| ambiance |
100.0% positive |
- “
The ambience charming and welcoming, the staff is above and beyond anything you could ever hope for, and the food is in a class by itself. ”
- “
Seated much quicker than expected, the place had the comfortable feel of a small, New England fishing town and fresh food to match. ”
- “
loved the decor. ”
- “
They create such a great ambiance and the food is not let down. ”
- “
The atmosphere was charming and cozy and we were happy UNTIL we tried the food. ”
- “
The atmosphere is warm and friendly, and although the bar is sometimes crowded, which seems to slow service to the front, (it happened to be on a busy saturday night) i've found the staff knowledgeable and eager to please. ”
- “
The prices and ambience are great as well. ”
- “
but food is great and it's fun. ”
- “
The food is to die for; the staff is warm, welcoming, and well informed, and the atmosphere is cozy and hip. ”
- “
The atmosphere was pleasant and quiet enough for conversation and noisy enough to ensure you weren't being listened to! ”
- “
The service is good and ambience is good for a date or group outing. ”
- “
Loved the suttle nuatical decor. ”
- “
We had a short wait at the bar which was fun because the bartenders were friendly. ”
- “
Overall, a good restaurant - nice atmosphere (a little more West Village than East Village), solid menu, prompt seating and fairly priced. ”
- “
Though the atmosphere is delightful, drawing an attractive over-40 crowd, the service at this East Village newcomer has a lot to be desired. ”
- “
If youre in the mood for a fun, fresh seafood place without any overdone nyc glitz, this place cant be beat. ”
|
| dessert |
100.0% positive |
- “
On the entre side, I very much like the pan roasted codfish with "New England chowder sauce" (basically cream, bacon and clams). ”
- “
My favorite was the chocolate pudding. ”
|
| drinks |
100.0% positive |
- “
Service was friendly, but the food was poorly paced; waited 45 for raw bar/apps, then entree came too soon. ”
- “
The drink menu is also great. ”
- “
white wine we ordered was great as well. ”
- “
Best wine prices in town! ”
- “
We order a bottle of wine and drink 1glass each. ”
- “
The wines were good, try the french rose. ”
- “
The atmosphere is warm and friendly, and although the bar is sometimes crowded, which seems to slow service to the front, (it happened to be on a busy saturday night) i've found the staff knowledgeable and eager to please. ”
- “
Had a nice bottle of wine (german/austrian) name we couldn't pronounce. ”
- “
This is decent bar food but I would not recommend it for dinner in NYC. ”
- “
Plus a nice wine list. ”
- “
Everyone was so friendly from the hostess to the bar to the table. ”
- “
strongly recommend the Lobster Sandwich Combo which includes an incredible Lobster Salad sandwhich on brioche with Old Bay french fries and a Blue Point Toasted Lager beer all for $20. ”
- “
started at the bar with Erin and loved her peppercini Martini. ”
- “
We had a short wait at the bar which was fun because the bartenders were friendly. ”
- “
Examples from the raw bar looked amazingly fresh. ”
- “
Fantastic raw bar, loved the calamari and probably had the best Lobster roll in my life. ”
- “
Food is delicious and the wine is reasonable - a great list, too. ”
- “
As if the 2 hour wait wasn't bad enough, the host/"manager" was so busy flirting with attractive female customers, he didn't seem to notice we had been sitting at the bar and we ended up missing his call. ”
- “
The raw bar sampler appetizer was extremely fresh. ”
- “
There are a selection of nice german and fishermen beers. ”
- “
The wine selection is good with reasonable price. ”
- “
Also, the wine is relatively inexpensive and the list offers many good selections. ”
- “
restaurant with class, professionalism, killer wine list (and prices), and an awesome chef! ”
- “
We had got there and we had to wait for a table - went to the bar and had drinks which were pretty good. ”
- “
Affordable white wine list. ”
- “
We were shocked by how they have priced some great bottles of wine so low. ”
- “
The timing of the food and wine was excellent. ”
|
| food quality |
94.39999580383301% positive |
- “
had the whole fish which was tasty and good, the oysters weren't as fresh as the waitress said it was. ”
- “
Amazing food, great value! ”
- “
The lobster sandwich was so yummy. ”
- “
But even if I had to wait, I would wait for the delicious BBQ shrimp cocktail and oysters, both fresh and fried. ”
- “
Definitely try the fried oysters; the tomato butter is heavenly. ”
- “
great, fresh food restaurant. ”
- “
An otherwise good meal had a bad ending. ”
- “
