| ambiance |
91.23000144958496% positive |
- “
The menu looked great and the atmosphere is rustic and inviting, but the communal tables can be the worst. ”
- “
The service was good and the overall ambience was very cozy (candle lit, brick walls, etc.) ”
- “
The food was great, the ambience was simple but romantic and I will be back for more very soon. ”
- “
Cozy, warm atmosphere, super comforting dishes, and reasonably priced. ”
- “
hope they continue to improve because the space was cozy, the food good and the experience wholyl enjoyable! ”
- “
Supper is a lovely place: good ambiance, cute communal tables and delicious inexpensive food. ”
- “
That said though, the service was good and the atmosphere as well ”
- “
We were a group of ten and were seated in the back of this very cozy dining room right next to a pretty walk in wine cellar. ”
- “
The place itself ought to have had a great atmosphere as the decor is cool and you feel the buzz as you walk in, however, we were stuck on a table in the back room (even though we were there before 7) which was a bit disappointing. ”
- “
Cozy atmosphere and great food ”
- “
really cozy, romantic, dim. ”
- “
The food and decor are excellent, though service was somewhat poor. ”
- “
SUCH good atmosphere. ”
- “
good food, good atmosphere ”
- “
The atmosphere was perfect for our group and we enjoyed the group seated next to us. ”
- “
Following dinner we headed back up to the bar and had an awesome evening with the extremely fun and friendly staff. ”
- “
love the staff, I love the ambience The staff is often griped about but I find them lovely. ”
- “
cozy, good food, but heinous hostess ”
- “
The atmosphere was great. ”
|
| dessert |
100.0% positive |
- “
Dishes such as pesto, spinach gnocchi with garlic cream and lemon spaghetti are excellent. ”
- “
the service was reasonably good, and the food was yummy (apps, entrees AND dessert). ”
- “
The desserts were awesome, we got this chocolate thing and our server came to the table with a pot of hot chocolate and poured it on from really high. ”
- “
The "by consumption" wine list is a brilliant concept as it means you drink as much as you want without the dilemma of whether to order a second bottle when you're just getting to your dessert. ”
- “
The food is fantastic -- from appetizers (try the grilled asparaus & grilled polenta w/ parmesan) to entree to dessert (awesome tirimisu). ”
|
| drinks |
91.66999816894531% positive |
- “
The wines are very good too and not too expensive. ”
- “
Following dinner we headed back up to the bar and had an awesome evening with the extremely fun and friendly staff. ”
- “
If you have a nice bottle of wine, dinner for 2 is easily $100. ”
- “
We went a little before 8 and were told to wait in the bar next door - the bartender could not have been nicer - the wine was excellent and we had a little appetizer before going to the main restaurant. ”
- “
We walked through the wine cellar and through this door in a BEAUTIFUL private room. ”
- “
If you have to wait, the wine bar is a great experience. ”
- “
We went to Supper's bar, located next door, a quaint, dimly lit east village bar, very cool, yet very crowded. ”
- “
Waited an hour and a half in the wine bar (wine bar was great). ”
- “
The food is great & very affordable the staff is so accomodating & the wine selection is huge. ”
- “
The food is very good, and I love the extensive wine list, especially the half-bottles. ”
- “
The bar next door is small, but if you are being served by the great gorgeous bartender Wade, you'll get a drink quickly and topped up regularly and you will be totally taken care of. ”
- “
The wine list is incredible, the food is incredible. ”
- “
Front section of the restaurant has a lighter feel with 4 outdoor tables, and a bar table to observe cooks making your meal, very cool. ”
- “
The bartender was fabulous, and not snobby, like many other "wine experts. ”
- “
The wait can be terrible and the bar next door is extremely crowded. ”
- “
The "by consumption" wine list is a brilliant concept as it means you drink as much as you want without the dilemma of whether to order a second bottle when you're just getting to your dessert. ”
- “
I've not had too many problems geting a table and the staff have always been really helpful in getting us from the next door bar or phoning us when the table's ready. ”
