Penelope Cafe

(212) 481-3800

159 Lexington Ave
New York, NY 10016 40.7437 -73.9815

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Kips Bay, Midtown

PENELOPENYC.COM

Hours:

Monday To Sunday From 08:00 AM To 11:00 PM

Price:

$

Last updated 7.26.11

Category:

Restaurants, Bakeries

Payment Methods:

Cash

Restaurant Special Features:

Local Favorite, Breakfast, Family-Friendly Dining, Brunch, Lunch Spot, Food Delivery, Cheap Eats, Dine At The Bar

General Info:

Open 7 Days

Cuisine:

Hamburgers, Traditional American

What People Are Saying About Penelope Cafe

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

In Short – Owner Jenny Potenza named this neighborhood spot after her pet turtle, but that's about the only slow aspect of this baby blue-walled eatery. Young neighborhood guests fill the wooden benches or bar stools throughout the day as they stop in for specialties such as nutella French toast, egg sandwiches, spinach pies, and chicken meatballs. Reviews and thank-you notes clipped to a clothesline emphasize the place's popularity, and waitresses wearing aprons add to the at-home feel.

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
Be prepared to wait for up to an hour on weekends. Have the waitress write your name on the chalkboard and take a cup of coffee outside.
Save Time:
In a hurry? Buy muffins, brownies, or bags of granola from the counter and take them to go.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. Downside to this place is the parking, although the later you come, the better, and service is great all the time.
  2. This place is super cute and the waitstaff give off a very relaxed comfortable vibe.
  3. The light blue colored walls and the decor is just the perfect place to go to and remember what summer feels like (and in the summer - with the windows open, it's just prefect!)
  4. It's a pretty small, cozy room and the staff is attentive.
  5. Great ambience, great food, great service.
  6. After a short debate on the influence of their decor (French country or English cottage) we decided to f**k it and enjoy the meal with nice conversation.
  7. penelope is the kind of place you always seem to be looking for but can never find - cozy atmoshere, great friendly service, great comfort food, simple but delicious wine list, even better prices.
  8. am bringing my mom and dad there today, as I know my mom will love the atmosphere, and my dad will love the food.
dessert
90.0% positive
  1. we were stuffed after our entrees, but couldnt resist ordering desserts since penelope is famous for its baked goods.
  2. And a fresh dessert menu.
  3. the carrot cake was really good dense cake that was not too sweet and topped with a layer of lemon icing.
  4. the pie was pretty good despite being served cold the crust was flaky and the filling tart.
  5. Apparently the carrot and red velvet cake is delicious.
drinks
33.3299994468689% positive
  1. Several members of our party reported that their drinks there were expensive.
  2. They had numerous creative and delcious wines and even allowed you to get a half a bottle, and if you got a full bottle, they allow you to take it home!
  3. penelope is the kind of place you always seem to be looking for but can never find - cozy atmoshere, great friendly service, great comfort food, simple but delicious wine list, even better prices.
food quality
85.1099967956543% positive
  1. Went again this past weekend and it was delicious.
  2. have mentioned downtown campiness before and this eatery had a couple suspects, but for the most part I loved the crowd, wait staff and especially the food.
  3. The mac&cheese is good, and the green apple sandwich is tasty.
  4. ordered the mac & cheese, one of my friends ordered the nice chicken meatball sandwich, and my other friend ordered the curried chicken salad.
  5. {they recently added some seafood items to their menu for the summer, so now the lobster roll is the most expensive, at $14.00} We eat there at least twice a week.
  6. Everyone was happy with their meal, and the price is great for the portion sizes.
  7. the curried chicken salad was good too a huge pile of chicken in a sweet curry dressing served on a bed of greens.
  8. The food is wonderful.
  9. The reality was that we each paid $11 for some of the most mediocre breakfast food I've ever had the displeasure of eating.
  10. More and more often lately I have been served stale, or sloppily prepared food that just isn't up to par with Penelope's previous consistently good food.
  11. the mac and cheese came with a breaded top and a big slice of tomato baked right in.
  12. The Farmers Omlette was extremely plain and came without any toast while, the Nutella French Toast was downright poor.
  13. went there the first time because someone told me the food was great and inexpencive.
  14. who puts cold cheese, cold ham, and untoasted/cold bread with cooked eggs to make a breakfast sandwich?
  15. The food is always delicious and the service friendly.
  16. Great ambience, great food, great service.
  17. The sandwiches and salads are delicious.
  18. penelope is the kind of place you always seem to be looking for but can never find - cozy atmoshere, great friendly service, great comfort food, simple but delicious wine list, even better prices.
  19. classic lobster roll piled atop a fresh baked brioche and a side of homemade fries.
  20. Their menu changes by the season, but they've always got their amazing chicken meatball.
  21. Apparently the carrot and red velvet cake is delicious.
  22. Overall, the food is good (although brunch is usually a little better) and the service is always friendly and accomomdating.
  23. The ingredients were fresh and not skimpy, and it came with a side of salad with dressing which was tart and sweet.
  24. The menu was extensive and creative, the food was well prepared and delicious.
  25. really good food accompanied by equally good prices
  26. The food is great, my favorite: The waffles, and also the fresh OJ.
