Crema Restaurante

(212) 691-4477

111 W 17th St (nr. Sixth Ave.)
New York, NY 10011 40.7394 -73.9957

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Flatiron District, Midtown

cremarestaurante.com

Hours:

Mon, noon-10pm

Tue-Fri, noon-11pm

Sat, 11:30am-midnight

Sun, 11:30am-10pm

Price:

$$$

Last updated 8.16.11

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Brunch, Outdoor Dining, Lunch Spot, Dine At The Bar

Cuisine:

Mexican

What People Are Saying About Crema Restaurante

Featured Review

Erin Behan

Contributor

The Scene – A blaze of brightness--oranges, yellows, reds--colors the narrow restaurant and its stucco-like walls. Consumption of margaritas and gratis fried tortillas at the small bar is de rigueur, but uneven service may discourage multiple drink orders at the linen-topped tables. – – The Food – Chef Julieta Ballesteros, formerly of Mexicana Mama, creates a menu with an impressive array of authentic flavors. The sharp, aromatic hoja santa herb enlivens steak-filled taquitos Nortenos dressed with crema, and a spirited chile emulsion dazzles in the pork-filled tamales…

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
Be warned that while the cilantro-spiked starter of guacamole pleases, it arrives as a mere spoonful.
Where to Sit:
Ask to be seated at the back tables, where you'll get a view into the bustling open kitchen.
Happy Hour:
Happy hour is Mon-Fri, 5pm-7pm, and offers two-for-one beers, house wines, signature margaritas and "Crazy Water," Mexican-style sangria.
What to Drink:
The Margarita Imperial achieves a nice balance with white tequila, orange liqueur, and fresh fruit juices. Or, celebrate with the Banderitos, a flight of three shots representing the colors of Mexico's flag: white (tequila), green (lime juice) and red (sangrita).
ambiance
95.0% positive
  1. The ambiance is pleasant and comfortable.
  2. Love the decor, atmosphere, the bar and lounge areas.
  3. Crema is a chic yet comfortable, a great place to meet friends for dinner and the perfect spot for Sunday brunch before shopping on 6th ave. Bravo!
  4. Amazing food,service and ambiance
  5. ambiance in the restaurant was great.
  6. Small, but has great atmosphere.
  7. loved-loved-loved this place--great food, great ambience, great decor.
  8. The food is truly excellent, the wait staff very nice, and the ambiance is delightful (and the margaritas are yummy!)
  9. The extraordinary attention to detail by chef Julieta Ballesteros and the entire staff, as well as the beautiful decor and ambience, create a rare dining experience - one where you are completely transported away from the routine of your life.
  10. There were 13 of us, and the restaurant is pretty small, but it was such a cozy atmosphere.
  11. Pleasant decor with nice lighting.
  12. The decor is elegant and slick yet cheerful and inviting.
  13. The staff is very friendly and the ambience is really great.
  14. Outstanding food, service, and ambiance.
  15. Most everything was really yummy and the staff was actually quite fun.
  16. Walking in, we delighted at the warm decor with screaming orange walls that somehow fit the place perfectly.
  17. Thoroughly enjoyable dining experience -- fantastic food, unpretentious ambience, strong drinks, and attentive service.
  18. The space is bright with great decor.
  19. The great food was accompanied by a wonderful atmosphere, and a friendly service.
  20. The only other complaint is that it does get very loud and the atmosphere can be frenzied, so it's not exactly a comfortable restaurant.
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. She checked on us throughout the duration of the meal and made excellent reccomendations for entrees and dessert.
  2. Our meal was amazing, I definitely recommend the duck dish, and the tres leches desert!
  3. How can beans in cornbread taste like dessert.
  4. HIGHLY recommend the tostados with grilled scallops, the sea bass, and the chocolate cake, the latter of which has mole in it!
drinks
77.77999877929688% positive
  1. CREMA's talented chef/owner prepares refined authentic Mexican food that plays softly on the palate rather than sandbagging the mouth with mega-hot concoctions that aim to raise beer and margaria consumption.
  2. They made sure the drinks kept flowing, and that we never ran out of that tasty guacamole!
  3. Love the decor, atmosphere, the bar and lounge areas.
  4. Skip the speciality cocktails (typical fruity overpriced concoctions) and the wine list (limited and overpriced) and head for a margarita or beer to wash down the delicious offerings.
  5. The dinner menu looks like it has a more interesting selection of entrees, but if they are even the fraction of the quality of the items we ate for lunch, I whole-heartedly advise you to make it a point and dine at Creama--if not for the drinks, then defi
  6. The only bad thing was the dry martini, which wasnt dry at all, because the barman put lots of little pieces of ice in the drink.
