (watermelon martini's) and good conversation. This is a small space (hey it's NYC) but had a good time just what was needed since I'm not into the whole bar scene. I asked about it being a gay bar and the bartender (I'm sorry I forgot here name, but she was GREAT! had too many martinis but it was a Wednesday night) she said it really isn't listed as a gay bar but all the clientele (3) were. If you want to talk, have some drinks at a good price, in a easy going environment, check it out before you move on.
service is everything
by kmd70
I happened into Cosmo with a few friends. The place was empty but the music was good(Van Lear Rose) so we stayed. Right off the bat the bartender made us feel welcome. I ordered a Martini from their drink list. I have to say it was done almost perfect. The bartender(Melody) was very engaging. My friends and I ended up staying for a lot longer than we would have if it wasn't for her. Some regulars came in and Melody made sure to introduce everyone and we all soon became friends. Not only is she pretty, she's smart, can make a pretty good Martini and makes everyone friends. We will be back because of her. Like I said service is everything.
- Pros: service, drinks
- Cons: empty, ventilation
The Details on Cosmo Martini Bar
Know Before You Go:
Rent the whole joint for a mere $200: a popular option for gay and straight alike. Call ahead to avoid showing up when it's closed for yet another private party.








Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter