07/31/09

My most amazing best birthday dinner EVER

by kalogiannis

this restaurant has all the right ingredients for a perfect dinner. For my birthday every year we always have some sort of a big party and this year battery gardens was our venue of choice. we all indulged in delicious margarita pizzas and crab cakes among other items. i had their signature dish the chilean sea bass which was awesome. i hear they do wedding here and i could only imagine how beautiful they turn out at this hidden gem.

• Pros: atmosphere, amazing food, sunset, awesome staff
• Cons: absolutely nothing

06/23/09

Rip-Off

by NYC2121

I recently attended an event catered by this company. I knew the hosts and found out what they had paid for their affair to be catered by Battery Gardens. When I saw what had been provided for thousands of dollars—cheap, 2nd-rate cheese squares and sour, unripe fruit, cheap wine along with abysmal presentation and service—I decided I would try to let others know. This place should be sued. They are ripping people off, and I'm sure they know it, but they had a "contract" with the venue so the hosts were basically held hostage. This should not happen. They are no better than criminals.

• Pros: None
• Cons: Everything

12/01/07

As of 9/16/07, for my wedding, Battery Gardens provided very good service and top quality food.

by ed1234567890

I am writting this review because I saw many others that said the food and service was low quality. Well, I have had no problems at all with reservations being honored and the the food and service were as expected: top notch!