There are several options as far as seating goes (out front, inside, garden in back, etc.) The service was good and so was the food. ”
- “
Most of us had the spaghetti with salad on top entree which was one of the best meals I've had in ages. ”
- “
Service was outstanding, we were thanked 7 times as we left the place at the end of our meal. ”
- “
If youre in the mood for a fun, fresh seafood place without any overdone nyc glitz, this place cant be beat. ”
- “
Reasonably priced go here for some truly delicious seafood entrees. ”
- “
The lobster sandwich (basically a lobster roll on a hamburger bun) is certainly good, but I can think of a few places (Ed's Lobster Bar comes to mind) that are a little better. ”
- “
Although I did not care for my skate main dish, the appetizers were satisfying and the oysters are a solid choice. ”
- “
w/ scallops/shrimp which replaced my fav dish is subpar and extremely salty. ”
- “
I'd do it all over again because the food was delicious! ”
- “
enjoyed my meal here, it's not great but it is ok. ”
- “
had a delicious whole duraude on a bed of vinagared greens, and lobster mashed potatoes. ”
- “
Mermaid had some of the best food Ive had in a NYC restaurant. ”
- “
was easily able to snag a reservation for dinner on a Wed. night to taste one of the best fish plates I had in a while. ”
- “
The lobster sandwich is good and the spaghetti with Scallops and Shrimp is great. ”
- “
Looking for a great seafood place to end the perfect summer day? ”
- “
An excellent destination for those looking for high quality, creative seafood, without the pretension of some other local fish houses. ”
- “
the seafood was fresh and delicious, I would have to agree on the recommendation for the mussels and the lobster rolls! ”
- “
Good food but noisy room ”
- “
The food was good and creative but our entrees were extremely salty. ”
- “
The staff was great, and the food was even better. ”
- “
The food is really great and the service is fantastic. ”
- “
The shrimp cocktail appetizer was fresh, though there were only four shrimps. ”
- “
and the lobster sandwich though small in size had real big chunks of tasty lobster bits and came with a side of their specialty old bay fries! ”
- “
The food was great. ”
- “
The Mermaid Inn was a greatly needed breath of fresh air. ”
- “
room/garden. A great new place for seafood in the E. Village without attitude. ”
- “
But other than that, incredible food. ”
- “
Otherwise, the lobster sandwich was delicious. ”
- “
would suggest it to anyone who likes superb service and fantastic food. ”
- “
The poblano mashed potatos that accompany the otherwise excellent grilled mahi mahi can be a little heavy, but the dish remains a winner. ”
- “
fresh dinner ”
- “
The lobster roll was great as were the fries, but it came with a $22 price tag. ”
- “
My husband said he could've eaten several more, the portion was fine for me he even exclaimed that the french fries were the best he has had. ”
- “
We had the salmon and the skate sandwich, both of which were outrageously delicious. ”
- “
Mermaid Inn is an overall good restaurant with really good seafood. ”
- “
The skate was juicy and meaty and went perfect with the corn/red onion relish that its served with. ”
- “
Excellent, affordable seafood ”
- “
We had the scallops as an appetizer and they were delicious and the sauce was wonderful. ”
- “
strongly recommend the Lobster Sandwich Combo which includes an incredible Lobster Salad sandwhich on brioche with Old Bay french fries and a Blue Point Toasted Lager beer all for $20. ”
- “
To everyone's surprise, the iceberg lettuce w/ blue cheese appetizer was very tasty. ”
- “
The lobster roll and fries w/ vingear were outstanding and so was the shrimp,scallops in the spagetti. ”
- “
The raw bar sampler appetizer was extremely fresh. ”
- “
The bay fries are terrific--crisp and slim and slightly seasoned, and the pumpkin pudding we had at the end was just the right finish. ”
- “
The skate was tasty and went well with the salad it came with. ”
- “
The lobster roll is great and the mahi mahi with the cold vegetables is so tasty to be so light. ”
- “
and the food is equally as great. ”
- “
Wifey had the skate which was so good, non-fish eaters probably wouldn't realize it was fish. ”
- “
The lobster sandwich was OUTSTANDING! ”
- “
Overall I truly enjoyed this restaurant and do plan to go back whenever I crave some good but simple seafood. ”
- “
Yes, it can be difficult to get a table during peak dinner hours, but if you're willing to come a little early or later in the evening, you will be rewarded with simple, excellent seafood at a very fair price. ”
- “
