| ambiance |
71.4300012588501% positive |
- “
The atmosphere is not for the faint of heart (the lines, the crowded, the bus-your-own-everything, the sawdust on the floor, the nasty bathroom, the don't-lose-your-ticket-or-else). ”
- “
It never ceases to amaze me when people write negative reviews of excellent, cheap-eats type places and fault them for their spartan decor, surly puryeors, and basic service. ”
- “
Dingy but colorful, great food, huge portions -- and just plain lots of fun. ”
- “
The food is still good but I wish the ambience was what is was 20-25 years ago. ”
- “
This was once a fun place full of character, now it is a disgusting dirty get them in get them out factory with rude help and the worst food in the city. ”
- “
Fabulous old decor & the best food we had on our recent trip to NYC. ”
- “
Yes, it has an authentic Old Manhattan atmosphere, which is harder and harder to find these days, and it serves a decent corned beef sandwich. ”
|
| dessert |
100.0% positive |
- “
enjoy an egg cream or a cel-ray soda with your meal. ”
- “
had a chopped liver sandwich and a vanilla egg cream, and my husband enjoyed a pastrami Reuben with a chocolate egg cream. ”
- “
An egg cream should be in a nice soda glass for over $4. ”
|
| drinks |
0.0% positive |
- “
The Pastrami sandwich was like "buttah" and with pickles and an icy cold beer to wash it down, it was a pleasurable experience. ”
- “
Sandwich & a cold beer and you're all set! ”
|
| food quality |
74.40000057220459% positive |
- “
The turkey's great too and the steak fries are about as good as frozen steak fries can get. ”
- “
Now, the sandwich was extremely good -- but it should have been for $14.95. ”
- “
Cool nostalgic vibe to it and I LOVE the sample they give you while you're waiting for your sandwich to be made. ”
- “
Decent corned beef; deplorable service ”
- “
Go to Kennsington Deli in Great Neck for a good tasting Kosher sandwich. ”
- “
terrible pastrami and corned beef. ”
- “
My matzoh ball soup was very mediocre. ”
- “
was able to finally visit this legendary deli earlier this year and ordered their famous pastrami sandwich. ”
- “
The pastrami sandwich overflows with juicy goodness, and I can't get enough of the fresh pickles. ”
- “
had a great corned beef sandwich at Katz and that was without tipping beforehand because I only had large-denomination bills in my wallet. ”
- “
I'll be honest, the sandwich was greasy, heavy, and one of the best pastrami sandwiches I've ever had! ”
- “
The latkes I have to say might be the best I have ever had, thin and crisp with the perfect potato flavor. ”
- “
An egg cream should be in a nice soda glass for over $4. ”
- “
the pastrami is delicious, and my fave sandwich. ”
- “
Matzoh ball soup should be piping hot, a great chicken broth and the matzoh ball should be flavorful and hot. ”
- “
Katz's is old New York at it's authentic and contemporary best. ”
- “
Want abuse and overpriced food? ”
- “
My friend and I didn't like the corned beef, maybe because we were already full on the pastrami. ”
- “
but i must admit that the pastrami sandwich looked great on TV, so i decided to give Katz Deli a try. ”
- “
If you're hesitant that it's the best kosher deli, just stop in and try a pastrami sandwich. ”
- “
this place is hands down the best pastrami sandwich you'll ever have in your life. ”
- “
Great portions on the sandwiches. ”
- “
the prices have obviously gone up since then and now i don't go often, but i know it's the place to go for a nice family meal that we'll all like. ”
- “
You will not be disappointed with the juicy, crisp outside, tangy meat. ”
- “
Dear God without doubt-the best sweet potato knish's and also some of the best pickles you can come by! ”
- “
tried the pastrami and corned beef (both warm), and the cold roast beef - all were good, but not quite $10-13 good, for such a small sandwich. ”
- “
The food is still good but I wish the ambience was what is was 20-25 years ago. ”
- “
the soup is COLD and disgusting. ”
- “
Although I didn't enjoy my bill, I did enjoy the sandwiches. ”
- “
The pickles that accompanied the sandwiches were excellent. ”
- “
Thirdly, I just cannot recommend this place because the chaos the ordering system is, the reliance on tickets that can be lost (it also bespeaks of how much they trust the customer - or are hoping they lose their ticket), the bleh non-meat food, the miser ”
