Sugar Sweet Sunshine

(212) 995-1960

126 Rivington St
New York, NY 10002 40.7198 -73.9869

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Lower East Side, Downtown

SUGARSWEETSUNSHINE.COM

Price:

$

Last updated 10.17.11

Category:

Bakeries, Catering, Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Family-Friendly Dining, Quiet

What People Are Saying About Sugar Sweet Sunshine

Featured Review

Allison Austin

Contributor

The Scene – On the block between uber-chic Schiller's and 'Inoteca, this little bakery is a breath of unassuming fresh air. The furniture is old and mismatched, the walls are bare and the baker is the counter person, the espresso puller and also the person who'll ring up your order. – – The Food – The owners used to work at Magnolia Bakery, so naturally there's going to be talk about who makes the best cupcakes. These are pretty good: The vanilla cake is superior to the chocolate, and the chocolate icing is superior to the vanilla. But what's surprising is the pumpkin…

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
Check out the original: Magnolia Bakery in the West Village.
Save Money:
Buying a birthday cake? Sprinkles and candy decorations are free, and the bakers will gladly add an inscription to your cake for $2.
The Extras:
Another Magnolia alum strikes out on his own.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. the location really isn't sketchy unless you're deathly afraid of hipsters, it's the lower east side for crying out loud.
  2. The decor was nice, but the woman behind the counter was extremely unfriendly.
  3. Awesome cupcakes, not-so-awesome location.
dessert
95.62999725341797% positive
  1. The owners Peg and Deb not only are impeccable bakers, their cake is moist, delicate and delicious.
  2. This is a small little bakery that specializes in making delicious loaf breads, cookies and friendly service.
  3. frostings are flavorful and complement the cakes well.
  4. which surprised me a bit actually, since most people said they liked the chocolate frosting at sSs more.
  5. The strawberry rubarb pie is amazing , so is the variety of trifles they sell by the cup.
  6. have never gotten rude service from them and even ordered a cake not on their menu and they agreed to make it for me.
  7. The coffee cake for breakfast is great too.
  8. The best peanut butter pie
  9. All of the chocolate-looking icing is their "chocolate-almond" icing-- that's their only choice and although I typically find almond flavoring delicious, this type is terribly disappointing.
  10. Prior to placing the order, I asked the clerk if they put fresh strawberries on the cake.
  11. They showed me the cake hesitantly, and I realized it only read Happy 7th Birthday.
  12. The cake is light and moist and the frosting is perfect- light, creamy, and just wonderful.
  13. am pretty plain when it comes to desserts and prefer the vanilla which were fantastic.
  14. After having had good cupcakes here, I decided to order a birthday cake for my son.
  15. the place also has cute couches you can lounge on - so bring a friend and enjoy the yummy desserts!
  16. especially loved the Red Velvet Cupcake, I also like the Ooowee Goowee chocolate cupcake & I'm not f.
  17. thought the cake itself good but not great: nothing particularly wrong, but the chocolate flavor was not particularly rich or exciting.
  18. The colors are so beautiful, cakes so moist, frosting just sweet enough and the pumpkin spice was wonderful.
  19. So friendly, great service and great desserts.
  20. In additon, I asked them to write Happy 7th Birthday Matthew on the cake.
  21. The cake looked awful (like tie dye), and the owner (the woman who was helping me) knew it.
  22. They have more than just yummy cupcakes - cookies, pies and ice box cakes, but its impossibel to leave without a cupckae.
  23. The cup cakes are divine.
  24. All the desserts looked good, we tried one of the cupcakes with buttercream frosting.
  25. If you like peanut butter, you must get the peanut butter pie.
  26. Plus you can order a custom cake or pie for any occasion.
  27. In any case, their vanilla frosting is reeeeeeeeally yummy, the cake itself has a nice flavor and is more moist than Magnolia's, and they're just really great cupcakes overall.
  28. In any case, you won't find a better vanilla cupcake anywhere, and you can order (they don't usually have these the display case) this amazing strawberry cake or cupcakes with cream cheese icing.
  29. love the Sunshines (yellow cake with vanilla butter cream frosting) but I'll also occasionally indulge in a coconut.
  30. would definitely recommend this place over Magnolia for cupcakes (but the peanut butter cookies at Magnolia are oh so good!)
  31. together we created an awesome cupcake pyramid as our wedding cake for 250 people!
  32. The red velvet and chocolate cupcakes were good, but the pistachio and pumpkin cupcakes were amazing, the best cupcakes I've ever had!
  33. Ok so I actually like their vanilla frosting more than Magnolia's, but I like Magnolia's chocolate frosting more than the chocolate-almond frosting at sugar Sweet sunshine.
  34. I'm a dessert connoisseur and certainly have been to every great bakery in NYC.
  35. Cupcakes are yummy and cookies, too.
  36. The cheesecake here is amazing, it must weigh 7 pounds!
  37. Icing is not my thing but the cake portion is just heavenly!
  38. My order was a pretty standard birthday cake.
  39. The cake is moist and the frosting is just sweet enough to give you a big mouthful of sugar without making you sick.
  40. The cupcakes are scrumptious, the cakes and pies are amazing, the banana pudding is beyond description.
drinks
100.0% positive
  1. And they also have coffee, teas and all that good stuff.
  2. The coffee cake for breakfast is great too.
  3. They also serve VERY GOOD cup of java (I looove good coffee to go with great cupcake!)
  4. and i like the coffee.
  5. It's a very nice place to just lounge in too, with possibly the last place in Manhattan where the coffee is still a dollar.
food quality
90.0% positive
  1. the cupcakes are delightfully yummy (i much prefer these to magnolia), i love the plain white and pistachio.
  2. The owners Peg and Deb not only are impeccable bakers, their cake is moist, delicate and delicious.
  3. This is a small little bakery that specializes in making delicious loaf breads, cookies and friendly service.
  4. Then they condescending told me that they used fresh strawberries that are frozen.
  5. fabulous everthing: cute store, nice people, high turnover (=fresh!)
  6. All of the chocolate-looking icing is their "chocolate-almond" icing-- that's their only choice and although I typically find almond flavoring delicious, this type is terribly disappointing.
  7. we didn't know that it also carried the most delicious cupcakes in the world!
  8. In any case, their vanilla frosting is reeeeeeeeally yummy, the cake itself has a nice flavor and is more moist than Magnolia's, and they're just really great cupcakes overall.
  9. The chai latte with soy is very tasty also.
  10. Cupcakes are yummy and cookies, too.
  11. They have more than just yummy cupcakes - cookies, pies and ice box cakes, but its impossibel to leave without a cupckae.
  12. Prior to placing the order, I asked the clerk if they put fresh strawberries on the cake.
  13. the place also has cute couches you can lounge on - so bring a friend and enjoy the yummy desserts!
  14. When I questioned them, and reminded them that I was told they used FRESH strawberries, they chuckled and said, "we don't use REAL fresh strawberries.
  15. the cupcakes were so delicious and amazing that people are telling us that the dream about them.
  16. Everything is delicious so far.
  17. The treats are delicious and the ladies are so sweet.
  18. The cupcakes here are delicious.
  19. It seems that everybody is making cupcakes these days and someone is even trying to franchise a cupcake business but Sugar Sweet Sunshine stands out above the crowd with their tasty treats.
  20. its quaint, cute and bright and the cupcakes are absolutely delicious.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. love the variety of flavors that they have and the seating space is very welc.
  2. have never gotten rude service from them and even ordered a cake not on their menu and they agreed to make it for me.
  3. Sugar Sweet Sunshine variety of flavors: German Cake, Pumpkin, Lemon, etc are all excellent.
  4. The strawberry rubarb pie is amazing , so is the variety of trifles they sell by the cup.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. It's a very nice place to just lounge in too, with possibly the last place in Manhattan where the coffee is still a dollar.
  2. it's a great place to stay and chit chat or just read a book.
  3. People are nice and friendly and there is a definite non-hipster vibe to the place (which is a very good thing), even if it is populated by them.
  4. was in the city recently and this place (being down the street from the awesome Economy Candy store) was on my list of places to try my first Red Velvet cupcake.
  5. Sugar Sweet Sunshine is a great place to get my cupcake fix.
return potential
0.0% positive
  1. although the lower East side is (obviously) pretty sketchy, so I'm not sure if I'd go back when there's still Magnolia's and Crumbs in better areas.
service
73.43999862670898% positive
  1. All in all, it was a great experience and I am glad I wasn't caught up in the "name" of the bakery, but the service - it really paid off!
  2. If they are quick, accurate and pleasant that is good service.
  3. Terrific cupcakes and service
  4. catch 22: bad customer service - great cupcakes
  5. together we created an awesome cupcake pyramid as our wedding cake for 250 people!
  6. Bad service is a good deterrent.
  7. which surprised me a bit actually, since most people said they liked the chocolate frosting at sSs more.
  8. People are nice and friendly and there is a definite non-hipster vibe to the place (which is a very good thing), even if it is populated by them.
  9. Whatever the case may be, I'm posting because I've never had anything but perfect service from them.
  10. Great cupcakes, good service
  11. the cupcakes were so delicious and amazing that people are telling us that the dream about them.
  12. The owner, who is also the server, is friendly.
  13. These people are expected to be uber friendly, charming, witty, entertaining and extremely accommodating or else customers are quick to get huffy?
  14. called and was stoked to have a friendly voice on the other end as opposed to the main stream cupcake cafe's I had called before.
  15. On top of that, the service was HORRIBLE - I was shocked at how much they don't care about customer service.
  16. Great delivery - great service
  17. The cupcakes are incredible (and I am not a cupcake person), the service - genuine.
  18. Incredibly rude and obnoxious owner, bad cupcakes.
  19. So friendly, great service and great desserts.
  20. I'm shocked that you received bad service from this place.
  21. great cupcakes, great customer service
  22. She kept cutting me off before I even got a word out and she asked me to leave in a very rude manner.
  23. This is a small little bakery that specializes in making delicious loaf breads, cookies and friendly service.
  24. Very rude service
  25. Obnoxious arrogant and down-right rude.
  26. normally i HATE cupcakes, but when i saw it in the display, i thought to myself, "these cupcakes must be out of sight if they want people to pay for it," most cupcakes are cheesy - like the ones you make for your elementary school teacher on teacher appre
  27. We had an adorable waitress/server who was very nice too.
  28. fabulous everthing: cute store, nice people, high turnover (=fresh!)
  29. have never gotten rude service from them and even ordered a cake not on their menu and they agreed to make it for me.
  30. once again, as someone in the biz: once the sun sets on your passion for finding good people to sell your product, you might be in for a long, dark night.
  31. When I called before I picked them up, the staff were very nice about it and filled my order within an hour!
  32. Worst service ever encountered
value
71.4300012588501% positive
  1. It's a very nice place to just lounge in too, with possibly the last place in Manhattan where the coffee is still a dollar.
  2. know that you're making tons of money and you probably don't care much about making more money off me, but your behaviour is absolutely disgusting and unacceptable.
  3. The prices are also slightly more reasonable than Magnolia but basically the same ballpark.
  4. The cupcakes can be pricey, but they're worth the occasional indulgence.
  5. These ladies (and gentlemen) make some damn good cupcakes (personally a huge fan of the pistachio cc's), and the cafe is a very cute spot to hang out and get your sugar and caffeine fix.
  6. Best inexpensive cupcakes made daily!
  7. Really cheap (for the city), creative flavors, the Red Velvet is my favorite!
wait time
100.0% positive
  1. once again, as someone in the biz: once the sun sets on your passion for finding good people to sell your product, you might be in for a long, dark night.
  2. These people are expected to be uber friendly, charming, witty, entertaining and extremely accommodating or else customers are quick to get huffy?
  3. If they are quick, accurate and pleasant that is good service.
4 Star Rating: Recommended

07/30/11

Recommended!

by SinNYC at Citysearch

Great cupcakes!

4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/23/10

Awesome cupcakes

by RKM at Citysearch

I highly recommend the pistachio cupcakes. Each cupcake is $1.50. I noticed that the cupcakes made out of chocolate cake mix tended to fall apart prematurely, so keep this in mind if you're eating on the run.

  • Pros: $1.50 per cupcake that tastes freshly made
  • Cons: The chocolate cupcakes tend to fall apart easily.
3 Star Rating: Average

10/13/09

catch 22: bad customer service - great cupcakes

by yshemtov at Citysearch

Possibly the WORST customer service I have ever encountered in my 8 years in NYC. Obnoxious arrogant and down-right rude. And - possibly the BEST cupcakes I've ever had. If you're principled enough - go somewhere else. But the cupcakes really are special - some of the staff on the other hand...not so much.

  • Pros: delicious cupcakes
  • Cons: Awful Customer service
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/12/09

Terrific cupcakes and service

by njhonie at Citysearch

I am very suprised at the negaive reviews of this place, I live 2 blocks away so i pass by this place every day and stop in at least 3 times a week. I get nothing but cheerful and prompt service each and ever time i go there from every employee that helps me. I have tried the cookies, cupcakes, and muffins and they are all excellent. The frosting can be a tad sweet at times but i just take some off now. LOVE LOVE LOVE this place. just a side not to the people who complain about how the place has been past business hours and they wanted service and feel they were treated rudely....If you have ever worked in retail industry, places have buisness hours for a reason and if you show up too early or too late its your own fault..(see the review on the girl who wanted a birthday supcake after the store was closed)...yes customer service is important, but people do have lives they have to get too...take care

  • Pros: Location/service/taste
  • Cons: store size
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/27/09

The best peanut butter pie

by vols16 at Citysearch

Cheap, better than any of the other cupcake shops in NYC. If you like peanut butter, you must get the peanut butter pie.

  • Pros: Peanut butter pie, banana pudding
  • Cons: Location

The Details on Sugar Sweet Sunshine

Place Categories:

  • best inexpensive cupcakes
  • great customer service
  • very disappointing cupcakes
  • great place
  • reeeeeeeeally yummy vanilla frosting
  • nice people
  • great cupcake bakery
  • very tasty chai latte
  • amazing rubarb pie
  • unbelievably flavorful icing
  • never bad experience
  • fresh strawberries
  • amazing custom cake
  • unacceptable behavior
  • great turnaround
  • all excellent sugar sweet sunshine variety
  • like coffee
  • big fan
  • rude manner
  • nice light buttercream
  • willing sss
  • capable peggy
  • warm surroundings
  • enjoy yummy desserts
  • favorite pumpkin spice cupcake