Pizza Suprema

AWARDED ONE OF THE 10 BEST PIZZAS IN NYC\n

(914) 401-4554

413 8th Ave (30th St and 31st St)
New York, NY 10001 40.75 -73.995067

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Chelsea, Midtown

Last updated 6.15.10

Category:

Restaurants

Restaurant Special Features:

Food Delivery

Cuisine:

Pizza

Email Business

What People Are Saying About Pizza Suprema

The Owner

Pizza Suprema

Owner

Located in Midtown, across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden for over 40 years this pizzeria has been owned by the same Italian family since its inception. It is currently rated "One of the Ten Best Pizzas in Midtown" by Gayot and has been rated by the New York Times culinary journalist Ed Levine as "one of the best pizzas in Manhattan." The Village Voice has also rated it "one of the best in NYC." Here Pizza making is taken very seriously. One cannot get chicken wings, hamburgers or anything else but excellent pizza at this establishment. Excellent pizza, with the finest ingedients, including fine imported romano grated cheese from Italy, the highest quality Grande Mozzarella and Plum Tomatoes is used to make a thin crust, well baked pizza in the Old Italian Tradition.

***Rated Highly by Gayot***

CityGrid

Read more from the owner

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

Pizza and Italian restaurant near Penn Station serves traditional pizza as it's cooked in the Old Country.

dessert
0.0% positive
  1. “Pizza place offers a wide selection of different pizzas by the slice or full pie.”
food quality
94.79000091552734% positive
  1. “Do yourself a favor and drop by, order a regular, a sicilian, a white, a fresh mozz and basil, or the upside down slice, it's all amazing!”
  2. “Suprema's slices are the best in the city because of the sauce.”
  3. “pizza suprema has never ever failed to meet my high expectations.”
  4. “Now that I'm downtown in SoHo, I miss the delicious pizza on 8th Avenue between 30th and 31st Streets.”
  5. “Before coming here, I always classified pizza as good or not so good, and never really understood why some people would be so adamant about pizza reviews.”
  6. “would recommend this place not only to pizza lovers, but to those who appreciate good cuisine!”
  7. “The thin crust is unbelievable and the fresh mozzarella basil is amazing!”
  8. “Pizza was affordable and de delicious”
  9. “If you love pizza you need to experience Pizza Suprema.”
  10. “Try their upside down pizza it like heaven on earth.”
  11. “Located diagonally across from the Eighth Avenue/31st Street entrance to Penn Station, Pizza Suprema is an old fashioned, pizza-by-the-slice pizzeria that has the best pizza slice in the city.”
  12. “My favorites are the regular round, upside down, fresh mozzarella, and white slice garnished with lightly breaded eggplant cutlets.”
  13. “Friendly staff, great delivery folks and the right combination of slightly sweet sauce, tasty cheese, and a crispy, yet robust crust.”
  14. “Pizza Suprema has the perfect combination and if you get the pleasure of trying their pizza make sure you try their regular slice, it is out of this world.”
  15. “everything about it was superb, the crust, the sauce, the cheese, yum!”
  16. “excellent pizza”
  17. “You're also getting this superb quality pizza at a cheaper price than what you would pay at these other so called pizzerias.”
  18. “the pizzas are always fresh, and delicious.”
  19. “Pizza place offers a wide selection of different pizzas by the slice or full pie.”
  20. “best pizza”
  21. “The owner is the best business man I have ever seen, his food is the best I have ever tasted.”
  22. “awesome pizza, for $2 and 3$ for a slice.”
  23. “The sauce is always fresh tasting and flavorful.”
  24. “Most places I have tried either the cheese was tasteless or the pizza tasted very dowey.”
  25. “great pizza”
  26. “The grated cheese on top of the upside down pizza gives it an edge over the regular sicilian slice which is also great!”
  27. “The fresh muzzeralla and basil is five stars!”
  28. “This place has one of the most unique assortment of pizzas that I've ever tried.”
  29. “Best pizza anywhere and great price!”
  30. “Including at some of the most "famous" joints, I gotta say that this is the best pizza I have ever had!”
  31. “You can really tell that they take their pizza seriously at this place, great ingredients and taste.”
  32. “It is not difficult to explain what makes their pizza great, but it would take me too many words to describe.”
  33. “If you like to mix it up a bit, have the white slice or fresh mozz.”
  34. “The service was great and the pizza was sooo good!”
  35. “Pizza is my favorite food.”
  36. “come to pizza suprema 3 times a week and its the best pizza ever!”
  37. “Their thin crust pies were cooked to perfection, delicious when I ate my first slice I felt as if a party broke out in mouth, fantastic flavor.”
  38. “My fiance and I love going here every once in a while for a guilty pizza indulgence.”
  39. “Having been born and raised in the NYC area, I am quite familiar with good pizza and not so good pizza.”
  40. “The best pizza in the city, fast service, great and friendly employees.”
  41. “Our favorite place for our favorite food is NY Pizza Suprema.”
  42. “You can even stack two warm cheese slices on top of each other like John Travolta in Saturday Night Fever and eat your pizza while strutting down Eighth Avenue.”
  43. “must for people looking for the best pizza in NYC”
  44. “The crust was nice and thin, sauce and cheese were of a good quality and the turnover always has fresh pies out of the oven.”
  45. “From the first time I ate here, I was blown away by the unbelievably delicious food they serve.”
  46. “The Sicilian slice is delicious (and so is the regular slice).”
  47. “This is the most absolute awesome pizza in the world!”
  48. “It is also the favorite food of my 6 year old son.”
menu variety
0.0% positive
  1. “Pizza place offers a wide selection of different pizzas by the slice or full pie.”
overall
100.0% positive
  1. “Its nice this place is so close to Penn Station.”
  2. “The place definitely lives upto it's reputation and a nice place.”
service
94.44000244140625% positive
  1. “The best pizza in the city, fast service, great and friendly employees.”
  2. “Pizza was good, owner was friendly and prices were great!”
  3. “PS: the management and staff are always very professional, courteous and gracious, which makes the expereince perfect in all respects.”
  4. “Friendly service and clean & fast!”
  5. “Friendly staff, great delivery folks and the right combination of slightly sweet sauce, tasty cheese, and a crispy, yet robust crust.”
  6. “The service was great and the pizza was sooo good!”
  7. “Great Pizza, fast service (even during lunch when they are really busy) and very clean.”
  8. “Before coming here, I always classified pizza as good or not so good, and never really understood why some people would be so adamant about pizza reviews.”
  9. “must for people looking for the best pizza in NYC”
value
100.0% positive
  1. “Best pizza anywhere and great price!”
  2. “Pizza was affordable and de delicious”
  3. “Stopped here after going to Climate 8 and they have a great over-the-counter price!”
  4. “Pizza was good, owner was friendly and prices were great!”
  5. “You're also getting this superb quality pizza at a cheaper price than what you would pay at these other so called pizzerias.”
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/30/12