  7. girlfriend and I went to have lunch and drinks at Crema about a month ago, and it was the best food I have had in quite a while.
  8. Thoroughly enjoyable dining experience -- fantastic food, unpretentious ambience, strong drinks, and attentive service.
  9. the Mater de was rude. After we gave him our name, he turned around and rolled his eyes and made a face. ???? Maybe they shouldn't have mirrors at the bar.
food quality
92.95000076293945% positive
  1. We sat in the front window and enjoyed our meal immensely.
  2. Had a an excellent meal with equal service.
  3. The food is amazing.
  4. agree with the editorial reviewer (that it's great food, but uneven service) but I'll give my two cents.
  5. And of course, the Agua Loca--sangria with everything in it--was delicious!
  6. CREMA's talented chef/owner prepares refined authentic Mexican food that plays softly on the palate rather than sandbagging the mouth with mega-hot concoctions that aim to raise beer and margaria consumption.
  7. Service was attentive and the meal was nicely paced.
  8. The food was delicious, I highly recommend checking this place out if you are in the area.
  9. Not only was the food a treasure find, but you must have at least one of their fantastic margaritas.
  10. The food was tasty, fresh, and luscious.
  11. love this food!
  12. The halibut in coconut milk after it's cooked with a bacon + shrimp crust is insanely good.
  13. Very nice food and service.
  14. Interesting food, bad service, expensive
  15. Great food, uneven service
  16. became a fan of the chef's when she was at Mexicana Mama, and all I can say is she's taken her talent for making delicious, innovative food and done it even better.
  17. Outstanding food, service, and ambiance.
  18. The service was good, but it took a looooooong time for our food to arrive.
  19. The best gourmet food I have eaten for a very long time, I have visited Crema last week for a dinner occasion and can not resist sharing my great fortune with the world.
  20. ordered the halibut and declared it my favorite dish in New York City.
  21. Our meal was amazing, I definitely recommend the duck dish, and the tres leches desert!
  22. All dishes are beautifully presented and the service, which can be slow during busy times, is well above average.
  23. The food was excellent and very unique, the service very friendly and attentive.
  24. went with a couple of friends this past weekend, and very much enjoyed the food.
  25. The portions were plentiful and the mini-tacos and beet soup were delicious (and I don't even usually like beets!)
  26. - Anything with mole sauce is delicious - it is probably the best I have ever had
  27. Great food.
  28. This is the second time i went there an i enjoyed the cuisine even better than the first time.
  29. Amazing food,service and ambiance
  30. The food was superb!
  31. First off the food was great!
  32. had the grilled chicken mole special for dinner which was fantastic and my friends had the Pastel Azteca.
  33. I've lived in Manhattan long enough so I'm used to medicore service, but I just thought it was strange when paired with the amazing food.
  34. The cheese and chorizo appetizer is delicious and it's served with their guacamole (so you don't need to order that as well).
  35. normally don't eat a lot of Mexican food, but when you find a restaurant as good as this one, you tend to go back.
  36. How can beans in cornbread taste like dessert.
  37. The food is amazing, this time i followed some people's suggestions and tried the Queso Flameado and the Flautas- both incredible.
  38. Best mexican cuisine I ever tried!
  39. They made sure the drinks kept flowing, and that we never ran out of that tasty guacamole!
  40. went for lunch and had tasty sangria and mexican food that was displayed in a unique way.
  41. ........I've always enjoyed Mexican cuisine, and Crema delivers.
  42. Since that initial visit, I have returned many times, and never fail to order the daily soup which is always complex and remarkably original.
  43. wonderful experience, and incredible food
  44. Great guac, tasty soups and of the four I've tried, every entree has been fantastic.
  45. the food is mediocre, they should call it Tex-Mex not Mexican.
  46. The food is amazing gourmet Mexican, not another burrito joint.
  47. Starting at Crema Restaurant with a great shot of the zillion tequilas they have and the guacamole with the killer habanero salsa] sends you off on an amazing culinary adventure.
  48. Happy marriage = Mexican food, French technique
  49. Towards the end of the meal, the chef Jullieta came out and gave us all complimentary spices and a delicious pineapple-infused tequila to sip!
  50. Most everything was really yummy and the staff was actually quite fun.
  51. The guacamole was divinely fresh.
  52. The food is a refined Mexican; capturing the best flavors of Mexican cuisine combined with haute cuisine touches of brilliance.
