Club A Steakhouse

(212) 688-4190

240 E 58th St
New York, NY 10022 40.7604 -73.9661

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Midtown East (Turtle Bay), Midtown, Midtown East

clubasteak.com/

Years in business

Established in 1979

Hours:

Mon-Sat 5pm-11pm

Price:

$$$$

Last updated 8.14.11

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Cash, Discover, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Private Rooms, Date Spot, Group Dining, Carry Out, Private Parties

Cuisine:

Steakhouse

Notable Chef:

Jean Christophe Villard

What People Are Saying About Club A Steakhouse

Featured Review

Melanie Berliet

Contributor

In Short – The hunt for quality food and hospitality stops at this brownstone space, where the well-to-do flock for cuts of cow that don't disappoint--in portion size or tenderness. The deep red walls and upholstered chairs make for sophisticated surroundings lacking only in pretension. If you don't see the attentive owner, or his son, the manager, meandering about, you'll still feel familial warmth radiating on all three levels. Dine in the main room, or in the lounge upstairs where the pianist plays smooth music at a volume not at odds with dinner conversation. Preface your entree with…

Editor's Tips

The Extras:
Dine to the tune of live music in the second floor lounge, courtesy of in-house musical director and renowned pianist Daniel Nye. (Every Wed-Sat until 2am.)
Fun Fact:
Club A's menu was designed by the restaurant's Executive Chef, the French-trained Jean Christophe Villard, formerly of Bobby Van's fame.
ambiance
92.9800033569336% positive
  1. could have chat and drank all night, thanks to the comfortable atmosphere and attentive service.
  2. There's always a really good vibe too - sometimes we sit upstairs where there's a piano player, who's really fun.
  3. The service and atmosphere (not to mention the fantastic piano player) added to the ambiance of the whole dining experience.
  4. It's a great atmosphere for a date, a night out with friends or entertaining clients.
  5. Great food and a wonderful atmosphere
  6. The service is outstanding and the ambiance is very warm and welcoming.
  7. Ambience is both comfortable, intimate, relaxing.
  8. The atmosphere was comfortable and the service was friendly and professional.
  9. The place is so beautiful, beautiful people, great atmosphere !
  10. The service is professional, considerate & diligent, and the atmosphere is fantastic.
  11. great service, cozy and comfortable atmosphere and food is excellent!
  12. They have it all - food, atmosphere and the very best service in the city.
  13. After about a half hour, Bruno( the owner) brought us upstairs to a table in a nice romantic, red velvet style room.
  14. have yet to find a restaurant with a more enjoyable atmosphere than I experienced at Club A this past weekend.
  15. brought my wife, daughter , and her boyfriend ,and the atmosphere was so nice we stayed for 3 hours.
  16. It creates a very warm and inviting atmosphere.
  17. From the intriguing ambiance (sultry) to the attentive, knowledgeable staff- Club A is a new Hot-Spot.
  18. re trying to enjoy an expensive, romantic dinner.
  19. Great service, atmosphere, food and etc.
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. From the appetizers to the dessert, everything was amazing!
  2. ..We didn't even want to look at the desert menu because we were full with our delicious porterhouse.
  3. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts.
  4. We also had Key lime pie for dessert- very good.
drinks
100.0% positive
  1. The great variety of wines just makes it perfect.
  2. The wine cellar is excellent, too.
  3. Always a big plus when waiters go the extra step to decant a bottle of wine.
  4. Everything was fantastic right down to the wine.
  5. so its expected), we didn't mind, We were enjoying time with eachother just talking & enjoying great wine.
  6. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts.
  7. The wine list is great and the prices are very reasonable.
  8. While the restaurant wine list is not large, it has some good bottles of wine to match the cuisine and they are reasonably priced.
  9. Steak & Chops was cooked to perfection, the sides were yummy and the pairing of wines were superb.
food quality
95.3499984741211% positive
  1. My favorite, filet mignon is so delicious and cooked perfectly I can never have enough.
  2. My husband actually loves the chicken (he's weird); I'm a vegetarian so I go for the jumbo shrimp scampi, absolutely delicious or lobster ravioli, best I've ever had.
  3. The food is amazing.
  4. While the restaurant wine list is not large, it has some good bottles of wine to match the cuisine and they are reasonably priced.
  5. The blue fin tuna was fresh, seared rare and served with two delicious sauces on the side.
  6. particularly love the onion soup followed by a juicy filet mignon and a side of the mouth-watering five cheeses truffle "mac
  7. The place is gorgeous and the food is great!
  8. recommend every dish!
  9. The shrimp served with two sauces is a brilliant starter and the vegetables are unforgettable.
  10. They have it all - food, atmosphere and the very best service in the city.
  11. Steak & Chops was cooked to perfection, the sides were yummy and the pairing of wines were superb.
  12. In addition to great steaks, the fish is perfectly prepared and the sides are outstanding.
  13. great service, cozy and comfortable atmosphere and food is excellent!
  14. Excellent steaks, none better
  15. The steaks were the juiciest, the Brussels sprouts roasted with bacon were amazing, and the baked potato was almost the size of a football, good thing we didn't order two!
  16. If you live on the U.E.S and you love steak as much as I do, this is the place.
  17. In a neighborhood full of beef joints that are past prime or depending on an outdated reputation with uniform mediocrity, Club A is the place to go.
  18. The steak is as good as any place in the city.
  19. This is the best steak I have ever had!
  20. From the friendly staff, to the amazing food and service and thereafter you head up to the piano room.