  27. If you want a neighborhood place where the food is good then go to Penelope's.
  28. My poached egg with ham and fontina was one piece of tasteless sourdough bread, two eggs "poached" to death such that they were hard boiled, draped with one piece of cold deli ham.
  29. After a short debate on the influence of their decor (French country or English cottage) we decided to f**k it and enjoy the meal with nice conversation.
  30. Great little spot for a quick, yummy bite
  31. The food is always excellent, the service is wonderful, and it is SO CHEAP.
  32. We thought everything was delicious.
  33. Kind of reminds you of the country, a nice departure from the iron-clad city with great food to boot.
  34. My date opted for the "really really good" (her words) chicken meatballs accompanied by a lemony dressing and an arugula salad.
  35. And a fresh dessert menu.
  36. The pita and breads accompanying this dish were also not memorable.
  37. This morning we finally made it over to discover that the best part of the experience was the anticipation of good food.
  38. Their hand-cut fries are good, too, so don't order them if you're on a diet!
  39. definately cute and popular, but the food is terrible.
  40. The dip was the best I've ever had, the mac&cheese made me feel like I was down south at a world famous soul-food restaurant, the salad was perfect, and the sandwich tasted just like a beef meatball wedge.
  41. With every bite we were mesmerized by how delicious and unique the food was.
  42. the pile of fries that came with the sandwich were also amazing thick-cut, hot on the outside & mealy on the inside.
  43. found this place while walking to work one day - its very quaint with fresh, tasty, innovative and affordable meals.
  44. My wife and I usually go to Penelope's for breakfast, and we always enjoy our meal.
  45. The menu is a assortment of innovative sandwiches and they have a great brunch.
  46. am bringing my mom and dad there today, as I know my mom will love the atmosphere, and my dad will love the food.
  47. The prices are also very reasonable and the dishes are inventive.
menu variety
85.71000099182129% positive
  1. Their menu changes by the season, but they've always got their amazing chicken meatball.
  2. the brunch menu seems reasonable.
  3. The menu was extensive and creative, the food was well prepared and delicious.
  4. The menu is a assortment of innovative sandwiches and they have a great brunch.
  5. And a fresh dessert menu.
  6. We went for brunch with friends and had to wait and when they came for us that thanked us for waiting, then my friend wanted to order the BBLT which was not on the brunch menu.
  7. {they recently added some seafood items to their menu for the summer, so now the lobster roll is the most expensive, at $14.00} We eat there at least twice a week.
overall
93.75% positive
  1. The dip was the best I've ever had, the mac&cheese made me feel like I was down south at a world famous soul-food restaurant, the salad was perfect, and the sandwich tasted just like a beef meatball wedge.
  2. great little place
  3. This is a great place for brunch.
  4. This is a great casual place on Lex.
  5. In a neighborhood overrun with lame chain restaurants, this is absolutely the best place to eat in the area.
  6. great local place
  7. This is a great place to grab a light dinner.
  8. If the line is short or you don't mind waiting, this is definitely the best place for brunch in the neighborhood.
return potential
100.0% positive
  1. My girlfriend and I continually come back to this charming little restaurant.
service
92.30999946594238% positive
  1. Great ambience, great food, great service.
  2. The setting at Penelope is charmingly rustic and the waiters are attentive and cheerful.
  3. penelope is the kind of place you always seem to be looking for but can never find - cozy atmoshere, great friendly service, great comfort food, simple but delicious wine list, even better prices.
  4. Downside to this place is the parking, although the later you come, the better, and service is great all the time.
  5. Overall, the food is good (although brunch is usually a little better) and the service is always friendly and accomomdating.
  6. The food is always delicious and the service friendly.
  7. Great service.
  8. The food is always excellent, the service is wonderful, and it is SO CHEAP.
  9. It's a pretty small, cozy room and the staff is attentive.
  10. The staff isn't very friendly and seams to busy to deal with you.
  11. have mentioned downtown campiness before and this eatery had a couple suspects, but for the most part I loved the crowd, wait staff and especially the food.
  12. our server was really friendly and nice.
  13. haven't had the mac/cheese, but if that's what people here rave about, and if that's your thing, then maybe you should go.
value
80.0% positive
  1. affordable brunch!
  2. was pleased to find that their portions are huge.
  3. The prices are also very reasonable and the dishes are inventive.
  4. penelope is the kind of place you always seem to be looking for but can never find - cozy atmoshere, great friendly service, great comfort food, simple but delicious wine list, even better prices.
  5. Everyone was happy with their meal, and the price is great for the portion sizes.
  6. the curried chicken salad was good too a huge pile of chicken in a sweet curry dressing served on a bed of greens.
  7. {they recently added some seafood items to their menu for the summer, so now the lobster roll is the most expensive, at $14.00} We eat there at least twice a week.
  8. Several members of our party reported that their drinks there were expensive.
  9. found this place while walking to work one day - its very quaint with fresh, tasty, innovative and affordable meals.
  10. really good food accompanied by equally good prices
wait time
100.0% positive
  1. Great little spot for a quick, yummy bite
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

