(212) 255-2060

202 West 14th St (nr. Seventh Ave.)
New York, NY 10011 40.7386 -73.9999

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: West Village, Downtown

LACARBONARANYC.COM

Hours:

Daily, noon-11pm

Price:

$$

Last updated 4.14.11

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, Discover, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Romantic Dining, Special Occasion Dining, Fine Dining, Brunch, Outdoor Dining, Lunch Spot, Group Dining, Cheap Eats, Dine At The Bar, Notable Wine List

Cuisine:

Italian

What People Are Saying About La Carbonara

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

Southern Italian cuisine including homemade pastas, seafood entrees, meat dishes and more, with prix fixe menu.

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
Primitivo Osteria offers Prix-Fixe menus, which means that there is a fixed price charged for any meal chosen from the variety listed on the menu.
The Extras:
Primitivo Osteria offers gift certificates for special occasions.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. will say the service, ambiance and dessert were really good.
  2. Previous reviews stated that this was a romantic place.
  3. Room is very romantic and wonderfully lit.
  4. But be aware that the tables are too close together to make it a comfortable, pleasant dining experience when it is crowded.
  5. Nice cozy atmosphere but most importantly very good food at very good prices.
  6. So, go there if you want romantic dinner for two or a nice get together with some friends.
  7. love the decor of the restaurant-very warm and cozy.
  8. The food is terrific, the waitstaff are competent, the atmosphere is just slightly upscale/trendy, and the prices are amazing!
  9. Second, the atmosphere is inviting and casual.
  10. would recommend this place as a great value and location for a large get together or just a dinner for 2.
  11. The service was fast, friendly and professional, the restaurant was comfortable and clean, the drinks were very tasty, and the food was out of this world.
  12. well, HOT, that never hurts:-) The atmosphere is excellent and the food is delicious.
  13. romantic dinner for two
dessert
80.0% positive
  1. will say the service, ambiance and dessert were really good.
  2. let the restaurant know ahead of time that we would be celebrating a friends birthday that night, and for a reasonable fee they provided us with an ice cream birthday cake that was exquisite.
  3. Dessert wise - very good tiramisu and kinda too strong chocolate cake.
  4. The deserts suck, but the lobster which was only 26 bucks, was OH SO worth it.
  5. For dessert I just had to try both the panna cotta and the tiramisu since those are my two favorite desserts.
drinks
90.0% positive
  1. Everything on the menu is excellent and the house red and white wines are the best deals in town!
  2. Luckily the food was great, and the wine was nice.
  3. My two favorite small plates were the marinated meatballs in basil pesto and wine, and the soft polenta with sweet sausage and wild mixed mushrooms.
  4. Good service and great bar.
  5. The waiter was very attentive, knew how the food was prepared and knew about the wines.
  6. They also had an extensive selection of great Italian wines that complemented the meal very well.
  7. Food sat cold waiting for wine and spoons.
  8. The service was fast, friendly and professional, the restaurant was comfortable and clean, the drinks were very tasty, and the food was out of this world.
  9. & the food & wine ~it's always an awesome evening!
  10. They have very good prices, a nice wine selection and down to earth people who work there.
food quality
97.8499984741211% positive
  1. The chicken parm is very good, as was the mozzerella tomato basil app and ceaser salad.
  2. The food is terrific, the waitstaff are competent, the atmosphere is just slightly upscale/trendy, and the prices are amazing!
  3. The fish dishes and salmon are among the best I have ever tasted, as always the pasta entrees are just wonderful - having tried almost the entire menu!
  4. The service is always warm and gracious, and the food-to-value ratio can't be beat.
  5. Very tasty homemade pastas, great antipasta apps and exiquisite salads.
  6. The Rigatoni Pollo Pazzo is wonderful, they have a prix fixe lunch that includes soup or salad, entree and hot or cold beverage for $8, The Sat and Sun brunch for $11 is exceptional, considering they offer unlimited mimosas!
  7. They also had an extensive selection of great Italian wines that complemented the meal very well.
  8. The food is delicious and oh my God, sooo cheap!
  9. great food, great staff!
  10. Tasty Italian food at very reasonable prices and friendly service.
  11. All the pasta dishes that my friends ordered were tasty.
  12. The spicy maranara sauce that came with it would have been good enough to put on some pasta and eat.
  13. Best rustic pizza, antipast, salads we have found.
  14. only had 4 on my plate, but the sauce is amazing.
  15. we always get the "greatest" warm service and the best food.
  16. Currently, there is a good prix fixe meal available but only if you know about it.
  17. They were both delicious and the prices were very reasonable, especially for New York.
  18. The food is great, service is getting better and best of all, the value is there.
  19. But the overall food experience was very much enjoyable.
  20. My boyfriend and I have tried many places in the surrounding area and none can come close to the excellent food for the price.
  21. We ordered the Portobello e Pecorino salad as appetizers, which tasted amazing and had wonderful flavor.
  22. The Risotto al Gamberoni (Arborio rice with green peas and shrimp) was done to perfection, and the Scaloppine Saltimbocca was the best I ever tasted!
  23. then had the meat-filled tortellini which was very good.
  24. The waiters and hostess were upbeat and very helpful, and our waiter recommended a really nice Barbera to have with our meal.
  25. The service was fast, friendly and professional, the restaurant was comfortable and clean, the drinks were very tasty, and the food was out of this world.
  26. LOVE the Tomato Mozzarella salad with the beautiful pesto and Balsamico reduction and I always have the vegetable Cappellini!
  27. The owner should be very proud of his staff for their professionalism and his food for its great taste.
  28. If you're looking for decent food at decent prices you won't be disappointed.
  29. & the food & wine ~it's always an awesome evening!
  30. This place was great, the food was amazing, the only complaint I would have is the chaotic staff, but they have a lot of business so they are just trying to please everyone.
  31. The food was great, as well as the prices.
  32. highly recommend the blueberry pancakes and i'm not a big pancake fan.
  33. went there for brunch and again the food was delicious.
  34. This used to be a place that you could go to a couple of times a week and enjoy great food and good services.
  35. There are many other Restaurants in the area that are less expensive and have food that is just as good.
  36. We usually have a good, reliable meal at this pretty local Italian.
  37. The entire staff was friendly and the food was very good.
  38. Excellent food and huge portion, superb service and very inexpensive.
  39. Luckily the food was great, and the wine was nice.
  40. Great food!
  41. The food is still terrific, but not worth the money.
  42. well, HOT, that never hurts:-) The atmosphere is excellent and the food is delicious.
  43. There are not enough kind words for Primitivo - the food is fantastic, the waitstaff wonderful and the owner is very friendly.
  44. Excellent wait staff, great food, and Tim is wonderful.
  45. great service, good food, outside seating
  46. great food, great value
  47. The Prosciutto e Melone was so fresh and presented in a beautiful display.
  48. Very good rustic italian pizza
  49. " The dinner menu featured a host of several small plates "prepared to order" perfect for those who wish to try several items to fully plated entrees, a la carte specialties and an assortment of other side dishes.
  50. the seafood pasta special is amazing, portions were very generous.
  51. The waiter was very attentive, knew how the food was prepared and knew about the wines.
  52. Good food & Good Atmosphere
  53. Very good food.
  54. would def recommend this place to anyone who loves Italian food at reasonable prices.
  55. My two favorite small plates were the marinated meatballs in basil pesto and wine, and the soft polenta with sweet sausage and wild mixed mushrooms.
  56. Great food.
  57. Nice cozy atmosphere but most importantly very good food at very good prices.
  58. The pasta dishes are around $16, and when my meal arrived, my food was served in a huge dish, and I received a child's size portion.
  59. Overall a positive experience with good food.
  60. The salad was generous and so delicious; my entree was excellent.
  61. We each started with a salad, I had a delicious Caesar and my wife had arugala with a house dressing.
  62. My favorite dish is the lemon chicken, which is on the lunch menu.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. Everything on the menu is excellent and the house red and white wines are the best deals in town!
  2. They have very good prices, a nice wine selection and down to earth people who work there.
  3. They also had an extensive selection of great Italian wines that complemented the meal very well.
  4. was amazed at the selections offered at these reasonable prices.
  5. My favorite dish is the lemon chicken, which is on the lunch menu.
  6. The fish dishes and salmon are among the best I have ever tasted, as always the pasta entrees are just wonderful - having tried almost the entire menu!
  7. " The dinner menu featured a host of several small plates "prepared to order" perfect for those who wish to try several items to fully plated entrees, a la carte specialties and an assortment of other side dishes.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. This is a great place!
  2. am definitely returning to the Primitivo-right now, my favorite Italian restaurant.
  3. This is a good place if you have a small party
  4. OMFG I had the best service ever in this place!
service
91.89000129699707% positive
  1. The unlimited mimosas were great, and the staff was really friendly.
  2. They have very good prices, a nice wine selection and down to earth people who work there.
  3. Tim and the team went out of their way to make the party very special for everyone (all 30 people walked away happy!)
  4. The waiters and hostess were upbeat and very helpful, and our waiter recommended a really nice Barbera to have with our meal.
  5. The service was excellent.
  6. The food is great, service is getting better and best of all, the value is there.
  7. Unfortunately, after a recommendation from a friend, four of us came for the first time to receive the worst service we have ever had in the city.
  8. Excellent food and huge portion, superb service and very inexpensive.
  9. Thanks Primitivo and its staff for making my birthday such a memorable experience.
  10. Fast service, promptly seated, good bang for you buck.
  11. the staff was so friendly and attentive.
  12. next time I'll get the name of my favorite waiter so that I can post it here and recommend to all of you.
  13. The service is friendly & attentive.
  14. The waiter was very attentive, knew how the food was prepared and knew about the wines.
  15. Wonderful attention from staff and just a great value in an area where most other restaurants are overpriced.
  16. The worst service
  17. Went with 6 friends and the service was great.
  18. The service was fast, friendly and professional, the restaurant was comfortable and clean, the drinks were very tasty, and the food was out of this world.
  19. will say the service, ambiance and dessert were really good.
  20. OMFG I had the best service ever in this place!
  21. great food, great staff!
  22. My waiter was extremely attentive and funny and nice and.
  23. There are not enough kind words for Primitivo - the food is fantastic, the waitstaff wonderful and the owner is very friendly.
  24. The owner should be very proud of his staff for their professionalism and his food for its great taste.
  25. Excellent wait staff, great food, and Tim is wonderful.
  26. This place was great, the food was amazing, the only complaint I would have is the chaotic staff, but they have a lot of business so they are just trying to please everyone.
  27. Good service and great bar.
  28. The service is always warm and gracious, and the food-to-value ratio can't be beat.
  29. It was early so it wasn't very crowded, but the place is very nice inside, staff is friendly.
  30. complained to our waiter about my miniscule portion, and he shrugged it off and asked me if I wanted to order an additional entree.
  31. Tasty Italian food at very reasonable prices and friendly service.
  32. Very friendly, warm and accomodating.
  33. we always get the "greatest" warm service and the best food.
  34. great service, good food, outside seating
  35. Third, the servers are very attentive, without being obtrusive.
  36. Not great evening service
  37. The entire staff was friendly and the food was very good.
value
86.78000450134277% positive
  1. They were both delicious and the prices were very reasonable, especially for New York.
  2. great lunch value.
  3. would def recommend this place to anyone who loves Italian food at reasonable prices.
  4. The food is great, service is getting better and best of all, the value is there.
  5. Excellent food and huge portion, superb service and very inexpensive.
  6. The salad was generous and so delicious; my entree was excellent.
  7. great food, great value
  8. the seafood pasta special is amazing, portions were very generous.
  9. Tasty Italian food at very reasonable prices and friendly service.
  10. the price is reasonable.
  11. was amazed at the selections offered at these reasonable prices.
  12. The pasta dishes are around $16, and when my meal arrived, my food was served in a huge dish, and I received a child's size portion.
  13. Nice cozy atmosphere but most importantly very good food at very good prices.
  14. The food is delicious and oh my God, sooo cheap!
  15. The food is still terrific, but not worth the money.
  16. would recommend this place as a great value and location for a large get together or just a dinner for 2.
  17. think the prices were very reasonable.
  18. Everything on the menu is excellent and the house red and white wines are the best deals in town!
  19. If you're looking for decent food at decent prices you won't be disappointed.
  20. They have very good prices, a nice wine selection and down to earth people who work there.
  21. My boyfriend and I have tried many places in the surrounding area and none can come close to the excellent food for the price.
  22. The food is terrific, the waitstaff are competent, the atmosphere is just slightly upscale/trendy, and the prices are amazing!
  23. There are many other Restaurants in the area that are less expensive and have food that is just as good.
  24. It would have been all right if they raised their prices, but to raise the prices, make the portions one third the size is ridiculous.
  25. The deserts suck, but the lobster which was only 26 bucks, was OH SO worth it.
  26. The food was great, as well as the prices.
  27. Wonderful attention from staff and just a great value in an area where most other restaurants are overpriced.
  28. The service is always warm and gracious, and the food-to-value ratio can't be beat.
  29. I've never had a huge appetite, and usually I have leftovers after dining out, but I was actually STARVING after I left this place.
1 Star Rating: Poor

03/31/10

The worst service

by axelfigueroa

The manager did not acknowledge us when we got there only after the bus boy did that he turn around and acknowledge our presence. We sat and 15 min pass by and no waiter came to take our order. Only after we ask the bus boy to call the waiter that this female waiter came with an attitude very non chalant she took our order and did not mention the specials. That was the last time she came to our table because she spend most of the time hugging the manager. We wanted more wine but we did not have a waiter again we have to ask the bus boy to call the waiter. Food came and no wine and no spoons for our pasta. Food sat cold waiting for wine and spoons. It took 2 more attempts to get the wine and spoons and even after that no apologies or excuses. We ask for the check and of course we have to call the bus boy again to call the waiter to get our check. And again no apologies.

  • Pros: good food
  • Cons: barely no service
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/10/09

Hidden Gem

by jsurak

Primitivo is one of the "best deals in town." The dinner menu featured a host of several small plates "prepared to order" perfect for those who wish to try several items to fully plated entrees, a la carte specialties and an assortment of other side dishes. My two favorite small plates were the marinated meatballs in basil pesto and wine, and the soft polenta with sweet sausage and wild mixed mushrooms...ABSOLUTELY SCRUMPTIOUS! The menu also offered a variety of vegetarian selections, which tempted my zen palate. I had the ravioli stuffed with herbed goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes and pink vodka sauce, YUMMUS!. They also had an extensive selection of great Italian wines that complemented the meal very well. A hidden gem on the border between (Chelsea and the West Village).

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/09/09

An Affordable Cut Above the Rest

by GEvanina

I have been dining at Primitivo since it opened, and it has only gotten better over the years. In fact, it is one of my favorite places to eat for several reasons. First, and foremost, the food is excellent. My favorite dish is the lemon chicken, which is on the lunch menu. Second, the atmosphere is inviting and casual. They recently did a nice job remodeling the interior of the restaurant. Third, the servers are very attentive, without being obtrusive. Oh--I almost forgot--the cappuccinos are the best!!!

4 Star Rating: Recommended

01/08/09

My old fav is my new fav!

by karenarkive

So, I've been going to Primitivo since it opened. The staff always made me feel welcome.. & are a bit flirty, which we love!, & the food & wine ~it's always an awesome evening! In the last year or so it was starting to feel a bit stodgy, you know, same ol same o, & not working with the excitement of the neighborhood... Well! How excited was I on my last visit! The decor is all new, all the stodgness is gone! & they're experimenting with new dishes as well as keeping up with the favorites I've always loved! My old favorite place in the west village is now my new favorite! & how fun to bring my friends here after checking out the galleries & shops!

  • Pros: ambience, food, wine,bar
  • Cons: not in my neighborhood
1 Star Rating: Poor

01/01/09

Go here only if you're on a diet

by doughfulbread

This place was terrible. AVOID. AVOID. AVOID. I ordered a mozzarella/prosciutto appetizer for $14, and when it arrived, I received 3 small slices of mozzarella, two thin slices of prosciutto, and 3 slices of tomatoes. The pasta dishes are around $16, and when my meal arrived, my food was served in a huge dish, and I received a child's size portion. I've never had a huge appetite, and usually I have leftovers after dining out, but I was actually STARVING after I left this place. I complained to our waiter about my miniscule portion, and he shrugged it off and asked me if I wanted to order an additional entree. Um, no, I would like to get what I paid for. Needless to say, I will NEVER eat here again. I would suggest only going to eat here if you're on a diet and are watching your food portions.

  • Pros: None.
  • Cons: TINY portions, not cheap, poor service

The Details on La Carbonara

Place Categories:

  • great italian food
  • friendly evening service
  • very reasonable prices
  • great little italian place
  • really friendly excellent wait staff
  • comfortable pleasant dining experience
  • very attentive waiter
  • warm very
  • great lunch value
  • inviting good atmosphere
  • great neighborhood
  • good reliable meal
  • beautiful room
  • really good dessert
  • worst service
  • very tasty drinks
  • amazing spicy maranara sauce
  • early place
  • romantic dinner
  • excellent additional entree
  • wonderful tim
  • very good tiramisu
  • favorite dish
  • really love italian restaurant
  • warm restaurantvery
Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement