Glad we went back!!.
Came here a year ago to try it for the first time. The pizza was great, but I ordered a meatball parm hero - the meatballs were bland, the sandwich was disgustingly big and the marinara sauce was HORRIBLE. How can you order from an Italian place that can't make marinara??!!.
We heard there was a new owner, so we gave it a try - my son had been begging for the pizza. They were giving out free samples of their garlic knots (new and REALLY good) with the "new" marinara sauce. The sauce was great.
I got a chance to talk to Kim, the new owner, and I explained our first time. She told me that a lot of the recipes either already were or would be changed - just not the pizzas! She gave me one of the new meatballs to taste - yum!
My family definitely thinks it's worth taking another look at Cricco - just have it delivered - parking during the week on Kinderkamack Rd stinks!