  53. Although all the food had great flavors, several fried dishes came out soggy and just not up to par for the price.
  54. The food is truly excellent, the wait staff very nice, and the ambiance is delightful (and the margaritas are yummy!)
  55. Visited Crema last night and enjoyed the food.
  56. Thoroughly enjoyable dining experience -- fantastic food, unpretentious ambience, strong drinks, and attentive service.
  57. While the service was very friendly, the barely edible and overpriced "food sculpture" was pompous.
  58. Not enough meat selections except a Filet Mignon skewer that was too expensive for me to consider.
  59. She checked on us throughout the duration of the meal and made excellent reccomendations for entrees and dessert.
  60. could go on and on about the fabulous Flautas, delicious Chili Rellenos and the savory Ribs but I might have to jump in a cab and go there AGAIN this week.
  61. And the duck tacos were wonderful and interesting.
  62. The chips were good, the salsa fine, though not as good as traditional salsa elsewhere.
  63. went with a group of friends, and the bulk of our dinner conversation ended up largely being about how great the food was.
  64. girlfriend and I went to have lunch and drinks at Crema about a month ago, and it was the best food I have had in quite a while.
  65. Skip the speciality cocktails (typical fruity overpriced concoctions) and the wine list (limited and overpriced) and head for a margarita or beer to wash down the delicious offerings.
  66. The food was really good, although the variety of dishes could be a little bit better.
  67. Examples: a $24 vegetarian plate (50cents worth of corn and beans, $20 for the over-sized china); $22 for chicken flautas ($4 of chicken, $18 worth of grease and salt); $8 for couple of dribbles of soup in a big bowl.
  68. The food was good, but I can't forgive poor service like that from the owner.
  69. Not only does Crema Restaurante do some excellent spicy Mexican food, but there?
  70. Everything was super fresh and more flavorful than your run-of-the-mill mexican, not to mention beautiful presentation as well.
  71. The great food was accompanied by a wonderful atmosphere, and a friendly service.
  72. Would recommend the guacamole and salsa, the scallop appetizer and the sea bass for an entree.
  73. The food was tasty - especially the chilean sea bass.
  74. Amazing food!
  75. Everything was superb and the margarita imperials were tasty!
  76. The food was very nice and amazingly presented.
  77. Fancy schmancy mexican food is really good!
  78. loved-loved-loved this place--great food, great ambience, great decor.
menu variety
85.71000099182129% positive
  1. good menu options
  2. The big eye tuna and the peking duck breast were both great choices,will definitely go back.
  3. Standout selections were the "trilogy" of crispy, airy flautas.
  4. Not enough meat selections except a Filet Mignon skewer that was too expensive for me to consider.
  5. The dinner menu looks like it has a more interesting selection of entrees, but if they are even the fraction of the quality of the items we ate for lunch, I whole-heartedly advise you to make it a point and dine at Creama--if not for the drinks, then defi
  6. The food was really good, although the variety of dishes could be a little bit better.
  7. WOW - what a creative menu.
overall
87.5% positive
  1. This is a great date place or for a special occasion.
  2. Overall, a great little restaurant in Chelsea.
  3. Although there aren't are shortage of good restaurants in New York, there are few that find a special place in my heart.
  4. Crema is a chic yet comfortable, a great place to meet friends for dinner and the perfect spot for Sunday brunch before shopping on 6th ave. Bravo!
  5. think it pays to be nice to your server, especially during restaurant week when alot of people are awful.
  6. definitely a great place for sunday brunch in my opinion.
  7. This place just opened and it's already become my favorite Mexican restaurant in the city.
  8. Amazing - my new favorite restaurant!
return potential
100.0% positive
  1. The big eye tuna and the peking duck breast were both great choices,will definitely go back.
  2. normally don't eat a lot of Mexican food, but when you find a restaurant as good as this one, you tend to go back.
service
87.70000457763672% positive
  1. That was just the beginning, the waiter was very nice and explained everything to us, and was very attentive.
  2. very friendly and gave us great recommendations.
  3. The great food was accompanied by a wonderful atmosphere, and a friendly service.
  4. Most everything was really yummy and the staff was actually quite fun.
  5. The wait staff is utterly prompt and corgial, and bear an air of warm and articulate professionalism which adds to your general sense of awe towards the experience.
  6. The service was great--it was hoppin' busy, but the staff were gracious throughout.
  7. The staff is very friendly and the ambience is really great.