  21. Great food and a wonderful atmosphere
  22. Great food
  23. ..We didn't even want to look at the desert menu because we were full with our delicious porterhouse.
  24. Sides were all really good too(Mac & Cheese with truffle oil & brussel sprouts with bacon)
  25. The food is of the best quality and cooked to perfection by the French chef (who we got to meet) from Bobby Van's.
  26. The food was average for a steakhouse, but nothing could make up for the tacky entertainment and horrible service.
  27. By far the best combination of steak, seafood and side dishes I've had in NYC and the service was outstanding.
  28. You'll go here for the steak but everything is so fresh you will come back again and again.
  29. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts.
  30. tried various items on the menu- the ones that really stick out are noted here: Sherry & Aged Gruyere Onion Soup was AMAZING- Great twist on the traditional French Onion, the Caesar Salad was just perfect and the U-7 Shrimp Cocktail were large and tasty
  31. The service was excellent, and the food was absolutely amazing!
  32. Great service, atmosphere, food and etc.
  33. the Caesar salad is excellent
  34. Finally, I don't have to go far for a good steak!
  35. The Chef happened to be in the dining room and we stopped him to tell him how great the food was, he was very pleasant.
  36. My filet mignon was perfectly cooked and the unique side dishes were a perfect complement ( especially the truffle macaronni and cheese - a MUST try!
  37. My wife is Greek and said it was the best lamb she ever had.
  38. The meat was tender, the fish was really fresh and the sides were really good and I am not a fan of vegs!
  39. Great Atmosphere,service, food and hospitality
  40. Prime Aged bone-in ribeyes were cooked to a perfect medium-rare with a crust that I will use as my standard for all future steaks.
  41. My brother-in-law who is a steak connaisseur loves the perfectly cooked filet mignon every single time.
  42. We all agreed the food was as good as any at the "name" steak
  43. went to Club A Steakhouse on Valentines day with my girlfriend & had a delicious meal.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. The great variety of wines just makes it perfect.
  2. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts.
  3. tried various items on the menu- the ones that really stick out are noted here: Sherry & Aged Gruyere Onion Soup was AMAZING- Great twist on the traditional French Onion, the Caesar Salad was just perfect and the U-7 Shrimp Cocktail were large and tasty
  4. ..We didn't even want to look at the desert menu because we were full with our delicious porterhouse.
  5. Seated promptly, Nicky our waiter covered each menu item with a description- his knowledge of the menu was exceptional and he had great recommendations.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. The steak is as good as any place in the city.
  2. Club A owners and staff have a great place here!
  3. It's a great restaurant.
  4. The service was first class, very nice place, perfect for a date, we will certainly be back.
return potential
100.0% positive
  1. You'll go here for the steak but everything is so fresh you will come back again and again.
  2. The service was first class, very nice place, perfect for a date, we will certainly be back.
service
88.00000190734863% positive
  1. The service was excellent, and the food was absolutely amazing!
  2. The owner, Bruno, is charming and attentive to his guests.
  3. From the intriguing ambiance (sultry) to the attentive, knowledgeable staff- Club A is a new Hot-Spot.
  4. The service is outstanding and the ambiance is very warm and welcoming.
  5. The service is professional, considerate & diligent, and the atmosphere is fantastic.
  6. The service and atmosphere (not to mention the fantastic piano player) added to the ambiance of the whole dining experience.
  7. Seated promptly, Nicky our waiter covered each menu item with a description- his knowledge of the menu was exceptional and he had great recommendations.
  8. The food was average for a steakhouse, but nothing could make up for the tacky entertainment and horrible service.
  9. Club A owners and staff have a great place here!
  10. From the friendly staff, to the amazing food and service and thereafter you head up to the piano room.
  11. The service was friendly and professional.
  12. The service was first class, very nice place, perfect for a date, we will certainly be back.
  13. could have chat and drank all night, thanks to the comfortable atmosphere and attentive service.
  14. They have it all - food, atmosphere and the very best service in the city.
  15. Nicky made our dining experience memorable, we never lacked for attentive service.
  16. great service, cozy and comfortable atmosphere and food is excellent!
  17. Great Atmosphere,service, food and hospitality
  18. Go there on a date or friendly gathering, doesn't matter with who, because once dinner is served you'll no longer acknowledge your guest.
  19. horrible, excruciatingly slow service (so bad you become ?
  20. The place is so beautiful, beautiful people, great atmosphere !
  21. Great service, atmosphere, food and etc.
  22. Always a big plus when waiters go the extra step to decant a bottle of wine.
  23. The atmosphere was comfortable and the service was friendly and professional.
  24. The staff was professional and attentive.
  25. By far the best combination of steak, seafood and side dishes I've had in NYC and the service was outstanding.
value
91.66999816894531% positive
  1. We ordered a nice bottle of california cabernet (Faust & at the the price they sell it at, it's definitely a deal).
  2. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts.
  3. The wine list is great and the prices are very reasonable.
  4. re trying to enjoy an expensive, romantic dinner.
wait time
50.0% positive
  1. I'm used to traveling all the way downtown or even as far a brooklyn for a good porterhouse but thanks to a friends recommendation those long rides are OVER.
  2. horrible, excruciatingly slow service (so bad you become ?
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/03/12

Fantastic Experience!

by CWDFLUSHING

Recently our company had a year-end celebration dinner at Club A Steakhouse, we were able to reserve their "wine cellar" private room which is a FANTASTIC setting. The steak was out-of-this-world... you have to try the porterhouse! Their Wine list is wonderful and staff was excellent. I would not hesitate to recommend this place to everyone I know that enjoys a good steak and great atmosphere!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/14/10

The best steak in years!

by merchant810779270831

I've worked in the neighborhood for years and just stumbled upon Club A last week. I have to say it was the tastiest steak I've had in years. Great atmosphere and very good food. Try the french onion soup it was outrageous!

1 Star Rating: Poor

06/08/09

Not good for catering

by BMort25

Was with a large party on Saturday night; staff was completely unprepared for us. Everything went wrong and made a special evening turn out to be less special. Food, drinks and staff were not organized.

  • Pros: Multi Level
  • Cons: Not good for big crowds
2 Star Rating: Below Average

05/28/09

Not so greta

by TimRim1

Been here a few times and food was always outstanding; asked for the Chef and he is no longer here. Needless to say, the food is not up to par anymore. It's either overcooked or undercooked; salty or not seasoned enough. Disappointing.

  • Pros: Ambience
  • Cons: Food went down hill
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/01/09

Top 3 steaks in in Manhattan

by ChefKreemy

Formerly Bruno's, a friend and I popped into Club A last night, having not heard much talk as to whether any good or not as a steakhouse. Lobster and Escargot to start were good, though escargot could have used more garlic. After that, it got amazing: 24oz. Prime Aged bone-in ribeyes were cooked to a perfect medium-rare with a crust that I will use as my standard for all future steaks. 5-cheese truffle mac and glazed brussel sprouts w/ bacon were two of the best sides I've ever had, affordable wine selections, and wonderful desserts. Service rivaled the food and owner/management, Bruno and Agron Selimaj, treat you like family. This was truly one of the best overall dining experiences I've had in recent memory and is going in my Top 3 for steakhouses. They really do a great job and I will definitely be bringing guests here frequently from now on.

  • Pros: Perfect steaks, amazing sides, outstanding service
  • Cons: none

The Details on Club A Steakhouse

Place Categories:

  • professional attentive service
  • great atmosphere
  • great food
  • great steak
  • enjoy romantic dinner
  • professional knowledgeable staff
  • outstanding thank you club a everything
  • very nice place
  • horrible excruciatingly slow service
  • equally good porterhouse
  • really good vibe
  • very good dessert
  • particularly love gruyere onion soup
  • charming bruno
  • just perfect caesar salad
  • nice red velvet style room
  • celebrate birthday club a
  • nice bottle
  • absolutely delicious ravioli
  • really fun piano player
  • welcoming ambiance
  • loves brotherinlaw
  • full neighborhood
  • truly wonderful first experience
  • charming owner
Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement