Sugarplum Bakery

We Deliver: Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, and Mini Cupcakes!

(646) 344-1590

90 Washington Street
New York, NY 10006 40.70811 -74.01442

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Financial District (Wall Street), Downtown, Financial District

Hours:

Daily 9am-7pm (By appointment only)

Last updated 3.29.11

Category:

Bakeries, Catering

Payment Methods:

American Express, Check, Visa, Discover, Money Order, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Food Delivery

Bakery Services:

Cake Decorating

Bakery Products:

Wedding Cakes, Cake

Editor's Tips

What People Are Saying About Sugarplum Bakery

The Owner

Sugarplum Bakery

Owner

The Sugarplum Bakery specializes in delicious and beautiful custom baked cakes and cupcakes for weddings and all occasions. Our goal is to make moist and delicious cakes that taste as good as they look!Ask about our Red Velvet Bite-Size Mini Cupcakes- perfect for your next party! Send our Sugarplum Present Cake (looks just like a square package with a bow!)to your clients or friends with a customized gift tag- perfect for birthdays or any celebration! Customize cupcakes by adding hand crafted sugar art to fit your event: tiaras, poker chips, baby rattles etc...$100 minimum order.Sugarplum…

Provided by CityGrid

Read more from the owner

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

Customized cakes for weddings and birthdays as well as cupcakes can be made and sent anywhere in the NYC area.

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
Delivery prices for locations around the city vary.
ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. “The cupcakes were so fun and festive and tasted delicious; everyone raved about them all night!”
dessert
94.28999900817871% positive
  1. “Everyone in the office loved the present cake and commented on how real the bow looked.”
  2. “When the cake arrived, the design was beautiful.”
  3. “might even order a cake for myself just to eat it.”
  4. “If you really want to make a positive impression with 13 year old girls and their moms, order the Tiffany cake!”
  5. “I've tried a number of other bakeries in NYC and found Sugarplum to be the best, not only in producing a beautiful and great tasting cake, but also in "getting it": Sugarplum was professional, attentive, and accessible throughout the entire process from d”
  6. “Yummy baby shower cake!”
  7. “The cake was amazing in its presentation and taste.”
  8. “My cousin was really happy with the cake and emailed a couple of days later to make sure I thank Alicia and to tell hert they loved the baby shower cake!”
  9. “The cake's detail was an incredible rendition of High School Musical, exactly what my daughter wanted for her birthday.”
  10. “Alicia and Sugarplum Bakery are extremely easy to work with and produced a perfect cake at a very reasonable and competitive price.”
  11. “had seen an incredible Sugarplum cake that my friend ordered for a Tribeca Film Festival event and I decided to give them a try.”
  12. “Easy to use/order, everyone loved the cake”
  13. “The cake was stunning, way more than we expected.”
  14. “Alicia (the designer) was great and helped me work through the details of how large the cake should be, flavor and icing combos and most importantly, the design.”
  15. “didnt know what design I wanted, but the staff was very helpful, they told me not to worry and that the cake would look great and hip and young for a 21st birthday party.”
  16. “Everyone LOVED the cake - it was super moist and super tasty - I noticed everyone going back for seconds.”
  17. “Beautiful and great tasting cake!”
  18. “If you don't order a cake from Sugarplum Bakery you're really missing out.”
  19. “Beautiful cake that tasted great!”
  20. “The red velvet cake was fabulous, definitely one of the best I have ever had.”
  21. “It was not just great, it was outstanding, everyone loved the cake and took pictures and everything, and not only did it look great, but it was amazing, the taste was superb.”
  22. “She loves yellow cake with chocolate frosting and I thought I would get that, but make it extra special.”
  23. “used to order cakes from a french bakery in my neighborhood and I was hesitant on spending more money.”
  24. “will continue to use Alicia for birthdays, corporate events, etc., and highly recommend Sugarplum Bakery for events that require a hassle-free, dependable process and professionally-designed cakes that that taste as good as the look!”
  25. “The cupcakes were just perfect rich and moist not to over powering and the hazelnut chocolate butter cream went perfectly with the chocolate cupcakes, all in all the perfect cupcake.”
  26. “We had chocolate and vanilla, with pear buttercream, displayed in tiers - they made the perfect certerpiece for the shower.”
  27. “It was the best red velvet cake i have ever tasted.”
  28. “Incredible design, and perhaps the best cake I ever tasted”
  29. “really like chocolate that much.”
  30. “Two weeks ago, after reading the reviews on City Search, I decided to order a cake and cupcakes for a baby shower from Sugarplum Bakery.”
  31. “The adults at the party were equally impressed - all wanted to know where the cake was from.”
  32. “So many people commented that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted- including our caterer.”
  33. “didn't want a typical run-of-the-mill baby shower cake so we went through several design ideas and she came up with a unique design that was super cute and was the centerpiece of the baby shower buffet table.”
  34. “Talk about a fantastic baker and great tasting cake.”
  35. “After viewing Sugarplum Bakery on-line I called immeditaely for a cake tasting; the cakes were so creative.”
food quality
100.0% positive
  1. “Everyone LOVED the cake - it was super moist and super tasty - I noticed everyone going back for seconds.”
  2. “The cupcakes were so fun and festive and tasted delicious; everyone raved about them all night!”
  3. “had three requirements - Moist, delicious and elegant.”
service
100.0% positive
  1. “strongly recommend Sugarplum for their incredible service and, of course, an absolute first rate product.”
  2. “would recommend Sugarplum Bakery on orignailty and great customer service and they deliver.”
  3. “So many people commented that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted- including our caterer.”
  4. “I've been there during busy and not-so-busy times and have had excellent service either way.”
  5. “I've tried a number of other bakeries in NYC and found Sugarplum to be the best, not only in producing a beautiful and great tasting cake, but also in "getting it": Sugarplum was professional, attentive, and accessible throughout the entire process from d”
  6. “didnt know what design I wanted, but the staff was very helpful, they told me not to worry and that the cake would look great and hip and young for a 21st birthday party.”
value
100.0% positive
  1. “used to order cakes from a french bakery in my neighborhood and I was hesitant on spending more money.”
  2. “Alicia and Sugarplum Bakery are extremely easy to work with and produced a perfect cake at a very reasonable and competitive price.”
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/27/09

Amazing High School Cake

by vwpierce at Citysearch

Cake was delivered to venue ahead of time. The cake was stunning, way more than we expected. The cake's detail was an incredible rendition of High School Musical, exactly what my daughter wanted for her birthday. The adults at the party were equally impressed - all wanted to know where the cake was from. I will definitely be ordering from here for my son's birthday in July - a Star Wars theme.

  • Pros: Delicious, beautiful design, wowed everyone at party
  • Cons: none
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/06/09

AMAZING and HIGHLY Reccomended

by emb914 at Citysearch

My boyfriend sent me cupcakes to the office for my birthday...they were AMAZING! Not only were they beyond tasty, they were customized to me with a logo of my company, shoes, pocket books, roses, etc. Receiving this cupcakes was 10x better than getting flowers... so thoughtful and creative!!

  • Pros: tasty, creative, accomodating
  • Cons: nothing
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/23/09

Chocolate Lover's Dream!!!!

by SaraSmith73 at Citysearch

I called Sugarplum Bakery to order SOMETHING (I had know idea what I wanted) for my sister's baby shower. I spoke with the owner, Alicia, she was amazing. I explained that my sister is having a boy and that I wasn't sure what flavors I wanted. She just took charge. She asked if I wanted cake or cupcakes, then suggested that she could make cupcakes with baby rattles and put them on a tier. To which I replied "I love the sound of that". Then she suggested her chocolate cake with hazelnut chocolate butter cream. Sounds amazing right!! Well it was, she personally delivered and setup the cupcakes. They looked absolutely amazing. OMG!! They were a chocolate lover's dream. The cupcakes were just perfect rich and moist not to over powering and the hazelnut chocolate butter cream went perfectly with the chocolate cupcakes, all in all the perfect cupcake. Even my father loved them and he doesn?t really like chocolate that much. OMG! Thank you soo much for your help Alicia. I will without doubt order from Sugarplum Bakery again.

  • Pros: taste amazing
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/23/09

orignial cupcakes and they deliver

by frypanman at Citysearch

I ordered cupcakes to be sent to my girlfriend's office for her birthday from The Sugarplum Bakery. The manger asked me what I had in mind and I just thought I wanted plain cupcakes with pink icing but then they started asking me questions about her favorite flowers and what else she was into. I was really impressed by the creative ideas that she had and I ended up ordering a dozen cupcakes- half with roses and half with fashion accessories like edible handbags and makeup on top of them. The people in her office are mostly young women too and they all got a huge kick out of the cupcakes, which I am told also tasted really good too. It was very easy to do busines with them- my order was placed over the phone and I didnt even have to go into the bakery. I would recommend Sugarplum Bakery on orignailty and great customer service and they deliver.

  • Pros: Customer Service, delivery, cool designs
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/23/09

Beautiful cake that tasted great!

by LindseyF at Citysearch

I ordered my wedding cake from Sugarplum Bakery for my small reception this past December. I really didnt have any idea of what I wanted except I knew I wanted something very simple and not frilly. Alicia was amazing to work with - she came up with several ideas that fit our budget and style. She even did the delivery and set up herself. We decided on doing the Sugarcookie Cake flavor, berries and chocoalte buttercream. So many people commented that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted- including our caterer. I would definitley use them again and would recommend Sugarplum to anyone.

  • Pros: Creative designs, very easy to do business with, great taste
  • Cons: none!

The Details on Sugarplum Bakery

Place Categories:

  • great red velvet cake
  • just perfect cupcakes
  • highly recommend sugarplum bakery
  • beautiful design
  • great alicia
  • competitive price
  • loved everyone
  • amazing sound
  • incredible service
  • not loved cake
  • delicious requirements
  • wonderful professional
  • wonderful baker
  • beautiful tasting cake
  • equally impressed adults
  • loves yellow cake
  • favorite flowers
  • very helpful staff
  • yummy baby
  • best red velvet
  • very impressed guests
  • strongly recommend absolute first rate product
  • best wedding cake
  • accessible sugarplum
  • like heaven tastes

Message from Sugarplum Bakery

  • Cakes, cupcakes, mini cupcakes
  • Best Tasting Cakes in NYC!
  • Delivery Only (no storefront)

The Sugarplum Bakery specializes in delicious and beautiful custom baked cakes and cupcakes for weddings and all occasions. Our goal is to make moist and delicious cakes that taste as good as they look!

Ask about our Red Velvet Bite-Size Mini Cupcakes- perfect for your next party!

Send our Sugarplum Present Cake (looks just like a square package with a bow!)to your clients or friends with a customized gift tag- perfect for birthdays or any celebration!

Customize cupcakes by adding hand crafted sugar art to fit your event: tiaras, poker chips, baby rattles etc...

$100 minimum order.

Sugarplum happily delivers in NYC!

We do not have a storefront and do not accept walk-ins with out an appointment. Contact us in advance to place an order.

alicia@sugarplumbakerynyc.com

Sugarplum Bakery