but food is great and it's fun. ”
- “
We were expecting a hardy amount of made with large lumps of lobester and ended up with a meager serving spread thing of what was more like a lobster spread :( I would definately go back but just to order the fish. ”
- “
The oysters and clams were amazing and at the end the tab was cheap and it came with a fortune fish. ”
- “
Everything was fabulous, from the food to the service to the music. ”
- “
The food is to die for; the staff is warm, welcoming, and well informed, and the atmosphere is cozy and hip. ”
- “
On the entre side, I very much like the pan roasted codfish with "New England chowder sauce" (basically cream, bacon and clams). ”
- “
Yummy food, charming place ”
- “
The timing of the food and wine was excellent. ”
- “
had the grilled salmon with risotto and I literally licked my plate clean. ”
- “
Salmon and risotto was delicious as well as the roasted muscles appitizer! ”
- “
food was good, but i expected better judging from the many rave reviews on this site. ”
- “
The food tastes fantastic- very fresh, very nice combinations of flavors. ”
- “
Good food in an ok setting. ”
- “
The lobster sandwich is amazing! ”
- “
Everything on the menu beckons, so I will have to be making a return trip soon, if only to sample more of the delicious entrees and salads. ”
- “
You better like seafood to some degree before going. ”
- “
Service was friendly, but the food was poorly paced; waited 45 for raw bar/apps, then entree came too soon. ”
- “
Loved the scenery, decent food. ”
- “
The food was delicious. ”
- “
Food is delicious and the wine is reasonable - a great list, too. ”
- “
How can you go wrong with fresh cooked lobster and mayo on a brioche burger bun. ”
- “
awesome seafood, go early. ”
- “
The food was excellent. ”
- “
Every dish we had was unique and delicious. ”
- “
The food is delightful and melts on your mouth. ”
- “
food was great, but the hype? ”
- “
The calamari that we started off with was outstanding and the grilled salmon filet was delish. ”
- “
Definitely recommend the west coast oysters and the rock shrimp balls w/ spicy sauce were ok. ”
- “
The complimentary pudding at the conclusion of the meal is good, sans that gross pudding "skin" on the top. ”
- “
The atmosphere was charming and cozy and we were happy UNTIL we tried the food. ”
- “
the scenery was great, the atomosphere was cute and quiet i opted for the early dinner, the food was great! ”
- “
Portions are a good size and quite tastey seafood. ”
- “
I'm a more red meat eater than seefood, but this is definitely one of the best seafoods I've ever had so far, and the service was memorable. ”
- “
good seafood ”
- “
The ambience charming and welcoming, the staff is above and beyond anything you could ever hope for, and the food is in a class by itself. ”
- “
This is decent bar food but I would not recommend it for dinner in NYC. ”
- “
The oysters were delish and shrimp was average. ”
- “
But most importantly, the food was delicious. ”
- “
took my girlfriend here for her birthday as it is her favorite restaurant in all of Manhattan and after eating the food I could see why. ”
- “
The food was amazing too. ”
- “
The mussels were amazing and for dinner we had the Swordfish and the Lobster salad sandwich, both of which were out of this world. ”
- “
Lobster salad sandwich wasn't bad, but I would wait for the actual New England coast if your really in the mood for it. ”
- “
also like the salmon with spicy corn salad. ”
- “
ordered the Mahi Mahi and the fish was very tasteless and overcooked. ”
- “
Seated much quicker than expected, the place had the comfortable feel of a small, New England fishing town and fresh food to match. ”
- “
She loves seafood, while I'm it's not always my favorite but I really loved what I got. ”
- “
Our lobster rolls were delicious, as usual, as were the Old Bay fries (sigh). ”
- “
Examples from the raw bar looked amazingly fresh. ”
- “
seafood at reasonable price ”
- “
The food is well prepared seafood in a delightful setting, good service and typical prices. ”
- “
Service was alright and food was pretty good too. ”
- “
Dont miss the scallops, grilled salmon that was done to perfection, and the best tomato salad Ive ever had. ”
- “
The lobster sandwiches was also very good. ”
- “
The food was decent and the staff was nice but the gentleman and the door left such a bad taste in our mouths that we would never return. ”
- “
Great food, a little small, but still a great place to go to. ”
- “
Great place & seafood ”
- “
The crabcakes and little neck clams were absolutely delicious. ”
- “
They create such a great ambiance and the food is not let down. ”
- “