- “
don't miss out on a plate full of fresh dill pickles. ”
- “
The sandwich is huge, the pastrami is tender, hand cut, juicy. ”
- “
While the sandwiches are not the very best I have ever eaten, I found the meat, the pastrami in particular, to be quite tasty. ”
- “
While there are plenty of places to go for a good corned beef sandwich, Katz's has a charm about it. ”
- “
But the food was terrible -- and expensive! ”
- “
The pastrimi sandwich is simply the BEST in the city. ”
- “
This is not justifiable---the portions are small, the food is disgusting, the staff rude, and the environment filthy. ”
- “
had a chopped liver sandwich and a vanilla egg cream, and my husband enjoyed a pastrami Reuben with a chocolate egg cream. ”
- “
LOVE their pastrami sandwich on rye. ”
- “
They will give you a sample while slicing the meat, and the sandwiches are big enough to easily share (no charge either!) ”
- “
The meats (pastrami, corned beef and tongue) are quite good (note: NOT best) but don't have anything else. ”
- “
The pastrami sandwich was outstanding! ”
- “
If you are in search of the most authentic NYC deli experience look no further than the famous and historic Katz's Deli down on the Lower East Side. ”
- “
As a big meat eater I must recommend the hot Pastrami. ”
- “
The food is amazingly good and I am thankful for having encountered it. ”
- “
Dingy but colorful, great food, huge portions -- and just plain lots of fun. ”
- “
would definitely visit again and bring friends from the Philippines over, hopefully to try the famous corned beef and salami next time. ”
- “
The food is still as good now as when I was a kid. ”
- “
Katz's Deli is the most overrated food place I've ever been to, On a recent visit we were served dry tasteless french fries, a plate of pick. ”
- “
The delicious pastrami, corned beef, salami, tongue, etc. also remain the same. ”
- “
Kosher dills are the perfect compliment for your unforgetable sandwich and they give you plenty of them. ”
- “
their corn beef and the pastrami are the best that money can buy and one sandwich is enough for two ”
- “
The soup was nice but wasn't too convinced by the Matzoh ball. ”
- “
The other food there outside of the Pastrami that is good corned beef. ”
- “
This was once a fun place full of character, now it is a disgusting dirty get them in get them out factory with rude help and the worst food in the city. ”
- “
don't see how anyone can think you'll get a better pastrami sandwich anywhere, and the hot dogs are the best around. ”
- “
Overall, great food and good experience. ”
- “
They'll usually give you a sample piece while they make your sandwich, and it's that first bite that always puts a smile on my face and makes me remember why Katz's is so good. ”
- “
The no-frills matzo ball soup is also very good, and never forget to order a side of half-sour pickles! ”
- “
The matzoh ball soup is the best i've ever eaten and this includes homemade recipes from my jewish relatives. ”
- “
The only thing is the food was just awful. ”
- “
The Pastrami was juicy and delicious with enough meat to feed 2. ”
- “
Last night me and my partner REALLY wanted a GOOD pastrami and corned beff sandwich. ”
- “
Only once did I have a piled high sandwich that was not very enjoyable that was more like it was from the Carnegie del. ”
- “
As a native New Yorker, I've been going to delis, including Katz's, my whole life, so I know a thing or two about good corned beef and pastrami. ”
- “
Wish they would grace their meat with some better bread, but the plain Jane rye provided a nice blank canvas, in a sense. ”
- “
Excellent sandwiches! ”
- “
The Pastrami sandwich was like "buttah" and with pickles and an icy cold beer to wash it down, it was a pleasurable experience. ”
- “
Also do keep in mind that it's probably also going to be one of the most expensive sandwiches you'll ever eat. ”
- “
Heres the thing yeah its a good sandwich but so what for this price $$$$ you can have a very good meal almost anywhere in NYC so save your money. ”
- “
The food is awful. ”
- “
love the quality of the food ”
- “
The food is wonderful it is the best deli. ”
- “
Well maybe its becaue once I did get my sandwich it was very good. ”
- “
french fries, Cole Slaw and pickles were all good. ”
- “
The corned beef was good too but a bit dry for my taste - maybe because I ordered it lean. ”
- “
The meat was warm and thickly sliced - not like the pastrami you buy at the deli that is cold and sliced thin on a machine. ”
- “
Matzoh ball soup was tasteless, pickles were limp and fries were mostly soggy and greasy. ”
- “
Potato salad - vomitable; one bite and I felt sick. ”
- “
enjoy an egg cream or a cel-ray soda with your meal. ”
- “
The corned beef Rueben was terrible --the meat was dry and the sandwich was greasy. ”
- “
Before I lay into them I will say that the meat (on the reuben) is 'good' but no better than what you can find at a good BBQ joint where the meat is tender and juicy and about three times less expensive. ”
- “
for those who don't like the food. ”
- “
Fabulous old decor & the best food we had on our recent trip to NYC. ”
- “
The reuben is an astounding $15.75 complete with tasteless rye bread and sauerkraut with metled cheese direct from the. ”
- “
Pastrami or corned beef are juicy and piled high (ask for extra rye bread). ”
- “
It seemed to me that Katz's attracts a good many tourists but this native New Yorker will still occasionally return to Katz's when I am feeling nostalgia for some tasty, old time deli. ”
- “
Sometimes I'll go with potato salad or a knish on the side, because you can't go wrong with either of those, and occasionally I'll have one of their delicious hot dogs as a prelude to my pastrami. ”
- “
Love the matzo balls and chopped chicken liver. ”
- “
Yes, it has an authentic Old Manhattan atmosphere, which is harder and harder to find these days, and it serves a decent corned beef sandwich. ”
- “
This was not just the worst meal of the year, but perhaps of the decade and century! ”
- “
The meat is ok (not good, but not vomitable) on the sandwich, but the radiation cheese and sauerkraut are gross. ”
- “
I'm not a pastrami/corned beef fan so when I got to Katz's, it's for the best hot dogs (mustard, saurkraut) in the city, snappy and fresh, and knishes, kasha-filled and hot and crispy, amazingly comforting with brown mustard. ”
- “
If they were actually well managed they would have a happier staff, the place wouldn't look like a dive, which it is, it wouldn't be a riddle to find out how to get service, it wouldn't be a surprise that there is 'waiter' service, there wouldn't be table ”
- “
Corned beef is also excellent but by nature it is not as flavorful or moist. ”
- “
the food is that good! ”
|
| overall |
75.0% positive |
- “
If you are a vegetarian, this really isn't a good place to go. ”
- “
The place is the best place on the East Coast for Pastrami and has been rated by many people. ”
- “
It's the best place i NYC. ”
- “
am really surprised to see here those great reviews and all those pictures of famous people hanging in the big hall of the restaurant. ”
|
| return potential |
50.0% positive |
- “
took my family here for the real deli experience, and I'll never go back, the service is deplorable, the staff is rude, and the prices are ridiculous. ”
- “
It seemed to me that Katz's attracts a good many tourists but this native New Yorker will still occasionally return to Katz's when I am feeling nostalgia for some tasty, old time deli. ”
|
| service |
42.58999824523926% positive |
- “
This is not justifiable---the portions are small, the food is disgusting, the staff rude, and the environment filthy. ”
- “
The waitress was nice, but the others were indifferent or surly. ”
- “
The waitresses are nice--also you can just get counter service & sit. ”
- “
am really surprised to see here those great reviews and all those pictures of famous people hanging in the big hall of the restaurant. ”
- “
People who work there are good people. ”
- “
The staff knows their stuff and the owners are professional and on the ball. ”
- “
can only surmise that people have never had decent pastrami to compare this dreck with. ”
- “
Dingy w/ yellowed pictures of all the famous people IE President Clinton after 2 hot dogs and a pastami WOW howed he do that, Jerry Lewis, and of coarse Harry & Sally. ”
- “
you are shuffled around by hang dog bus people who apologize profusely about the rude management who close down sections you are eating in and make you move. ”
- “
