Recommend this business?
Add a Photo
At a Glance
?
0% dessert
“Pizza place offers a wide selection of different pizzas by the slice or full pie.”
94% food quality
“If you like to mix it up a bit, have the white slice or fresh mozz.”
0% menu variety
“Pizza place offers a wide selection of different pizzas by the slice or full pie.”
100% overall
“The place definitely lives upto it's reputation and a nice place.”
94% service
“Great Pizza, fast service (even during lunch when they are really busy) and very clean.”
100% value
“Best pizza anywhere and great price!”
Write a Tip for
Pizza Suprema
From The Owner of Pizza Suprema
About Pizza Suprema
-
Award Winning Pizza
-
Free Fast Delivery
-
Corporate Deliveries
Located in Midtown, across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden for over 40 years this pizzeria has been owned by the same Italian
family since its inception. It is currently rated "One of the Ten Best Pizzas in Midtown" by Gayot and has been rated by the New York Times culinary journalist Ed Levine as "one of the best pizzas in Manhattan." The Village Voice has also rated it "one of the best in NYC." Here Pizza making is taken very seriously. One cannot get chicken wings, hamburgers or anything else but excellent pizza at this establishment. Excellent pizza, with the finest ingedients, including fine imported romano grated cheese from Italy, the highest quality Grande Mozzarella and Plum Tomatoes is used to make a thin crust, well baked pizza in the Old Italian Tradition.
***Rated Highly by Gayot***
…
View Less
Tips for Pizza Suprema
April 03, 2013
The pizza slices are crazy good.I think
I have been to most pizza places in New York and this is in my top 5.
Thanks Brigitte Grisanti New York Food Traveler
0
Heart
December 31, 2012
Pizza Suprema is a great bargain, and its proximity to Penn Station makes it a great way to kill time waiting for your train. Slices are guaranteed fresh. I have never had a bad slice here, and that's more than I can say for many of the mediocre slabs I've scoffed down nearby.
0
Heart
July 23, 2012
This restaurant is pretty good. I really liked their Pizza and soup. It was awesome.
0
Heart
July 12, 2012
Decent pizza at an affordable price. Beats those frozen pizzas and fast food chain restaurants, if you know what I mean. It was a great experience and I met a new friend there, so there. (=
0
Heart
March 17, 2012
BEST pizza in NYC, by far. This pizza is beyond amazing. Right amount of cheese, sauce and every other ingredient. If your by penn station/MSG- this is a must g. Got the top 10 BEST pizza restaurants in NYC https://files.nyu.edu/jdy215/public/
0
Heart
January 11, 2012
Good pizza. I have had the privilege of finding this little jewel of a pizzeria. The prices are excellent for delivery or carry-out. The pizza quality is quite good given the low budget busting prices. I would recommend this pizzeria as a good pizza with a super value.
0
Heart
July 09, 2011
Great Pizza.
I visited NYC for 1 day. I tried Pizza Suprema after searching the internet for good NY style pizza.
Awesome pizza at a good price.
Perfect crust, sauce and toppings.
I had a slice of white pizza and pepperoni pizza for $7.75. Huge slices.
I don't see how this could be improved.
Please keep it up. I will eat here every time I visit NYC.
If a restaurant like this existed in Northern VA, Pizza Hut, Dominos and Papa Johns would immediately be out of business.
0
Heart
March 07, 2011
Best pizza ever!.
I work several blocks from Pizza Suprema. Almost weekly,
a group from work heads for lunch together and even though there are numerous pizza joints in the area, we always choose Pizza Suprema. Their upside down pizza is out of this world. And their sauce is just yummy no matter which pizza you get. I would recommend Pizza Suprema anytime you are in the 34th Street area in the Big
Apple.
The Pig
0
Heart
Write a Tip for
Pizza Suprema
People also viewed
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.