Even though its good seafood, the prices are too high. ”
- “
the codfish was decent and fresh (the reduction was especially interesting), but i found the white flesh slightly bland, though the skin was seasoned to perfection. ”
- “
Our friend had the grilled dorade and felt it was too boney (obviously not restaurant's fault - stupid fish). ”
- “
The tasty shrimp soup Veracruzano is a spicy tomato/seafood broth studded with plump shrimp and served with grilled bread. ”
|
| menu variety |
100.0% positive |
- “
Everything on the menu beckons, so I will have to be making a return trip soon, if only to sample more of the delicious entrees and salads. ”
- “
There are a selection of nice german and fishermen beers. ”
- “
Small menu but everything we had was excellent. ”
- “
The drink menu is also great. ”
- “
but the menu is great. ”
- “
Overall, a good restaurant - nice atmosphere (a little more West Village than East Village), solid menu, prompt seating and fairly priced. ”
- “
Limited menu but they all sounded good and interesting. ”
- “
There are several options as far as seating goes (out front, inside, garden in back, etc.) The service was good and so was the food. ”
- “
The wine selection is good with reasonable price. ”
- “
Also, the wine is relatively inexpensive and the list offers many good selections. ”
- “
Pinot Grigio was our selection and the whole bottle was well enjoyed. ”
|
| overall |
100.0% positive |
- “
Me and my boyfriend went there last Friday 'coz we read how great the restaurant was on citysearch. ”
- “
Anyway, an overall nice place and especially good if you want to take out your parents in the East Village. ”
- “
room/garden. A great new place for seafood in the E. Village without attitude. ”
- “
Visited The Mermaid this weekend with some friends and decided this is our new favorite east village restaurant. ”
- “
Mermaid had some of the best food Ive had in a NYC restaurant. ”
- “
took my girlfriend here for her birthday as it is her favorite restaurant in all of Manhattan and after eating the food I could see why. ”
- “
Looking for a great seafood place to end the perfect summer day? ”
- “
Very nice place, looked it up on CitySearch and went there after shopping with the wife one night. ”
- “
Great food, a little small, but still a great place to go to. ”
|
| return potential |
93.33000183105469% positive |
- “
Overall I truly enjoyed this restaurant and do plan to go back whenever I crave some good but simple seafood. ”
- “
The food was decent and the staff was nice but the gentleman and the door left such a bad taste in our mouths that we would never return. ”
- “
We were expecting a hardy amount of made with large lumps of lobester and ended up with a meager serving spread thing of what was more like a lobster spread :( I would definately go back but just to order the fish. ”
- “
Everything on the menu beckons, so I will have to be making a return trip soon, if only to sample more of the delicious entrees and salads. ”
- “
All in all a wonderful experience, can't wait to come back. ”
|
| service |
91.84000015258789% positive |
- “
The waitstaff was so friendly and accomodating. ”
- “
would suggest it to anyone who likes superb service and fantastic food. ”
- “
The food is really great and the service is fantastic. ”
- “
friendly waitstaff. ”
- “
There are several options as far as seating goes (out front, inside, garden in back, etc.) The service was good and so was the food. ”
- “
And the staff is very friendly and accomodating. ”
- “
We had a short wait at the bar which was fun because the bartenders were friendly. ”
- “
The service is good and ambience is good for a date or group outing. ”
- “
This place is great, atmoshere wonderful, staff is amazing. ”
- “
Everyone I talked to from the host to our waitress was helpful and friendly. ”
- “
Great new place that really cares about service. ”
- “
Our waiter Chad was adorable, I haven't had a staff nearly as friendly in a while. ”
- “
great service! ”
- “
The atmosphere is warm and friendly, and although the bar is sometimes crowded, which seems to slow service to the front, (it happened to be on a busy saturday night) i've found the staff knowledgeable and eager to please. ”
- “
The food is to die for; the staff is warm, welcoming, and well informed, and the atmosphere is cozy and hip. ”
- “
Good service, decent prices. ”
- “
Everyone was so friendly from the hostess to the bar to the table. ”
- “
Staff was friendly and followed up to make sure we enjoyed our experience. ”
- “
The staff was great, and the food was even better. ”
- “
Wait-staff is knowledgeable and attentive, and is not afraid to make a recommendation. ”
