| ambiance |
100.0% positive |
- “
The atmosphere is incredible and the food. ”
- “
Lovely ambiance coupled with a delicious and well-prepared meal make for a perfect dining experience. ”
- “
Parking is ample; the location is great if you are in LM. ”
- “
their soups are fantastic and the atmosphere is excellent. ”
- “
To sum it up, the service, food, staff and decor were incredible. ”
- “
The layout and decor are great. ”
- “
The decor is lovely, the service is warm&attentive and the food is divine. ”
- “
like to have a cool, fun, or romantic atmosphere when I'm paying these kinds of prices. ”
- “
The food was exquisite, the service impeccable and the atmosphere elegant (with a tad corporate air feel). ”
- “
loved the ambience and the service was great. ”
- “
The setting was stuffy for a young couple looking for a romantic spot - the wine steward was amazed when we showed a basic knowledge of grapes, and the couple next to us were in their 80s (they informed us of this proudly) and on their 2nd date. ”
- “
The rack of lambs are to die for, the service is great, the ambiance is perfect. ”
- “
The dining room has great lighting and a nice ambience, with beautiful white drapey things hanging from the ceiling. ”
|
| dessert |
90.0% positive |
- “
The menu offers 3 savory courses and dessert, we figured there must be a reason for this so we went for 3 savory courses. ”
- “
The asparagus salad was fantastic, the mahi mahi literally melted in my mouth, and the warm flourless chocolate cake with mango sorbet was phenomenal. ”
- “
The desserts I loved was the creme brulee of caramel or chocolate dipped with the churros, as well as the delicious strawberry souffle! ”
- “
The chocolate carmel cake was amazing! ”
- “
Even if you don't order desert, there are these little nibblets that come out for you to snack on. ”
- “
cake with an amazing espresso/walnut ice cream. ”
- “
And to top it off, the Gotham warm chocolate cake left an indelible impression on my mind as the best chocolate dessert I can remember to date. ”
- “
While all of the food is delicious, I highly recommend the chocolate cake. ”
- “
Then the desserts came, and they were hands down the best dessert we ever had. ”
- “
The entree was good, not outstanding and the desert was great. ”
|
| drinks |
90.62999725341797% positive |
- “
Service was outstanding both in the dining room and at the bar. ”
- “
cake with an amazing espresso/walnut ice cream. ”
- “
Presentation is excellent and so is the bar. ”
- “
nice twist is their lunchtime wine menu (all at $20.02) for tasting wines, half bottles, and full bottles. ”
- “
They can make a good martini once you get then bar tenders attention. ”
- “
It was exactly what I was looking for; gourmet, seafood, excellent presentation, enormous wine list, beautiful setting. ”
- “
The wine list had mostly expensive wines, but one does come here to treat oneself, right? ”
- “
The only thing which was even a slight problem to an otherwise perfect experience was they didn't have the wine we ordered. ”
- “
This is a great place to have dinner or even just for drinks. ”
- “
Engjoyed the 3 course lunch at the fabulous bar, such a deal ($24.70). ”
- “
Try dining at the bar for a casual lunch - it's a great spot to people watch. ”
- “
We started with excellent house cocktails which are all very old school and for serious drinkers - no fruity watered down concontions and lots of bourbon based drinks. ”
- “
If one has to wait a bit for a table, the bar is huge and perfect for pre-dinner conversation as it is never too loud. ”
- “
My girlfriend and I ate at Gotham bar and grill last night, and our experience was amazing. ”
- “
Love the spacious dining room and the bar is great for solo diners. ”
- “
The setting was stuffy for a young couple looking for a romantic spot - the wine steward was amazed when we showed a basic knowledge of grapes, and the couple next to us were in their 80s (they informed us of this proudly) and on their 2nd date. ”
|
| food quality |
96.05999946594238% positive |
- “
Lovely ambiance coupled with a delicious and well-prepared meal make for a perfect dining experience. ”
- “
The meal was amazing every bite was savory, we were disappointed when the meal was over. ”
- “
Wonderful food in a mundane setting, definitely geared towards an older crowd. ”
- “
Excellent food with professional but friendly service. ”
- “
recommendations were right on: the octopus appetizer was delicious even for those unadventurous with their tastes. ”
- “
