Best of Citysearch
Add a Photo
- Neighborhoods:
- Midtown, Kips Bay
- Categories:
- Restaurants
- Cuisine:
- Traditional American, Cheesesteak, Steakhouse
- Restaurant Special Features:
- Payment Methods:
View Less
At a Glance
?
100% ambiance
“The bread is fresh, i've never had a problem with the meat, and they replicate the atmosphere of a philly place.”
76% food quality
“The meat is subpar and dry, the onions are too large and overcooked, and they are skimpy on the cheese wiz.”
100% overall
“But really the best steaks ever are at a tiny place in Manayunk and i can't remember the name.”
79% service
“While your there, have a chat with the always friendly staff as a good cheese steak takes a moment to prepare.”
83% value
“The meat is too dry, they have a huge pile of meat on the grill and wedge you off a slab when you order.”
100% wait time
“Not only are the cheesesteaks fantastic, but the service is quick and friendly.”
Write a Tip for
Carl's Steaks
What Our Expert Scouts Say
January 23, 2013
Of all New York's cheesesteak imports, Carl's tries harder for true Philly authenticity than any of its rivals, and succeeds. It's the most Philly-like cheesesteak in town. But that doesn't make it the best.
0
Heart
Tips for Carl's Steaks
October 26, 2007
I HEART Carls Steaks!!. This is the best cheesesteak in NY hands down!! I go to Philly pretty frequently and must get a cheesesteak when Im there (therefore I definetly know when I have a good or bad cheesesteak! ) Most places do not know how to make an authentic Philly cheeseteak, but Carl has perfected it!! From the meat to the bread, and lets not forget the option to have cheese whiz or white cheese mmmm. I work 30+ blocks from their location and Ive gone there a few times on my lunch break..(a serious mission huh?..LOL) I love the fact that it stays open late on the weekends so if you're hanging out partying and get the munchies this is a good place to go.
0
Heart
June 27, 2007
Best cheesesteak sandwich in manhattan@. I simply LOVE this place! Their cheese steak is sooo juicy and delicious. They have 3 different types of cheese to top it off. Also a choice of with or without onions. The service is so speedy and fast and by the time I place my order its almost ready. The staff is friendly and attentive which I appreciate esp during busy lunch hour. The sandwichs hold a generous portion of steak on top of thick bread. Def the best place to get a cheese steak by far in the city!
0
Heart
June 06, 2007
Can't talk, eating.
Make no mistake, Carl's has the best Philly cheese steak in NYC. If you are into Jim's of South Street in Philly, this is as close as you are going to get in the big apple. Sometimes I sit around just dreaming of my next Carl's cheese steaks and the cab ride there and back are certainly cheaper and faster than going all the way to Philly. While your there, have a chat with the always friendly staff as a good cheese steak takes a moment to prepare. Try the Carl's at Yankee's stadium too.
WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR!??!??
P.S. Get the fries. Put them on your sandwich. Yeah, that's nice.
0
Heart
February 02, 2007
philly native in NYC- Best in NYC. having moved from philly 10 years ago and living in nyc, i was very happy to see Carl's open up. It is by far the best philly cheesesteak in manhattan. the bread - perfect, the meat- perfect, the whiz.....perfect and of course the grease....perfect.
0
Heart
November 17, 2006
Best cheesesteaks in nyc. These cheesesteaks are made the way the were supposed to be made: sloppy, greasy, tasty, and with tons of meat. Carl's does a killer job of replicating Philly steaks, and offers both Wiz and provolone. The fries are not half bad as well. The only downside is if you eat there (this means if you somehow manage to find a spot), you will walk out smelling like a human cheesesteak. You've been warned.
0
Heart
August 06, 2006
Best NYC has to offer. SO. I'm from Philly. I've eaten tons of my share of steaks from Pat's, Geno's, and Jim's (which, quite frankly, is terrible.) But really the best steaks ever are at a tiny place in Manayunk and i can't remember the name. ANYWAY. Carl's is the best NYC has to offer. Not quite a Philly cheesesteak, but the best i've had here, and i've been searching NYC's cheesesteak scene for several years. The bread is fresh, i've never had a problem with the meat, and they replicate the atmosphere of a philly place. (this goes for the place in east midtown. i've never been in the one on chambers st.) greasy, good, get it with the whiz if u wanna be a true philadelphian. and no matter how Wogie's advertises their bar and cheesesteaks, don't be fooled. there is nothing philly about wogie's. If anyone ever finds an OUTSTANDING cheesesteak in NYC, let me know!!!
0
Heart
January 23, 2006
Not Ready for Prime Time. This may be the best in NYC but Philly has nothing to worry about. I had the opportunity to try this place 3 times and each time came away with the same thoughts, the meat was too dry and there was no flavor. I did notice this last visit that the steak was in a bin and was pre cooked. As the fry cooked needed more steak he added it to the grill from the bin and warmed it, which I'm sure contributes to the lack of flavor. Anytime I've had a cheese Steak in Philly at Geno's or Pat's I got something a little fresher. This will more than likely be my last time at this establishment.
0
Heart
October 02, 2005
Nope....this is not a philly cheesesteak. These New Yorkers have been fooled to think this is what a cheesesteak is suppose to taste like. I've had way better at a place in Atlanta, GA. Go to philly for the real thing.. the only thing that carl has gotten right is the bread
0
Heart
May 21, 2005
As close as it gets.... Philly Cheesesteaks are hard to replicate. So far, I've sampled each and every cheesesteak place in NYC, and I've got to say that this is as close as it gets. Problem is that unless there is a crowd, the meat sits out too long. By too long, I mean, thats what makes the difference between this steak and what you'd find in Philly. The more people on the line, the better the Cheesesteaks are. It might not have that little extra something that is the "Philly Cheeseteak" - but its still very good. Make sure you get it with onions and Cheese whiz.
0
Heart
February 04, 2005
Meh. Not even close to Philly cheesesteaks! They aren't horrible, but they let the meat sit too long and it congeals. My main issue is that they are WAY too salty. The bread is good, though. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here unless I were hungover and needed greasy food.
0
Heart
Write a Tip for
Carl's Steaks
Related Guides
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Add Blog Post
Add your blog review of Carl's Steaks to Citysearch
Do you have a review of Carl's Steaks on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
- 1. Include our image link in your Carl's Steaks review blog post.
- 2. Citysearch will notice that you're linking to one of our pages. We'll scan your blog.
- 3. We'll show a link to your blog post from the Carl's Steaks page on Citysearch.
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
Image Link
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.