- “
However, you can spend time in the nice wine bar next door. ”
- “
The bar next door that the door people suggest waiting in is cramped and uncomfortable but the bartender was nice and the wine was reasonable. ”
- “
We all felt it was a good value for the money, so much so that we went next door to the wine bar area to have another bottle or two of bubbly before heading out. ”
- “
We were a group of ten and were seated in the back of this very cozy dining room right next to a pretty walk in wine cellar. ”
- “
I've been to Supper before, but never knew they had a back room and this huge, beautiful wine cellar. ”
- “
Leave about a 1/2 hour of wait time in on a weekend night and ask your server to recommend the wine. ”
- “
$45 a head with tip for bad gnocchi, mediocre wine (as recommended by a condescending waiter, who thought himself oh-so-nice) and the feeling that our companions (at our shared table) were listening in on all our chatter. ”
|
| food quality |
93.33000183105469% positive |
- “
will be bringing everyone I know here from now on - the service was excellent and the food even better. ”
- “
Everything is delicious and you can't beat the prices. ”
- “
All the dishes we got were perfect portions. ”
- “
The food is very good, and I love the extensive wine list, especially the half-bottles. ”
- “
Cozy, warm atmosphere, super comforting dishes, and reasonably priced. ”
- “
The menu was difficult to decipher, but most importantly, I suppose, the food was good. ”
- “
DINNER: service was acceptable and the food good (not superb, but decent). ”
- “
have been to Supper countless times since it opened and while I've waited and it's been crowded, the food has always been so good that I didn't really care. ”
- “
went with my party of six and waited for an hour and half in anticipation of some very yummy yet reasonable dishes. ”
- “
Simply beautiful food. ”
- “
Supper is a lovely place: good ambiance, cute communal tables and delicious inexpensive food. ”
- “
The food was great, the ambience was simple but romantic and I will be back for more very soon. ”
- “
Still great food, Still great service, Still love it! ”
- “
The food is great and the prices are even better. ”
- “
had the mozzarella and tomato salad which was really fresh and delicious and then the gnocchi afterwards - real comfort food! ”
- “
This place, along with Frank, is a typical overrated, overhyped trendy place that serves bored italian food by bored looking waitstaff. ”
- “
love the food at Supper, but the service sucks. ”
- “
Great pasta, great meat. ”
- “
Definitely not the spot for people who don't like to dine in close-quarters, but the food is amazing for the $$, some of the best in NYC! ”
- “
THe food there is amazing. ”
- “
The food was great - nothing too fancy or flashy, just really tasty food with a "home cooked" feel. ”
- “
The food is fresh and authentic Italian and the portions are great for the price. ”
- “
The wine list is incredible, the food is incredible. ”
- “
Cozy atmosphere and great food ”
- “
The french toast is AMAZING. ”
- “
The salad (beet) was fresh - simple - needed more cheese. ”
- “
good food, good atmosphere ”
- “
Pasta - spaghetti with lemon and parmesan was delicious. ”
- “
almost any pasta dish is good and a great value - real quality ingredients and healthy portions. ”
- “
Their fresh mozzarella is some of the best I've ever had. ”
- “
We came here hearing it was a hip spot with a reasonable price and yummy food. ”
- “
No other restaurant has so many simple wonderful fresh vegetables. ”
- “
I've only eaten here once; the bread is delicious - warm, rustic, bread charred on the outside served with oil and olives. ”
- “
Front section of the restaurant has a lighter feel with 4 outdoor tables, and a bar table to observe cooks making your meal, very cool. ”
- “
The food was good, but I don't care how popular a place is, I don't want to be made to feel like a fool or that I'm not special enough to be there. ”
- “
The calamari is fantastic, the meat special no matter what it is is always delicious and the lasagna is irresistable. ”
- “
The panzanella, which used to be one of my favorite dishes, was so salty we couldn't eat it. ”
- “
This place has the most wonderful authentic meals. ”
- “
Cool place with tasty dishes ”
- “