If they were actually well managed they would have a happier staff, the place wouldn't look like a dive, which it is, it wouldn't be a riddle to find out how to get service, it wouldn't be a surprise that there is 'waiter' service, there wouldn't be table ”
- “
Our waiter was rude, and tried to serve me a bagel with lox and creme cheese on a cinnamon raisin bagel. ”
- “
Decent corned beef; deplorable service ”
- “
The staff is very, very rude. ”
- “
took my family here for the real deli experience, and I'll never go back, the service is deplorable, the staff is rude, and the prices are ridiculous. ”
- “
The place is the best place on the East Coast for Pastrami and has been rated by many people. ”
- “
It never ceases to amaze me when people write negative reviews of excellent, cheap-eats type places and fault them for their spartan decor, surly puryeors, and basic service. ”
- “
Service is always a bit mediocre and the seating is not great because its a cafeteria but youre not there for the seating or the service, your there for the legendary pastrami and thats what youll get. ”
- “
This was once a fun place full of character, now it is a disgusting dirty get them in get them out factory with rude help and the worst food in the city. ”
- “
Please ignore all reviews that say this place is terrible and mark it with one star, it is not meant to be a 5 star restaurant with crisp white linens and impeccable waiter service. ”
- “
the people were rude and i will never step foot in this "landmark" again. ”
- “
If you are going to make people wait on the disgusting line, then you should use the same method that banks employ. ”
- “
These people are rude. ”
- “
The service was excellent. ”
- “
There were other people on my line that were getting really mad, cursing under their breath about our guy and your poor system of service. ”
- “
Expensive, dirty, rude. ”
- “
Thirdly, I just cannot recommend this place because the chaos the ordering system is, the reliance on tickets that can be lost (it also bespeaks of how much they trust the customer - or are hoping they lose their ticket), the bleh non-meat food, the miser ”
- “
the staff was rude, and the area where you could be served by a waitress had people waiting like vultures for the next available table! ”
|
| value |
56.479997634887695% positive |
- “
Want abuse and overpriced food? ”
- “
Thirdly, I just cannot recommend this place because the chaos the ordering system is, the reliance on tickets that can be lost (it also bespeaks of how much they trust the customer - or are hoping they lose their ticket), the bleh non-meat food, the miser ”
- “
Before I lay into them I will say that the meat (on the reuben) is 'good' but no better than what you can find at a good BBQ joint where the meat is tender and juicy and about three times less expensive. ”
- “
Great portions on the sandwiches. ”
- “
I've had equally large portions at Carnegie and Stage delis which were painfully dry. ”
- “
But the food was terrible -- and expensive! ”
- “
Dingy but colorful, great food, huge portions -- and just plain lots of fun. ”
- “
Heres the thing yeah its a good sandwich but so what for this price $$$$ you can have a very good meal almost anywhere in NYC so save your money. ”
- “
huge rip-off. ”
- “
It never ceases to amaze me when people write negative reviews of excellent, cheap-eats type places and fault them for their spartan decor, surly puryeors, and basic service. ”
- “
WAY too expensive! ”
- “
their corn beef and the pastrami are the best that money can buy and one sandwich is enough for two ”
- “
Also do keep in mind that it's probably also going to be one of the most expensive sandwiches you'll ever eat. ”
- “
The sandwich is huge, the pastrami is tender, hand cut, juicy. ”
- “
the prices have obviously gone up since then and now i don't go often, but i know it's the place to go for a nice family meal that we'll all like. ”
- “
The pastrami was excellent, and half was enough to fill me but I'm not sure if it's worth $15. ”
- “
This is not justifiable---the portions are small, the food is disgusting, the staff rude, and the environment filthy. ”
- “
took my family here for the real deli experience, and I'll never go back, the service is deplorable, the staff is rude, and the prices are ridiculous. ”
|
Deals
share
@katzsdeli | Facebook |