400 E 57th St, New York, NY | Directions 1002240.758312 -73.962927
Mon-Wed: 4:30pm-1:00am Thursday: 5:00pm-2:00am Fri-Sat: 5:00pm-4:00am Sunday: 4:00pm-1:00am
Neighborhoods: Sutton Place, Midtown
Had to wait almost an hour to be sited. Was hanging out at the bar, it was crowded. The food was worth waiting for. Next time I'll have to call to reserve the place.
Best Puerto Rican food between the LES and El Barrio!!1 – Went there with a large party of 10 people, had reservations set up 2 weeks in advance. Unfortunately, our table was not ready for a little more than hour. It seems smaller parties were easier to sit though. The restaurant gave us a free round of drinks, which was a lot more you'll get in most places in NYC. The place was also very nicely decorated, with a great bar area. We sat down and enjoyed a pre-fixe menu that had been created for our group.
And the minute the food came out, any issues with waiting immediately disappeared. The food was absolutely unbelievable. Growing with a Puerto Rican mother cooking these dishes almost everyday, makes you kind of weary of eating it at restaurants and I must say that I wasn't sure if a Sofrito, on 57th and 1st, looking all sleek would be the place to go. But, I was proven completely wrong. The food was delicious and traditional. The portions were large and their prices were great. The staff was also very attentive. Aside from the long table wait (which I hope was an unusual occurrence), this place is must for anyone craving some home cooked Latin food in a more treated environment with prices that are just perfect. I can't wait to return!
Great Experience – My overall experience at Sofrito was great. It's the food and the food alone that brings me back. Is it crowded, yes. Is it loud, yes. Are the wait staff a little too pushy, yes. Do I wish I could hear, yes! But that seafood paella and that panil, wow. The empanadas, wow.
I will continue to go back and hopefully the management will heed all of the comments and continue to improve.
DINNER AT SOFRITOS – Friday was the night I was there with my husband. We met by the dining bar area and had cocktails (mojitos which was amazing). I had the paella which was absolutely delicious, the dish was so flavorful, it was a delight. The atmosphere was filled with energy, we were excited to be there. This is definitely a hot spot!
Fine dining establishments need not say they are "fine dinin – I have been coming to Sofritos for the past 5 years. Never in my life had this experience.
1. I was told that if it was 10 or me we HAD to order from a $35 restaurant week menu. (for starters, If I want something off of the regular menu, why can't I have it??. 2. I don't eat Spanish desert so my desert would have gone to waste). Your cooks are there to cook food so the excuse given was "we don't have the bandwidth to produce this food"
Well what if I placed 11 to go orders?
2. After my table of 9 sat, 2 late people attempted to join us. They used the end of the table as a guide and sat their chairs exactly how it the opposite end was seated. I was told then our orders would be canceled and we HAD to order from the pre-fixe menu by manager JOE.
Our two guess decided to sit behind us. I was told the reason was is because "we are a fine dining establishment."
First off, I've been to plenty of restaurants, i.e., Mr. Chows (where, by the way, the place your napkin on your lap). and they do not BOAST that they are fine dining. the proof is in the pudding.
Most fine dining establishments do not play music or have loud salsa bands, the hostesses actually wear PUMPS and the manager's always wears a tie, where as Joe's suit was too big, the host had a short mini skirt and flats.
I should have taken my table of 9 up the block to Cabana's and spent the $332 there. Sofritos, remember, having an "A" rating does not equate fine dining, it is the cleanliness of your kitchen amongst other things.
Would I go back.. doubt it, unless it is less than 5.
and ps..i asked 5 times for the bread (bread that is SUPPOSE to come out while you are reading the menu) But yet, his tip was included.. SMH!
Don't believe the hype – I heard such great things about this place. I went for the first time with a friend to celebrate her Bday and had to wait 2 hours (not exaggerating) to be seated. Once seated, my chair was bumped constantly by the running staff. Our server never checked in on us and when he did he never returned with what we'd requested. The music is too loud and the place is freezing. While eating we were rushed by staff and our plates snatched from under us because they needed the table. And honestly I've had better food. The Tilapia and spinach were both extremely bland.
its ok.. – The first time I went to this place I loved it. I was impressed with the food, service, decor, and music. However this was when they first opened. I went back with a friend super excited about going from previous experience. I walked in sat down and was turned off. I told my friend this is not the place I came to. The music was super loud!! We could not talk or hear what the waiter was saying. This is a resturant not a club so I think guests would want to talk during dinner. Food was not good, the waiter was not attentive and seemed like he did not want to be bothered with us. The only thing I enjoyed from my second visit was my mojito. I would not go back Sofrito lost its touch.
Bad Experience – This is not the place for you if you want to have a nice dining experience with a friend. We waited nearly an hour and were never seated and finally left. We had one drink while waiting and getting the attention of the bartender was an adventure -- no one wanted to step aside. It was much too crowded, overcapacity and a hazard. Overall spend your hardearned money someplace else where your patronage is appreciated the moment you walk through the door.
happy! – good food,great ambient(little bit cold!) very busy,good service!mofongo is great!
So junk – I would never recommend this place not even to my enemy. Everything at this place is horrible. Every type of food is salty, the place is very noisy and can't not say anything without yelling, the waitress are so low class that not even deserve the tips that they are making for every table. About USD 100 for table in one hour, like an engineer which Im sure they don't even have any college degree. They rush you to leave so they can't keep making more money and not let you enjoy your food. The sangria was made out of the cheapest red wine of the world. The ambiance was terrible plus nobody should dress for this place. I wore a very expensive and elegant dress and I step out smelling like onions and garlic. I had to wash my hair at midnight. I hope this review helps a lot of people because it is not fair to spend money In this non sense way.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Sofrito on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.