Great food, great value ”
- “
The food is always fantastic and plenty of it - I always leave with a doggy bag. ”
- “
The food is very good (especially the Veal Milanese which is one of the best in town). ”
- “
The food is fantastic -- from appetizers (try the grilled asparaus & grilled polenta w/ parmesan) to entree to dessert (awesome tirimisu). ”
- “
The food was affordable and tasty. ”
- “
Having lived in Rome, I know what they served us was NOT Italian food, not even a poor substitute. ”
- “
The dishes were also tasty. ”
- “
My friend got the pasta with dad's marinara sauce with ricotta which was awesome. ”
- “
The food is great & very affordable the staff is so accomodating & the wine selection is huge. ”
- “
The daily specials are especially good, and try the minimalist homemade fettucine dishes. ”
- “
hope they continue to improve because the space was cozy, the food good and the experience wholyl enjoyable! ”
- “
oh, and the chicken cutlet special on thursdays is really yummy. ”
- “
The appetizers were delicious! ”
- “
The food and decor are excellent, though service was somewhat poor. ”
- “
Good food, Poor service ”
- “
the service was reasonably good, and the food was yummy (apps, entrees AND dessert). ”
- “
the beet salad and the bread salad app (can't ever remember the name of the bread salad) are always great. ”
- “
The food is consistently very good, service is fine for a busy restaurant and the price is right. ”
- “
the place had 4 empty tables that i could see (7pm - sunday) i've run a similarly priced place in san fran in the past and the food wasnt to our reasonable standards, staff couldnt get past initial interview. ”
- “
cozy, good food, but heinous hostess ”
- “
The food was average at best and you can get the same at any cheapy mediocre italian in the city. ”
- “
The daily specials are always very tempting and the appetizers are great especially the mushroom trifolati. ”
- “
Nonetheless the tasty Italian food makes up for it. ”
- “
for appetizers our favorites were the fresh mozzarella which is not to be missed, the bruschetta was melt in your mouth delicious and the polenta was so good that everyne was fighting over it! ”
- “
Cozy spot, amazing food! ”
- “
The polenta is amazing, the brunches are incredible (the French toast is to die for) I have all my birthdays and get-togethers at Supper and each time they treat me and my friends better than the last. ”
|
| menu variety |
78.5699987411499% positive |
- “
The food is very good, and I love the extensive wine list, especially the half-bottles. ”
- “
My only complaint is that the waiter added a 20% tip to bill (despite there being no mention of this on the menu, etc.,), didn't tell us about it (hoping it'd slip past us as it sometimes happens in big parties). ”
- “
The food is great & very affordable the staff is so accomodating & the wine selection is huge. ”
- “
The menu was difficult to decipher, but most importantly, I suppose, the food was good. ”
- “
The menu looked great and the atmosphere is rustic and inviting, but the communal tables can be the worst. ”
- “
Don't want to lambast the whole restaurant, my friend liked his entree, but if a restaurant would consider having a tasteless entree on its menu as what i got, then i wouldn't be too keen on the other entrees. ”
- “
we left, too bad because the menu looked great. ”
|
| overall |
100.0% positive |
- “
great place for a great night ”
- “
The food was good, but I don't care how popular a place is, I don't want to be made to feel like a fool or that I'm not special enough to be there. ”
- “
pretty good place ”
- “
If you don't want a piece of Manhattan, stay in Bayridge so the rest of us can enjoy this great East Village restaurant. ”
- “
It's just a great place to have dinner. ”
- “
Maybe a good place to test a potential mate, but no longer a good place to eat. ”
- “
Supper is a great place for a great night. ”
- “
Supper is a great place. ”
- “
And then you hear Coldplay, which is great yet having the occurring thought this is out of place. ”
|
| return potential |
66.66999816894531% positive |
- “
The food was great, the ambience was simple but romantic and I will be back for more very soon. ”
- “
would never go back with such an obnoxious waiter. ”
- “
Love this place, will def be back. ”
|
| service |
73.86000156402588% positive |