- “
Though a little slow (it was fairly busy), the waitstaff was friendly and got everything right. ”
- “
Outstanding service ”
- “
eat out all the time and never have I come across such a friendly and knowledgeable staff. ”
- “
I'm a more red meat eater than seefood, but this is definitely one of the best seafoods I've ever had so far, and the service was memorable. ”
- “
The food is well prepared seafood in a delightful setting, good service and typical prices. ”
- “
had the whole fish which was tasty and good, the oysters weren't as fresh as the waitress said it was. ”
- “
The service was superb I'll definately be coming back here. ”
- “
While the no reservations policy is hard, the wait wasn't too bad and the service was friendly. ”
- “
Service was friendly, helpful and never pushy. ”
- “
The service is excellent: friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient. ”
- “
our server was really great and attentive when she could be, but it was busy. ”
- “
Wonderful attentive wait staff and hostesses. ”
- “
The food was decent and the staff was nice but the gentleman and the door left such a bad taste in our mouths that we would never return. ”
- “
In a city largely lacking good service outside of high-end restaurants, this is noticeable in and of itself. ”
- “
I'd rather tip him than the server since he was the only person who took a good care of us. ”
- “
The ambience charming and welcoming, the staff is above and beyond anything you could ever hope for, and the food is in a class by itself. ”
- “
Our waitress was nice and it was almost a perfect evening for us. ”
- “
The staff was knowledgeable and full of personality. ”
- “
The service was impeccable! ”
- “
Service was friendly, but the food was poorly paced; waited 45 for raw bar/apps, then entree came too soon. ”
- “
Everything was fabulous, from the food to the service to the music. ”
- “
The music was also amazing, and even though it was a crowded Friday night, the servers were attentive and friendly. ”
- “
Though the atmosphere is delightful, drawing an attractive over-40 crowd, the service at this East Village newcomer has a lot to be desired. ”
- “
As if the 2 hour wait wasn't bad enough, the host/"manager" was so busy flirting with attractive female customers, he didn't seem to notice we had been sitting at the bar and we ended up missing his call. ”
- “
The waiter was very friendly and informative. ”
- “
Horrible service ”
- “
very pleasant hostess took my name and cell number and told me she'd call (wow, very rare in nyc) once they had a table ready. ”
|
| value |
94.73999977111816% positive |
- “
And the cod was a huge hit too. ”
- “
seafood at reasonable price ”
- “
Wine list is small and overpriced but the bubbly by the glass was pretty good. ”
- “
The food is well prepared seafood in a delightful setting, good service and typical prices. ”
- “
Excellent, affordable seafood ”
- “
The lobster roll was great as were the fries, but it came with a $22 price tag. ”
- “
Best wine prices in town! ”
- “
Good service, decent prices. ”
- “
Yes, it can be difficult to get a table during peak dinner hours, but if you're willing to come a little early or later in the evening, you will be rewarded with simple, excellent seafood at a very fair price. ”
- “
The oysters and clams were amazing and at the end the tab was cheap and it came with a fortune fish. ”
- “
wasn't a huge fan of the sardine appetizer ”
- “
The reasonable prices are what you'd expect to pay at this type of place, but it's not outstanding by any means. ”
- “
The prices and ambience are great as well. ”
- “
Amazing food, great value! ”
- “
Overall great experience for the price (entrees hovered around ~$19). ”
- “
Even though its good seafood, the prices are too high. ”
- “
The wine selection is good with reasonable price. ”
- “
Also, the wine is relatively inexpensive and the list offers many good selections. ”
- “
restaurant with class, professionalism, killer wine list (and prices), and an awesome chef! ”
|
| wait time |
90.0% positive |
- “
Though a little slow (it was fairly busy), the waitstaff was friendly and got everything right. ”
- “
best lobster roll we've had in a long time. ”
- “
Not more then five minutes came the catsup, cold plates and warm buns. ”
- “
The Mermaid Inn is one of the best restaurants I have been to in a long while. ”
- “
The atmosphere is warm and friendly, and although the bar is sometimes crowded, which seems to slow service to the front, (it happened to be on a busy saturday night) i've found the staff knowledgeable and eager to please. ”
|
Deals
share
@themermaidnyc | Facebook |