Smith & Mills

(212) 219-8568

71 N Moore St
New York, NY 10013 40.7201 -74.0098

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Downtown, Tribeca

What People Are Saying About Smith & Mills

The Editor

Kara Zuaro

Citysearch

In Short – Marked only by a bare light bulb and its street address painted in red, this sophisticated nook is tucked inside a carriage house in the far reaches of Tribeca. Tufted banquettes hug the perimeter of the 450-square-foot space, contrasting with the more industrial elements of the decor--framed antique blueprints, metal chairs, utilitarian bar stools and weathered hardhats. Well-dressed guests stop in for quiet conversation, expertly poured cocktails, and a full menu of refined breakfast, lunch and dinner fare. – – Hits: Intimate digs, perfect pours and high-class…

1 Star Rating: Poor

10/18/09

eurotrashy nasty waitstaff

by deejayspicerack

it was uniquely euro trash, the waiter literally shoved me out of the way while I was waiting for the bathroom which is inconveniently located next to the bar. if i had my way i would've spit in his mouth, but .. have to be lady like so i just ran up a tab, and ran out... not worth the costly drinks & food when some rude waiter who relies on your tips to live, physically assaults you, a patron. this is the kind of place that gives new york a bad name.

  • Cons: natiest wait staff in nyc
1 Star Rating: Poor

05/05/09

Horrible Attitude

by carpy2000

What a great place to have such toads own and operate it. We were on vacation for two days, catching some local culture and tripped into Smith & Mills. The first drink order took a half an hour to receive after requesting the same order three times from two different people. Odd thing: There were only 8 people in the place. When a drink was set o the bar, the bartender looked at my wife and said, "Is there something wrong with it?" in a mean snooty way, to which she replied "OTher than the fact it's not mine, no." The rest of the next hour and a half only went down from there. Some people pay extra for the abuse, for us, we enjoy a faint smile, a genuine interest in delivering an order, and not being questioned when our friends left (With their baby mind you) "Hey, are they going to pay?"--I was going to pay the whole tab anyway...how many couples with a baby stiff the bartender? (Hey, maybe this is a great new ploy for all those with babies!). Just say no to this place unless you want to poke your head in, take a look then go open something similar down the street and make a mint and take their business.

  • Pros: London Bomb Shelter Vibe
  • Cons: Horrible, Offensive and Rude Service all around
4 Star Rating: Recommended

04/25/08

great ambience, good for drinks, better for brunch

by kk359

love this place when it's not too crowded...feels like a french bomb shelter from ww2 where you'll have your last drink before the luftwafa drops one on you....thats a compliment. Also like the old style elevator that;'s been turned into a bathroom(did u notice?).

Too many hipsters seemed to be bused in from Bklyn on most nites, some celebrities, sat across from Jude Law and Cameron Diaz there a few months ago, she had to wait while I was taking a leak in the elevator bathroom. Also went there for brunch. Very simple food, they cook off a hotplate it seems, but good brunch date place

  • Pros: romantic when not too crowded, good brunch
  • Cons: dirty beer drinking hipsters from brooklyn

The Details on Smith & Mills

What to Drink:

The menu offers classic cocktails like the Manhattan, Old-Fashioned and Negroni, but you can also request a delicately refreshing elderflower cocktail, made with St. Germain liqueur, champagne and soda.

Food Served:

Stop by in the morning for coffee and muesli, or complement after-work cocktails with high-class bar snacks like oysters and caviar or a braised beef baguette.

Fun Fact:

The ornate bathroom is built inside a former elevator shaft complete with intricate wrought-iron work, an antique sliding door and an old train car sink.

Category:

Restaurants, Bars & Clubs

Payment Methods:

Cash

Bar & Pub Special Features:

Bar Menu

Bar & Club Special Features:

Specialty Cocktails, After Work

Lists In Manhattan

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Smith & Mills

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

4 Star Rating: Recommended

AYZA Wine & Chocolate Bar

11 W 31st St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Ted's Montana Grill

110 W 51st St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Piola

48 E 12th St, New York, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Salsa Y Salsa

206 7th Ave, New York, NY

Advertisement