- “
was here recently with 6 others: BAR: The bartender was EXCELLENT--extremely knowledgeable and friendly (unfortunately, I can't remember her name). ”
- “
Hmm- no thanks, so we sat awkwardly, and the table service was about as good as the service the host offered. ”
- “
The desserts were awesome, we got this chocolate thing and our server came to the table with a pot of hot chocolate and poured it on from really high. ”
- “
The hostess was so rude I wanted to leave right away. ”
- “
I've not had too many problems geting a table and the staff have always been really helpful in getting us from the next door bar or phoning us when the table's ready. ”
- “
This place had some of the best Risotto I've ever had AND the waitress was very friendly and attentive! ”
- “
regular cross town haunt for me due to the value it offers in a great friendly environment. ”
- “
My only complaint is that the waiter added a 20% tip to bill (despite there being no mention of this on the menu, etc.,), didn't tell us about it (hoping it'd slip past us as it sometimes happens in big parties). ”
- “
will be bringing everyone I know here from now on - the service was excellent and the food even better. ”
- “
don't usually go there over the weekends or during prime dinner hours--but for a weekday dinner it's great, and I've never had any problems with crowds, waiting, or bad service. ”
- “
Leave about a 1/2 hour of wait time in on a weekend night and ask your server to recommend the wine. ”
- “
you can watch everything they do from making tomorrow's stock to sauteeing your veal) to the big portions to the laid back service and good prices. ”
- “
That said though, the service was good and the atmosphere as well ”
- “
DINNER: service was acceptable and the food good (not superb, but decent). ”
- “
Our dinner on a January Monday was enjoyable, but would have been better if she had offered a warmer greeting than a snarl, and had allowed us to sit in one of the booths rather than at a tiny table for 1.5 people. ”
- “
Our waiter had poor service and was rude during our stay. ”
- “
the service is always a bit stiff but typically prompt - they have good timing (don't you hate it when your entree arrives immediately after or, worse, right over top of your appetizer?) ”
- “
The food is consistently very good, service is fine for a busy restaurant and the price is right. ”
- “
Definitely not the spot for people who don't like to dine in close-quarters, but the food is amazing for the $$, some of the best in NYC! ”
- “
At 7pm, 3 of our party had not yet arrived, but at 7:05, the hostess seated us anyway which I thought was really nice considering they are very explicit about their 10 minute table hold policy. ”
- “
The bar next door is small, but if you are being served by the great gorgeous bartender Wade, you'll get a drink quickly and topped up regularly and you will be totally taken care of. ”
- “
The male host was completely obnoxious and his idea of announcing who's next on the list is to scream out people's names. ”
- “
The food and decor are excellent, though service was somewhat poor. ”
- “
love the food at Supper, but the service sucks. ”
- “
Our waitress was really nice - friendly and helpful and kept an eye on us without being intrusive however the same can't be said for the guys who topped up the water and cleared the plates. ”
- “
they don't take reservations - if you're having a big group of people out for a birthday - be decent and book somewhere else for your friend instead of being a cheap a@s and then complaining about waiting on a Saturday night in the East Village as one of ”
- “
The service was excellent and very well timed. ”
- “
The food is great & very affordable the staff is so accomodating & the wine selection is huge. ”
- “
Still great food, Still great service, Still love it! ”
- “
The service was good and the overall ambience was very cozy (candle lit, brick walls, etc.) ”
- “
Everyone is so rude I can barely stand it. ”
- “
The service is generally very good although be warned they don't take reservations and on Friday and Saturday nights it can get pretty crowded. ”
- “
the place had 4 empty tables that i could see (7pm - sunday) i've run a similarly priced place in san fran in the past and the food wasnt to our reasonable standards, staff couldnt get past initial interview. ”
- “
The bar next door that the door people suggest waiting in is cramped and uncomfortable but the bartender was nice and the wine was reasonable. ”
- “
THIS PLACE HAS AWFUL, AWFUL, AWFUL service by any standard. ”
- “
love the staff, I love the ambience The staff is often griped about but I find them lovely. ”
- “
bad service, big price tag ”
- “
Following dinner we headed back up to the bar and had an awesome evening with the extremely fun and friendly staff. ”
- “
The service, unfortunately, was a bit obnoxious: my date and I were interrupted too many times by the waitress (who was probably just trying to be attentive, but there is something as a little too much attention) and later the bus boy, who kept on trying ”
- “
cozy, good food, but heinous hostess ”
- “
the service was reasonably good, and the food was yummy (apps, entrees AND dessert). ”
- “
Would try again - hoping the poor service was specific to the waitress and not the establishment. ”
- “
The bartender was fabulous, and not snobby, like many other "wine experts. ”
- “
We went a little before 8 and were told to wait in the bar next door - the bartender could not have been nicer - the wine was excellent and we had a little appetizer before going to the main restaurant. ”
- “
Hoping, praying this time it would be decent service- NO SUCH LUCK. ”
- “
The waitress didn't even bother picking up the fork she pushed over from our table (she knew she did it, but just walked away). ”
- “
would never go back with such an obnoxious waiter. ”
- “
It was a bit chilly due to cold breeze from outside whenever anyone came inside but it warmed up as the table filled up (with 6 people). ”
- “
Good food, Poor service ”
- “
$45 a head with tip for bad gnocchi, mediocre wine (as recommended by a condescending waiter, who thought himself oh-so-nice) and the feeling that our companions (at our shared table) were listening in on all our chatter. ”
- “
The waitress was on her own terms, though the other staff were polite. ”
|
| value |
97.82999992370605% positive |
- “
The wines are very good too and not too expensive. ”
- “
We came here hearing it was a hip spot with a reasonable price and yummy food. ”
- “
The food is great and the prices are even better. ”
- “
almost any pasta dish is good and a great value - real quality ingredients and healthy portions. ”
- “
For $10 a plate, Supper and Bar Pitti are the best deals in town. ”
- “
bad service, big price tag ”
- “
In a city with expensive, over rated dining, this place is a gem! ”
- “
good value ”
- “
Great food, great value ”
- “
they don't take reservations - if you're having a big group of people out for a birthday - be decent and book somewhere else for your friend instead of being a cheap a@s and then complaining about waiting on a Saturday night in the East Village as one of ”
- “
Everything is delicious and you can't beat the prices. ”
- “
Dishes are under $15 and the portions (with the exception of ravioli which was good but left me hungry) are good. ”
- “
The food was affordable and tasty. ”
- “
The food is great & very affordable the staff is so accomodating & the wine selection is huge. ”
- “
The food is fresh and authentic Italian and the portions are great for the price. ”
- “
The food is consistently very good, service is fine for a busy restaurant and the price is right. ”
- “
I've been to Supper before, but never knew they had a back room and this huge, beautiful wine cellar. ”
- “
you can watch everything they do from making tomorrow's stock to sauteeing your veal) to the big portions to the laid back service and good prices. ”
- “
All the dishes we got were perfect portions. ”
- “
Supper is a lovely place: good ambiance, cute communal tables and delicious inexpensive food. ”
- “
regular cross town haunt for me due to the value it offers in a great friendly environment. ”
- “
find the prices very affordable. ”
- “
We all felt it was a good value for the money, so much so that we went next door to the wine bar area to have another bottle or two of bubbly before heading out. ”
|
| wait time |
100.0% positive |
- “
At 7pm, 3 of our party had not yet arrived, but at 7:05, the hostess seated us anyway which I thought was really nice considering they are very explicit about their 10 minute table hold policy. ”
|
Deals
share