04/18/11

A shortcut to that road-trip cafe you will never forget

by Space

Penelope is one of a kind, I cant put my finger on it, if its the food or if its the staff or the physical atmosphere of the place that makes eating there such a unique experience. Every time I go there I have the same feeling, in the middle of that great road trip of life, every bite of that Grilled Chicken Club, a smile from one of the Penelopee's and suddenly Im transported in to an American Beauty moment.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

11/15/10

Great FOOD

by LIN09

This place is like no other in the area.

Great comfortable place always busy and easily the best food option in the area.

We had a blast waiting for a table and met new people outside while waiting to be seated.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

11/07/10

Delish!

by nycplayground

The only bad thing about this place is that during peak times there is a long wait to be seated. The food is that great! This country kitchen serves the most delicious food..great spinach artichoke dip, a spectacular chicken meatball sandwich, an addicting veggie burger...I can go on and on. And don't forget to order desert! Its way too good o pass up!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/26/10

Totally a best option!

by Alwashere

This is definitely one of my favorite brunch spots. It's literally right next to my house, so I carefully observe the massive line that begins to form every Sunday morning at 10am.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/16/10

Lovely Penelope's

by mmeilan27

If you want a neighborhood place where the food is good then go to Penelope's. I am from out of town and go to New York once a year. This past weekend will be the 4th year we've had breakfast at Penelope's ... its a must on our trip. I've only been there for breakfast and there is a long wait..but come on guys, its breakfast! Get up earlier and if you're there by 9:30am a table for 4 took 20 minutes. Totally worth it for the papaya/strawberry and coconut waffles...yummmmm

  • Pros: Yummy breakfast
  • Cons: None

The Details on Penelope Cafe

Place Categories:

  • great comfort food
  • great friendly service
  • great local place
  • affordable meals
  • amazing pile
  • affordable diner quality brunch
  • very reasonable prices
  • recommend soulfood restaurant
  • delicious curried chicken salad
  • creative brunch menu
  • great brunch spot
  • most mediocre breakfast food
  • cold deli ham
  • cheerful waiters
  • not very friendly staff
  • loved wait staff
  • nice server
  • cold cheese
  • not skimpy ingredients
  • excellent bblt
  • fresh dessert menu
  • nice conversation
  • best dining experiences
  • absolutely loved everything
  • lame chain restaurants

As Seen In…

Best of Citysearch

New York

Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement