(212) 475-4977

124 4th Ave
New York, NY 10003 40.7332 -73.9901

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Greenwich Village, Downtown

PINTAILESPIZZA.COM

Price:

$

Last updated 8.16.11

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Cash, Visa, Discover, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Family-Friendly Dining, Family Style Dining, Group Dining, Cheap Eats

General Info:

Open 7 Days

Cuisine:

Pizza, Italian

Editor's Tips

What People Are Saying About Pie

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

The Scene – The clean, curvaceous pop design distinguishes this narrow, brightly lit pizza joint. The room is dominated by a counter showcasing the day's fresh pizzas, which a bevy of young servers cut to order with scissors and sell by the pound. The restaurant's dearth of tables makes delivery an appealing option. – – The Food – Pie takes a liberal approach to pizza, concocting a vast assortment of pies with toppings ranging from traditional to interesting--prosciutto and ricotta--to downright strange: potato chips and walnuts, or whole eggs. Experimentation is a…

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
The kitchen turns out all sorts of surprises--lemon-broccoli pizza, anyone?-- which you may miss by ordering off the delivery menu, rather than coming in and checking out the options. Be sure to ask your server about them.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. “This place has a somewhat fun vibe to it, compared with many other places that serve pizza.”
  2. “Great Pizza in a fun clean space.”
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. “Loved the dessert pizza.”
food quality
92.8600025177002% positive
  1. “Loved the dessert pizza.”
  2. “Very inventive, love the Nutella pizza.”
  3. “Really good pizza.”
  4. “and so much nicer than the normal dirty old pizza place.”
  5. “What great pizza!”
  6. “Pie has good pizza for slightly more than you would pay at a traditional pizzaria.”
  7. “Brunch pizza with eggs and bacon is delicious.”
  8. “those portabello mushrooms look so tasty on the pizza.”
  9. “My favorite is the pepperoni pizza.”
  10. “The pizza is so addictive- i just love it!”
  11. “Also, they serve up a great variety of combinations that one might not normally see, and the pizza is pretty good too; however, the fact that they put your slice of pizza on a scale to determine its weight goes a bit too far, and also results in paying a ”
  12. “got some really good mushroom pizza last night they have tons of variations.”
  13. “Yeah, the thin crust pizza is very tasty, but the whole "snip and weigh" thing is a bit too precious.”
  14. “This place has a somewhat fun vibe to it, compared with many other places that serve pizza.”
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. “Also, they serve up a great variety of combinations that one might not normally see, and the pizza is pretty good too; however, the fact that they put your slice of pizza on a scale to determine its weight goes a bit too far, and also results in paying a ”
  2. “Great thin crust, with lots of choices for toppings.”
overall
0.0% positive
  1. “and so much nicer than the normal dirty old pizza place.”
service
100.0% positive
  1. “the people that work there are really friendly.”
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/27/10

was there last night

by anibioman at Citysearch

i got some really good mushroom pizza last night they have tons of variations. its really cool. the people that work there are really friendly. me and my friends really liked it and its really close to union square so thats cool too.

  • Pros: great atmosphere
  • Cons: kinnda expensive
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/10/08

Yumm-o

by charliechuch at Citysearch

This place is sooo good! I love that i can pick diff. types of pizza w/o being a complete hog. You can have a bit of this and a bit of that...brilliant! The pizza is so addictive- i just love it! It is thinner than the typical slice so you don't feel weighed down after which is always a plus.

  • Pros: Delicious pizza and you can taste all diff. kinds
  • Cons: There aren't enough locations. Random craving and inconvenient times
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/17/06

Great Pizza in a fun clean space.

by dzan at Citysearch

Really good pizza...and so much nicer than the normal dirty old pizza place...If you haven't been you should GO...sometimes the place can be a bit noisy...but the food makes up for it! My favorite is the pepperoni pizza...but next trip I'm trying the mushroom...those portabello mushrooms look so tasty on the pizza...not so sure about the bacon and egg pizza...but looks interesting...I am always amazed at what other people eat here...there is a potato chip pizza...a strawberry with chocolate pie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I wish they had arrugula and proscuitto...

There is artwork on the walls...I live in Brooklyn but am in the Union Square area often and stop by to get my fix. Maybe they'll open a PIE in Fort Greene(hint hint)...

  • Pros: Good...Great Pizza
  • Cons: a bit noisy...
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/18/06

Great Pizza

by bayridgegal at Citysearch

Love this place. There is a great selection and I think it is more affordable than pizzerias who charge by the slice. The retro/funky design is cool. We always stop by when we are in the neighborhood.

3 Star Rating: Average

07/28/04

One More Pizza Place

by nevedovsky at Citysearch

This place has a somewhat fun vibe to it, compared with many other places that serve pizza. Also, they serve up a great variety of combinations that one might not normally see, and the pizza is pretty good too; however, the fact that they put your slice of pizza on a scale to determine its weight goes a bit too far, and also results in paying a bit of a premium for a slice of pizza which, while good, does not merit paying more than one would pay at most places. Give it a try if you're up for a change of pace, but overall, there are better deals.

  • Pros: Fun, Imaginative

The Details on Pie

Place Categories:

  • good mushroom pizza
  • love place
  • cool retrofunky design
  • dirty old pizza place
  • delicious brunch pizza
  • somewhat fun vibe
  • best neopolitan
  • loved dessert pizza
  • love nutella pizza
  • great thin crust
  • favorite pepperoni pizza
  • fast delivery
  • tasty portabello mushrooms
  • cool square
  • great pizzeria
  • very tasty thin crust pizza
  • great variety
  • clean great pizza
  • really friendly people