  8. Hostess and bartender were very nice to me which made me feel at home.
  9. The food is truly excellent, the wait staff very nice, and the ambiance is delightful (and the margaritas are yummy!)
  10. As far as the service goes, I've always been seated promptly by a warm and energetic hostess.
  11. The service was really good too, the waitresses and the hostesses were really nice too.
  12. Had a an excellent meal with equal service.
  13. We had great service.
  14. The food was excellent and very unique, the service very friendly and attentive.
  15. Very nice food and service.
  16. The extraordinary attention to detail by chef Julieta Ballesteros and the entire staff, as well as the beautiful decor and ambience, create a rare dining experience - one where you are completely transported away from the routine of your life.
  17. the Mater de was rude. After we gave him our name, he turned around and rolled his eyes and made a face. ???? Maybe they shouldn't have mirrors at the bar.
  18. Great food, uneven service
  19. but the service, not good at all.
  20. All dishes are beautifully presented and the service, which can be slow during busy times, is well above average.
  21. Great, attentive service (thanks Michael).
  22. The wait staff very friendly and efficient without being invasive or pushy.
  23. We were seated immediately, and the servers were extremely attentive.
  24. our waitress was extremely friendly and attentive and made our experience all the more enjoyable.
  25. think it pays to be nice to your server, especially during restaurant week when alot of people are awful.
  26. Interesting food, bad service, expensive
  27. While the service was very friendly, the barely edible and overpriced "food sculpture" was pompous.
  28. The food is amazing, this time i followed some people's suggestions and tried the Queso Flameado and the Flautas- both incredible.
  29. Amazing food,service and ambiance
  30. Service was friendly and wonderful.
  31. Again, the service was slow, and not particularly attentive, but just good enough.
  32. He was a very professional bartender and host.
  33. Service was attentive and the meal was nicely paced.
  34. We were welcomed so warmly by the hostess, and immediately sat us at a great table, she brang a booster for my little girl, and gave us a great smile.
  35. The service was good, but it took a looooooong time for our food to arrive.
  36. The food was good, but I can't forgive poor service like that from the owner.
  37. Outstanding food, service, and ambiance.
  38. I've lived in Manhattan long enough so I'm used to medicore service, but I just thought it was strange when paired with the amazing food.
  39. Wait staff could be a little more attentive.
  40. The chef is truly a gifted artist and everyone is so warm and friendly.
  41. agree with the editorial reviewer (that it's great food, but uneven service) but I'll give my two cents.
  42. Thoroughly enjoyable dining experience -- fantastic food, unpretentious ambience, strong drinks, and attentive service.
value
70.0% positive
  1. Skip the speciality cocktails (typical fruity overpriced concoctions) and the wine list (limited and overpriced) and head for a margarita or beer to wash down the delicious offerings.
  2. The flavors are really exquisite and unusual and the portions were a good size - even sharing we had plenty.
  3. While the service was very friendly, the barely edible and overpriced "food sculpture" was pompous.
  4. Examples: a $24 vegetarian plate (50cents worth of corn and beans, $20 for the over-sized china); $22 for chicken flautas ($4 of chicken, $18 worth of grease and salt); $8 for couple of dribbles of soup in a big bowl.
  5. The guacamole is a little pricey given the portion size but it was good nonetheless (still prefer the guacamole at dos caminos).
  6. Although all the food had great flavors, several fried dishes came out soggy and just not up to par for the price.
  7. brought clients here for lunch and it was a huge hit!
  8. The portions were plentiful and the mini-tacos and beet soup were delicious (and I don't even usually like beets!)
  9. Not enough meat selections except a Filet Mignon skewer that was too expensive for me to consider.
  10. Interesting food, bad service, expensive
wait time
66.66999816894531% positive
  1. Thank you Crema for one of the best dining experiences we've had in a long time.
  2. All dishes are beautifully presented and the service, which can be slow during busy times, is well above average.
  3. The best gourmet food I have eaten for a very long time, I have visited Crema last week for a dinner occasion and can not resist sharing my great fortune with the world.
  4. Again, the service was slow, and not particularly attentive, but just good enough.
  5. I've lived in Manhattan long enough so I'm used to medicore service, but I just thought it was strange when paired with the amazing food.
4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/13/11

Nice cozy place

by flaca1987 at Citysearch

This is a nice cozy place great atmosphere and nice decor. My boyfriend and I went here for restuarants week and we had a great time the menu was pre fixe obviously. We had the lamb sliders which were delicious I reccomend them highly, for the entree I ordered the wrong thing if you are new to organic hint dont order organic chicken that was my mistake, the desert was delicious ice cream, bananas, blue berrys. The waiters were great very nice, patient, friendly. We had a table in the back which was awesome because they had bachata, merengue, and salsa playing. I only wished they had a dance floor. Overall great place I reccomend.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

07/18/10

Great Food

by Scott 30 at Citysearch

Went to Crema the other night. Food was terrific for the most part. The service was also excellent. The waiter new when to help and when to let us enjoy our meal.

For the main meal, I had the Carne Asada which was delicious. We also got the pork taquitos which were out of this world.

We did have salsa and chips when arriving which I was not crazy about, I would have preferred pico de galo instead of the guacamole and two other salsas that accompanied them.

I would definitely go back and the Margaritas were out of this world.

  • Pros: Food
  • Cons: Price
1 Star Rating: Poor

05/05/10

Never go here

by tamaratoday at Citysearch

My friend and I went here this evening for Cinco de Mayo. We waited 45 minutes for a table (no problem as it's 2 hours everywhere else and we didn't make reservations). Once we sat down we waited and waited. I had to get up and ask a bus boy to clear the table from the people before us. My friend got up and got us menus. Then the bus boy told me to order with the maitre'd. He said that was incorrect and would send someone over. We finally got fed up with waiting we walked over to the bar to order. We waited about 25-30 mins for all of this. My food came out in 10 mins and my friends food came out 30 mins AFTER that. Holy cow. I spoke with the GM/Maitre'd and he was defensive and said we didn't have reservations and they were busy and asked 'well, what do you want me to do about it?'. We were so patient at a restaurant that wasn't nearly as busy as any other Mexican Restaurant and the GM was bordering on yelling at us. Don't go here- ever.

  • Pros: Decent drinks
  • Cons: Service was beyond rude and manager yells at customers
4 Star Rating: Recommended

03/01/10

Worth the Trip

by nw14jx at Citysearch

Had a an excellent meal with equal service.The expierence started at the bar with ginger martini served by Rescalla.He was a very professional bartender and host.The big eye tuna and the peking duck breast were both great choices,will definitely go back.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/24/10

Creative and Delicious!

by JacquelineFusaro , Citysearch Contributor at Citysearch

Despite the negative reviews, my experience was quite pleasant! I went for lunch and had tasty sangria and mexican food that was displayed in a unique way. I appreciated the artistic plating. When a dish catches my eye, it makes me want to take out my camera and snap a picture of it. That's what intrigues me and draws me back to a restaurant! Overall, the taste lived up to the looks and I left satisfied!

  • Pros: Great Food/Creative Plating
  • Cons: Pricey/Empty at Lunch

The Details on Crema Restaurante

Place Categories:

  • great schmancy mexican food
  • great uneven service
  • favorite mexican restaurant
  • great decor
  • incredible flavors
  • wonderful entire experience
  • great date place
  • slow service
  • very friendly wait staff
  • comfortable ambiance
  • really yummy most everything
  • pricey guacamole
  • very nice hostess
  • great atmosphere
  • amazing meal
  • really nice waitress
  • fantastic margaritas
  • fabulous airy flautas
  • really great ambience
  • articulate professionalism
  • very nice bartender
  • thoroughly enjoyable dining experience
  • great thanks michael
  • warm gifted artist

As Seen In…

Best of Citysearch

New York