Pizza is decent!!!

by gailk84

Popular atmosphere. Pizza is decent! Very like me!!!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/17/12

BEST pizza in NYC, by far

by Briana786

This pizza is beyond amazing. Right amount of cheese, sauce and every other ingredient. If your by penn station/MSG- this is a must g. Got the top 10 BEST pizza restaurants in NYC https://files.nyu.edu/jdy215/public/

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/11/12

Good pizza

by ztwgenwmj

I have had the privilege of finding this little jewel of a pizzeria. The prices are excellent for delivery or carry-out. The pizza quality is quite good given the low budget busting prices. I would recommend this pizzeria as a good pizza with a super value.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/09/11

Great Pizza

by JoeMoralli

I visited NYC for 1 day. I tried Pizza Suprema after searching the internet for good NY style pizza.

Awesome pizza at a good price.

Perfect crust, sauce and toppings.

I had a slice of white pizza and pepperoni pizza for $7.75. Huge slices.

I don't see how this could be improved.

Please keep it up. I will eat here every time I visit NYC.

If a restaurant like this existed in Northern VA, Pizza Hut, Dominos and Papa Johns would immediately be out of business.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/22/11

joannas restaurant

by joannas2001

kdfkllllllllllllllll

The Details on Pizza Suprema

Place Categories:

  • best pizza
  • thin robust crust
  • favorite food
  • great service
  • nice place
  • fresh mozzarella basil
  • like basil mozzarella slice
  • great overthecounter price
  • superb everything
  • flavorful sauce
  • never ever failed pizza suprema
  • fresh mozz
  • fresh twentyfive pies
  • very nice owner
  • great right combination
  • favorite pizzeria
  • always plentifull cheeze
  • delicious regular sicilian slice
  • tasteless most places
  • favorite roman pie layered
  • always very professional management
  • perfect expereince
  • always very professional staff
  • like heaven
  • friendly employees

Message from Pizza Suprema

  • Award Winning Pizza
  • Free Fast Delivery
  • Corporate Deliveries

Located in Midtown, across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden for over 40 years this pizzeria has been owned by the same Italian family since its inception. It is currently rated "One of the Ten Best Pizzas in Midtown" by Gayot and has been rated by the New York Times culinary journalist Ed Levine as "one of the best pizzas in Manhattan." The Village Voice has also rated it "one of the best in NYC." Here Pizza making is taken very seriously. One cannot get chicken wings, hamburgers or anything else but excellent pizza at this establishment. Excellent pizza, with the finest ingedients, including fine imported romano grated cheese from Italy, the highest quality Grande Mozzarella and Plum Tomatoes is used to make a thin crust, well baked pizza in the Old Italian Tradition.

***Rated Highly by Gayot***

Advertisement

Featured In

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement