Bobby Van's Steakhouse

07/17/11

Average meals and poor service

by fabienmajor

Last friday, i went there for a business lunch. The ambiance was great and the location extraordinary.

But i can only conclude the reputation is very hype! Waiting too long for a poor service.

We don't ask extravagant things: Just pepper... and water for our tea! Imagine that; you pay more than a hundred bucks for a lunch and no one care about you.

I supposed normally clients must bring their hot water? We quit the Bobby Van's Steakhouse with deceptions.

07/17/09

DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY

by neighborwallst

I live across the street so went there for lunch. We ordered porter house and filet mignon. They were both so overcooked and dry that it was disgusting to even attempt to swallow!!!! When I brought it up to our waiter, he was not only condescending, but rude and ignorant!!!! He said it's supposed to be like that and that's how they are normally served!!!! It's either the waiter needs to get TRAINING!!! or they need to get a new chef!!!! I will never go back there and been advising everyone in my building to not waste their time and money here! It's a shame as our building is literally outside their restaurant.

• Pros: NONE
• Cons: EVERYTHING!

12/12/08

Exceptional Food, Staff, and Ambiance!

by wallstreetdi

I have been going to Bobby Vans for years and this location is their best by far. I had to write this review as we went there for my husbands birthday with a few friends tonight. From the moment we walked in the staff was wonderful. They gave us a perfect table, they recommended a fantastic Merlot, and we had the best time. It was one of the best evenings out we had in a long time.. We closed the place down and the staff did not make us feel rushed at all..they actually told us to take our time!! I must say bravo and we look forward to coming back. Did I mention the food is incredible..you must have the tuna tartar, chilean sea bass, and ofcourse the steak...all are delicious!! FYI:This review is about the main restaurant and not the vault downstairs.

• Pros: Food, Staff, Ambiance
• Cons: None that I can think of...

09/28/08

A joke....

by austin2

Went there last week. Borderline laughable. Ordered the sirloin, medium rare and asked the waiter how big it was. He said 20 oz.. I got a medium well steak that was maybe 10 oz.. Hash browns were OK but asparagus was boiled/steamed to death. Outback is better.

• Pros: None really given the many steakhouse choices in NYC
• Cons: Price given the mediocre food

06/09/08

Cool venue but...

by pirate187

Had lunch here last week and was quite disappointed. The venue is very cool...downstairs in the old JP Morgan vault. Very clubby and warm - the perfect Wall-Streeter-beef-eater type setting. Service was efficient and pleasant. However, the food was rather disappointing. Ordered the $27 filet mignon - it was tough and not perfectly cooked to a medium rare. I'm fairly certain the skimpy portion of steak fries went from the freezer, to the fryer, to my plate. Also included were peas that were, well, just peas. My colleague asked to substitute mashed potatoes for fries and was denied. They were brought as a side for $7. My draft MIller Lite (I know, I know) tasted skunk - cleary their tap lines haven't been flushed recently! Perhaps an off day...I'm not sure. But $130 later (lunch for 3)...not sure I'll be back.