You'll get Fidji water out of plastic bottles served to excellent food. ”
- “
The Miso Black cod was extremely tasty, the fish was perfectly cooked as was the veggies and rice. ”
- “
The food was tasty, creative and well seasoned. ”
- “
have had an incredible duck risotto there (with cabbage), sweet shrimp risotto, filet. ”
- “
Gotham is awesome- so much better than Jean Georges (where I found my food inedible), or Union Square Cafe, or so many other hyped restaurants in NY. ”
- “
The decor is lovely, the service is warm&attentive and the food is divine. ”
- “
loved the presentation, the service, and most importantly the food, we were never rushed, we had the nicest table, and we enjoyed the whole experience! ”
- “
Great food almost makes up for robotic service ”
- “
The food was nice- I choose that word intentionally. ”
- “
Asparagus/beet salad, mahi mahi and warm choc. ”
- “
And the food is superb. ”
- “
The steak was a perfect medium rare and served warm. ”
- “
They consistently serve top-notch food and the service is always fantastic. ”
- “
Gotham's food is fabulous, 98% of the time. ”
- “
While the tuna tartare appetizer was excellent, the ny steak entree was nothing special. ”
- “
their soups are fantastic and the atmosphere is excellent. ”
- “
The lamb chops were superb. ”
- “
The tables are a bit close and it can get a little loud, but the food is delicious and the service is outstanding! ”
- “
loved the refreshing chilled melon salad to start off with. ”
- “
Everything from the food to the service was incredible. ”
- “
The food here is fabulous. ”
- “
The food is excellent. ”
- “
The food was outstanding -- I inhaled the venison chop that was (barely) cooked to perfection and the bite I stole of my husband's duck was equally wonderful. ”
- “
The food was the best I have tasted in a long while. ”
- “
The food was exquisite, the service impeccable and the atmosphere elegant (with a tad corporate air feel). ”
- “
The food was excellent - good fresh ingredients, prepared well, and served stylishly. ”
- “
Meaning, I ordered Lobster Tails as an entree (The Tails were delicious) and along with my Tails came Spinach with beans and fried potatoes that were close to potato steak fries. ”
- “
It was exactly what I was looking for; gourmet, seafood, excellent presentation, enormous wine list, beautiful setting. ”
- “
My wife ordered a warm mushroom salad and the free range chicken, She enjoyed the mushrooms and other stuff in the salad but was overwhelmed by the greenery on it (which was almost comical in how over the top it was stacked). ”
- “
The foie gras would transport you with it's flavors and it was simply divine, the grilled lamb was perfectly tasty, not overcooked, and the seasoned herbs were really mouth watering, and I can't wait to return for another occassion! ”
- “
tasty towers ”
- “
*It is the single most delicious dish I have ever tasted. ”
- “
Wonderful service and amazing food make this place a must try. ”
- “
This used to be a vow what incredible food place. ”
- “
The squab was good but not outstanding as was the seafood salad. ”
- “
While all of the food is delicious, I highly recommend the chocolate cake. ”
- “
There was 3 baby carrots, a spoon full of spinach, sun dried tomatoes, 3 pieces of eggplant, and 10 string beans, oh and onions. ”
- “
but the greeting at the door is so rude, that it puts a damper on the entire meal. ”
- “
Last night was no exception; the tomato salad with arugula was the best appetizer I've had in awhile and my lobster was cooked to perfection. ”
- “
The service was great and the waiter made sure we always had fresh bread to eat. ”
- “
The organic free range chicken was a 6, the lamb chop was excellent, and we had to send the halibut back 2x with no result- ended up having to order anther dish (cod) in which the fish was good but the clams were too tough to eat and the sausage wasn't ev ”
- “
But the food is wonderful. ”
- “
tend to like my pasta a bit over done, just slightly past al dente, but this was like eating rice. ”
- “
The desserts I loved was the creme brulee of caramel or chocolate dipped with the churros, as well as the delicious strawberry souffle! ”
- “
The appetizer (pasta of the day) was very tasty, and the Atlantic halibut had a sense of individual style, but was a bit bland. ”
- “
The asparagus salad was fantastic, the mahi mahi literally melted in my mouth, and the warm flourless chocolate cake with mango sorbet was phenomenal. ”
- “
I've been there on numerous occasions and with the exception of a recent disappointment (ordered the duck and the dish came cold to the table, so I had to send it back), the food is always excellent. ”
- “
The Pasta was delicious, very rich and earthy like i expected (and the bread we were served was very handy in mopping up the sauce) and the pasta was well cooked. ”
- “
We ordered a nice bottle of rose champange for the meal. ”
- “
Gotham has good food that is displayed elegantly (can you say Leaning Tower of Pisa made of lobster?) ”
- “
The asparagus mushroom risotto, seared tuna, and lobster tail were the best we ever had. ”
- “
The food was good, but seemed mismatched. ”
- “
All the food was very delicious, including ceviche, lobster, berkshire pork. ”
- “
It's a place for people with stacks of money who don't want to get dressed up but want 5 star food and great service. ”
- “
But the winner was the grilled hanger steak with baby carrots and crispy fingerling potatoes bordelaise sauce; so perfectly cooked, tender and well-seasoned. ”
- “
Great food is not that hard to find. ”
- “
yummy pasta and he had a wonderful large NY steak, it was the best of the best. ”
- “
The food was fantastic and worth every penny, I had the house special. ”
- “
The atmosphere is incredible and the food. ”
- “
Great food, lovely dining room ”
- “
To sum it up, the service, food, staff and decor were incredible. ”
- “
The place is enduring for a reason - excellent food, well prepared, beautifully presented. ”
- “
Let's be honest - the food is always great here. ”
- “
Considering the money you pay, you would expect good food AND spectacular service. ”
- “
Overall, the food was good. ”
- “
Gotham is quite expensive, but the service and food are flawless. ”
- “
Gotham is pricey but this is NYC and the food and service was worth the visit. ”
|
| menu variety |
62.5% positive |
- “
The menu offers 3 savory courses and dessert, we figured there must be a reason for this so we went for 3 savory courses. ”
- “
nice twist is their lunchtime wine menu (all at $20.02) for tasting wines, half bottles, and full bottles. ”
- “
guess they knew people wouldn't order it if they had that on the menu. ”
- “
The place was an excellent place for lunch - my friends and I had the pre-fixe lunch menu. ”
|
| overall |
100.0% positive |
- “
Without a doubt, Gotham is our favorite restaurant in New York. ”
- “
This is a great place to have dinner or even just for drinks. ”
- “
In general its a nice place but it certainly not in the outstanding class. ”
- “
Service was friendly, we were early for our reservation but were seated immediately coat and bag check was very nice and the hostess was as friendly as you'll find in a place like this in NYC. ”
|
| return potential |
100.0% positive |
- “
The foie gras would transport you with it's flavors and it was simply divine, the grilled lamb was perfectly tasty, not overcooked, and the seasoned herbs were really mouth watering, and I can't wait to return for another occassion! ”
|
| service |
84.75000381469727% positive |
- “
On more than one occassion when I am with a large group where the tip will already be included, the service is awful. ”
- “
It's a place for people with stacks of money who don't want to get dressed up but want 5 star food and great service. ”
- “
The service was helpful, but aloof. ”
- “
Service was average, but our waiter was full of "tude ”
- “
Gotham is pricey but this is NYC and the food and service was worth the visit. ”
- “
Namely, the space is beautiful, although the tables are set very close to each other and the waitstaff was very attentive. ”
- “
loved the ambience and the service was great. ”
- “
Service was friendly, we were early for our reservation but were seated immediately coat and bag check was very nice and the hostess was as friendly as you'll find in a place like this in NYC. ”
- “
Everything from the food to the service was incredible. ”
- “
Hostess, servers, bussers--all staff were very attentive and pleasant. ”
- “
Service was professional and friendly. ”
- “
The service was great! ”
- “
The food was exquisite, the service impeccable and the atmosphere elegant (with a tad corporate air feel). ”
- “
get it that Restaurant Week is discounted, and many people tip only the percentage of the cheap prix fixe price, I am sure they would much rather have people paying full price and buying liquor and leaving big tips, but they sure as heck are not going t ”
- “
The service was fantastic. ”
- “
It's such a unique place - you can dress formal or casual and you'll get the same level of service. ”
- “
The service was great and the waiter made sure we always had fresh bread to eat. ”
- “
The rack of lambs are to die for, the service is great, the ambiance is perfect. ”
- “
Always perfect attentive service. ”
- “
The one drawback was the service-while professional and precise, our waitress was not friendly by any stretch of the imagination. ”
- “
Excellent food with professional but friendly service. ”
- “
The service was very pleasant if not observant. ”
- “
The service is formal yet friendly and Gotham has always been CONSISTENT on delivering a memorable experience (oh. ”
- “
very attentive and they all truly seemed to want you to have a perfect experience there. ”
- “
loved the presentation, the service, and most importantly the food, we were never rushed, we had the nicest table, and we enjoyed the whole experience! ”
- “
Gotham is quite expensive, but the service and food are flawless. ”
- “
The serving staff was superb; our server was perfectly nice without being our buddy, always responsive and cordial without being snooty. ”
- “
Went with a small group, had great service and truly enjoyed our meals. ”
- “
Wonderful service and amazing food make this place a must try. ”
- “
our waiter was so friendly and made you feel at home. ”
- “
To sum it up, the service, food, staff and decor were incredible. ”
- “
Try dining at the bar for a casual lunch - it's a great spot to people watch. ”
- “
They consistently serve top-notch food and the service is always fantastic. ”
- “
Although the place is a bit overcrowded, waiters are always polite and professional. ”
- “
but the greeting at the door is so rude, that it puts a damper on the entire meal. ”
- “
Great food almost makes up for robotic service ”
- “
Service was very attentive, but not pushy. ”
- “
Considering the money you pay, you would expect good food AND spectacular service. ”
- “
The Captain was attentive & polite, unlike most NYC restaurant service employees. ”
- “
guess they knew people wouldn't order it if they had that on the menu. ”
- “
The service is impeccable and they really look to make sure you are taken care of. ”
- “
The staff is truly wonderful and classy. ”
- “
The tables are a bit close and it can get a little loud, but the food is delicious and the service is outstanding! ”
- “
The manager was cold and rude from the minute we walked in. ”
- “
The employees were very warm and pleasant and made us feel at home. ”
- “
The service was wonderful from the minute I walked through the door. ”
- “
The decor is lovely, the service is warm&attentive and the food is divine. ”
|
| value |
61.11000061035156% positive |
- “
It's a place for people with stacks of money who don't want to get dressed up but want 5 star food and great service. ”
- “
The wine list had mostly expensive wines, but one does come here to treat oneself, right? ”
- “
If one has to wait a bit for a table, the bar is huge and perfect for pre-dinner conversation as it is never too loud. ”
- “
My boyfriend and I are huge fans of the TV show ? ”
- “
If you are going to an expensive restaurant the least they can do is work with you. ”
- “
Great value lunch for $20.02! ”
- “
get it that Restaurant Week is discounted, and many people tip only the percentage of the cheap prix fixe price, I am sure they would much rather have people paying full price and buying liquor and leaving big tips, but they sure as heck are not going t ”
- “
That place is overpriced for what you get in your plate. ”
- “
My only complaints: 1) tables are close together and it's an uncomfortable situation to go to the restroom - you need someone to pull the tabel out for you and if you don't wait for that to happen, your butt will be in your neighbor's dinner (and I'm not ”
- “
like to have a cool, fun, or romantic atmosphere when I'm paying these kinds of prices. ”
- “
This is a pricey place to dine in the evening, but the prix fixe lunch offers superb value. ”
- “
Gotham is quite expensive, but the service and food are flawless. ”
- “
Gotham is pricey but this is NYC and the food and service was worth the visit. ”
- “
The food was fantastic and worth every penny, I had the house special. ”
- “
Considering the money you pay, you would expect good food AND spectacular service. ”
|
| wait time |
66.66999816894531% positive |
- “
The manager was cold and rude from the minute we walked in. ”
- “
The food was the best I have tasted in a long while. ”
- “
The service was wonderful from the minute I walked through the door. ”
|
Deals
share
Facebook |