(212) 563-5331

488 9th Ave
New York, NY 10018 40.755408 -73.994831

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Garment District, Midtown

MANGANAROS.COM

Years in business

Established in 1893

Last updated 2.10.12

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Ethnic Market Products:

Italian Food Products

Restaurant Special Features:

Lunch Spot

Cuisine:

Italian

What People Are Saying About Manganaros

Featured Review

Josh Ozersky

Contributor

Hell's Kitchen may be Clinton to its newer residents, but it's still Hell's Kitchen to the Maganaro family, who have been operating this tiny, unchanged grocery and sandwich shop for three generations, and who continue to turn out Italian cold cut sandwiches, meatball and veal heroes, and even a few pasta dishes exactly as they did since opening in the 50s. There's dust from back then, too, but history comes with a price.

Editor's Tips

Know Before You Go:
There's another place named Managanos next door, a hated family rival. Don't bring them up.
Parking:
Theater parking takes up all available street spaces.
Fun Fact:
Manganaro's is very close to the Lincoln Tunnel entrance, so it's a great stop on the way out of town.
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. Even after purchasing the cookies she acted like she did us this big favor for just waiting on us.
  2. Just as my date was about to order some cookies the lady behind the counter started yelling at this young boy who worked there.
  3. My girlfriend order the cookies and put a ten dollar bill on the counter.
food quality
75.0% positive
  1. didn't even mind the prices until I got rude service and poor food.
  2. would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for rare olive oils, cheeses and amazing Italian sandwiches.
  3. went in last week with a friend because she was hungry, now, I am not one to impress but everyone always looks to me when they are trying to find authentic New York places.
  4. went in yesterday to grab a famous sandwich and I was amazed at the rare Italian products this place has to offer.
  5. The lasagna was good, decent portion with big chunks of meat, not ground meat.
  6. Authentic food in an environment you won't find anywhere else.
  7. This is the best italian sandwich meat you will ever encounter on the island.
  8. Since passing on this story EVERY SINGLE PERSON I've spoken to who has ever been there says the same thing, it's dirty, the food is awful and watery and the service is a nightmare.
service
50.0% positive
  1. It's rude, nasty, dirty, dusty and should be closed by the Board of Health.
  2. didn't even mind the prices until I got rude service and poor food.
  3. Since passing on this story EVERY SINGLE PERSON I've spoken to who has ever been there says the same thing, it's dirty, the food is awful and watery and the service is a nightmare.
  4. The staff was nice and made me feel like I was at home.
  5. More often than usual, I will buy something if people are nice and friendly, I will feel guilty if i don't buy anything.
  6. The service wasn't rude, wasn't unfriendly, just no nonsense, "NEXT
value
33.3299994468689% positive
  1. We didn't mind the price but the attitude of the woman behind the counter was just terrible.
  2. didn't even mind the prices until I got rude service and poor food.
  3. My girlfriend order the cookies and put a ten dollar bill on the counter.
wait time
100.0% positive
  1. This restaurant was recommended to me by a New Yorker, so I took the subway and walked a long way to get some authentice Italian.
1 Star Rating: Poor

04/26/11

TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE

by kosey

It's unfortunate that others had a similarly terrible experience to mine. The reality check that in fact I had NOT done anything wrong by simply entering the store is a bit of a relief though... There must be something very wrong with the woman who works there. I won't speculate what, but it must be bad. She's not stable. However, the verbal abuse I received makes it tough to be empathetic. I felt the need to offer fair warning to others who might be seduced by the interesting interior to enter the store. Why take the chance that you'll be abused? Nobody needs that. You have to walk the entire length of the store for this abuse as well, as the food counter is located at the very back of a very long store. And then, after she has gone off on you and you turn around to leave because of course you would not think of ordering anything to eat there, you have to listen to her continued rant as it trails after you. Very unsettling and a real downer.

1 Star Rating: Poor

02/28/10

Stay Away

by Busby

Have been to Managaro many times, poked head in today as we were not sure if it was open and the little woman owner came running from the back... we asked if they were open 'cause it was empty and she said--Do you want to eat or do you want company? She was rude and nasty and as we turned to leave, she called us tourists, ( we are native New Yorker's) with big noses (Jews) and yelled at us while we walked down the street.

We will NEVER go there again. Not only was she rude but anti-semetic.

  • Pros: Used to Be good
  • Cons: Woman Owner is a shrew
1 Star Rating: Poor

01/14/10

Give this place a skip

by Ruth Peltason

I used to come here and when I was back in the neighborhood and needed to treat some clients to lunch, I thought this would be fun,. I didn't even mind the prices until I got rude service and poor food. The women are bossy and pushy, demand cash, the place was empty and dusty. That's before the food, My $11 sandwich was on terrible, had very little salami, 2 chunks of cheese with the peel on, and pathetic toppings. For that much money, I expected a classy sandwich and some sort of side. Very irritating and disappointing. I simply can't recommend it to anyone for anything. Even the fun grocery items are gone.

  • Pros: None any more
  • Cons: Rude service, no bang for the buck
1 Star Rating: Poor

01/04/10

Scrooge lives!!

by CSMobileUser2

My husband and I stopped in with hopes of taking some italian delicacies home for christmas. We were disappointed to find a nonexistant inventory. we were then dismayed when the woman staffing the place informed us to confine our sightseeing to a museum if we didn't plan to buy anything from her. Needless to say, we were shocked by the abuse, especially given what little she had to offer. her behavior was reprehensible and ruined an otherwise lovely christmas trip to the city.

1 Star Rating: Poor

11/15/09

Totally Rude & Inflexible

by Bkid

I have been eating at NY Italian Delis my whole life and I have never had such a horrible experience as I did at Manganaro Foods & Restaurant. The lady who was working there was unnecessarily rude from the minute I walked in. I asked them to make a basic chicken sandwich with roasted peppers and greens and she snapped "order off the menu only!" There were only three hot sandwiches on the menu?? What kind of NY

deli only has 3 options and won't customize? So I ordered a basic chicken parm and asked if she could put sauce on it and she said.."no only oil and vinegar on sandwiches!!" What?, who does this lady think she is??..I told her forget it..i'm leaving and she yelled "good go make it at home!" She was so obnoxious it was comical, and it's not like they had a good selection of food. Do yourself a favor and don't go here, visit the unrelated Manganaro's Heroboy next door, much better and friendlier.

  • Pros: Nothing
  • Cons: Rude, Boring Menu, Etc...

The Details on Manganaros

Place Categories:

  • awful food
  • bad attitude
  • worst place
  • rude dusty
  • decent portion
  • nice people
  • order cookies
  • amazing italian sandwiches
  • famous sandwich
  • authentic new york places
  • best italian sandwich meat
  • good mmmmm
  • nice staff
  • big favor
  • recommended restaurant
  • good mmmm
  • rude service
  • big chunks
Advertisement

Featured In

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement