(347) 448-5676

545 E 5th St (nr. Ave. A)
New York, NY 10009 40.724416 -73.983344

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Alphabet City, East Village, Downtown

LAVAGNANYC.COM

Hours:

Mon-Thu 6pm-11pm

Fri-Sat 6pm-11pm

Sun 5pm-11pm

Last updated 4.12.12

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Romantic Dining

Cuisine:

Mediterranean, Italian

What People Are Saying About Lavagna

Featured Review

Melanie Berliet

Contributor

Behind a deep red awning in Alphabet City lies this understated trattoria, frequented by locals in search of a casual, romantic spot for traditional Italian fare served in rustic, welcoming environs. The right side of the space is dominated by a wood-burning oven, turning out whole roasted fishes and pizzas dripping with Fontina and truffle oil. The menu also includes several pasta courses and other seasonal dishes. Despite the restaurant’s rather small size, the wine list is extensive (and affordable), with several varieties to complement each dish.

Editor's Tips

Save Money:
There’s a $29, three-course prix fixe menu offered on Sundays from 5pm to 7pm.
What to Drink:
Have a glass of wine at the small restaurant bar--the award-winning wine list features over 200 bottles.
When to Go:
The floor to ceiling windows allow for a breezy, open atmosphere in warmer months
ambiance
92.8600025177002% positive
  1. Tasty food, nice ambiance, good for a date, or a party of 6.
  2. The food and the ambience are great, but the service tops everything, the staff welcomes you and makes you feel right at home!
  3. The place is so romantic that i went there for my first date!
  4. It is a very cozy restaurant with excellent serivce and the food is superb.
  5. First of all, I really love the decor; it is romantic and dark lit, perfect for dates.
  6. Yes, this is a romantic place, but we did not feel out of place.
  7. highly recommend Lavagna for a romantic evening.
  8. Hopefully, the out of the way location won't mean big crowds.
  9. The very inventive food was great and was nice, cozy and out of the way on 5th Street - so great for a date as I went with my girlfriend.
  10. Wanted to try some honest Italian fare in an inexpensive, romantic setting.
  11. This place has a very nice ambiance, decor, vibe, etc.
  12. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  13. great ambiance, though if you come on the weekend you'll be sharing that ambiance quite intimately will many many other people.
  14. The restaurant has a very charming, relaxed and cozy ambiance, the food is delicious and not your typical Italian fare - here on top of pasta you'll find things like braised rabbit and seared monkfish.
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. The warm chocolate cake was also quite good.
  2. My BF's Warm Fruit Crisp was warm, sweet and it goes very well with their Vanilla ice cream.
  3. Finally, the desserts were outstanding.
  4. Yummy food, graet wine list but the best was the dessert.
  5. The semolina bread pudding dessert was an incredible melange of textures and flavors - an I am a real dessert afficionado.
  6. Three Star dining at $25 or Under prices, an excellent waitstaff (most have been there since its opening), attractive intimate room, creative menu, inexpensive wine list & a desserts that rival most patisseries, LaVagna is the best dining deal in Manhatta
drinks
100.0% positive
  1. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  2. Solid, inexpensive northern italian food, good wine list, great neighborhood vibe.
  3. Three Star dining at $25 or Under prices, an excellent waitstaff (most have been there since its opening), attractive intimate room, creative menu, inexpensive wine list & a desserts that rival most patisseries, LaVagna is the best dining deal in Manhatta
  4. Another thing that is wonderful about this restaurant is a really amazing wine and beer selection.
  5. We had the Arugula salad which was good and initially the white bottle of wine we ordered was insufficiently cold.
  6. If you do not have the sense enough to recognize great food and wine in the east village - Stay home!
  7. Great wine selection and good food
  8. Yummy food, graet wine list but the best was the dessert.
food quality
93.17999839782715% positive
  1. The restaurant has a very charming, relaxed and cozy ambiance, the food is delicious and not your typical Italian fare - here on top of pasta you'll find things like braised rabbit and seared monkfish.
  2. Charming place, good food
  3. Top off the miserable waiting experience with mediocre food and service and you have a ruined Saturday night.
  4. The portions are large and hearty (espeically the pasta with sausage) and the specials were just as appetizing as the main menu.
  5. The very inventive food was great and was nice, cozy and out of the way on 5th Street - so great for a date as I went with my girlfriend.
  6. The food is simple, everything tastes really great.
  7. am most picky about Italian food and I must say that Lavagna did not disappoint.
  8. the food was excellent.
  9. My Rigatoni dish ended being the most delicious pasta dish I've tasting thus far, and it is also HUGE.
  10. The food at Lavagna is great and service gets hairy on weekends because people expect to sit for hours at their tables or to arrive late and still have their table.
  11. My favourite dishes are scallops appetizer, pasta with rabbit, pork entree, and once I had a special of the skate wing, which was trully amazing!
  12. the skate fish and shell steak were just so divine.
  13. The food is okay, but the service is terrible -- my wife is a vegetarian and instead of pointing out the vegetarian dishes when we requested, our waiter told us to figure it out for ourselves and said he'd come back later.
  14. And I love onions and vinegar so there's not a better dish then this one for me.
  15. Solid, inexpensive northern italian food, good wine list, great neighborhood vibe.
  16. We had a wonderful meal there the other night - Octopus Carpaccio and great pasta and pizzas.
  17. really love the pan-seared scallops; the puree sauce is very sweet and savory and scallops totally soaked up the juice.
  18. The proscuitto appetizer with figs and some type of little bread was excellent.
  19. The angel hair pasta with tomato sauce looked very nice, but was not to my liking, as the sauce was very spicy.
  20. It is a very cozy restaurant with excellent serivce and the food is superb.
  21. The food and the ambience are great, but the service tops everything, the staff welcomes you and makes you feel right at home!
  22. Comforting tasty food
  23. Yummy food, graet wine list but the best was the dessert.
  24. Overall, my pasta entree was the best dish and in my opinion that doesn't say much for the cuisine considering all the excellent alternatives nearby.
  25. The food is excellent too.
  26. been going there for 3 years excellent restaurant, great food price fix went up from 25 to 28 is my only problem service is nice
  27. Average, good food, noisy
  28. Great wine selection and good food
  29. The semolina bread pudding dessert was an incredible melange of textures and flavors - an I am a real dessert afficionado.
  30. We had the Arugula salad which was good and initially the white bottle of wine we ordered was insufficiently cold.
  31. Overall the dish was excellent, although the texture of the fish was too rubbery for me.
  32. If you do not have the sense enough to recognize great food and wine in the east village - Stay home!
  33. service is attentive, eager and kind, and the food is simply fantastic, especially given how low the prices are.
  34. Everyone in my party enjoyed the food so much, that we vowed to come back really soon.
  35. Only problem was noise level, which took away from an otherwise perfect meal.
  36. The service was excellent, and the food was divine.
  37. All the food was absolutely delicious!
  38. know the food is amazing and I'm sure the restaurant will continue to prosper, but it has definitely lost my business for good!
  39. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  40. Don't get me wrong, the food is not bad.
  41. the pasta puttanescas sauce was perfect, the pasta a little too al dente.
  42. Great food, average service
  43. Lamb main was great, tasty although slightly overdone for my medium rare taste.
  44. Tasty food, nice ambiance, good for a date, or a party of 6.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. Nothing great on this menu but everything is pretty good and it's a nice first date place, lively but candlelit.
  2. The portions are large and hearty (espeically the pasta with sausage) and the specials were just as appetizing as the main menu.
  3. Three Star dining at $25 or Under prices, an excellent waitstaff (most have been there since its opening), attractive intimate room, creative menu, inexpensive wine list & a desserts that rival most patisseries, LaVagna is the best dining deal in Manhatta
  4. Another thing that is wonderful about this restaurant is a really amazing wine and beer selection.
  5. Then we looked at the menu not much to choose from and finally they did not great us good bye.
  6. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  7. Great wine selection and good food
overall
100.0% positive
  1. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  2. Nothing great on this menu but everything is pretty good and it's a nice first date place, lively but candlelit.
  3. Been coming to this place for years & its still the best restaurant in the East Village, despite all the recent competition.
  4. This is a great date place.
  5. THE best Italian place in the neighborhood!
return potential
50.0% positive
  1. Everyone in my party enjoyed the food so much, that we vowed to come back really soon.
  2. The food is okay, but the service is terrible -- my wife is a vegetarian and instead of pointing out the vegetarian dishes when we requested, our waiter told us to figure it out for ourselves and said he'd come back later.
service
81.25% positive
  1. do you like people shouting at you?
  2. The service is not bad, it is just UNBELIEVABLY bad.
  3. been going there for 3 years excellent restaurant, great food price fix went up from 25 to 28 is my only problem service is nice
  4. The wait staff was a bit cold as they just pointed us to take our coats without offering.
  5. Seriously, in the city full of great restaurants (with normal service) why would you want to be screamed at by some idiot and wait for hours?
  6. Top off the miserable waiting experience with mediocre food and service and you have a ruined Saturday night.
  7. The food at Lavagna is great and service gets hairy on weekends because people expect to sit for hours at their tables or to arrive late and still have their table.
  8. The service is friendly and efficient, and the value is unbelievable.
  9. Great Date spot, food is good, service is beyond excellent, it's a perfect cozy little place, large wine selection, I been there several times and am never disappointed by anything!
  10. service is attentive, eager and kind, and the food is simply fantastic, especially given how low the prices are.
  11. great ambiance, though if you come on the weekend you'll be sharing that ambiance quite intimately will many many other people.
  12. The food is okay, but the service is terrible -- my wife is a vegetarian and instead of pointing out the vegetarian dishes when we requested, our waiter told us to figure it out for ourselves and said he'd come back later.
  13. Great food, average service
  14. The service was excellent, and the food was divine.
  15. the staff was friendly, and the price was right.
  16. The food and the ambience are great, but the service tops everything, the staff welcomes you and makes you feel right at home!
value
76.91999912261963% positive
  1. who did the billing walked over in a huge sissy fit about how there was nothing wrong with the bill.
  2. Solid, inexpensive northern italian food, good wine list, great neighborhood vibe.
  3. the staff was friendly, and the price was right.
  4. awesome price fix though they just raised price
  5. IT KILLS ME TO GIVE THIS PLACE THAN GLOWING REVIEW;THE FOOD HORRIBLE FLAVORLESS;it is not worth it?
  6. Wanted to try some honest Italian fare in an inexpensive, romantic setting.
  7. The service is friendly and efficient, and the value is unbelievable.
  8. The portions are large and hearty (espeically the pasta with sausage) and the specials were just as appetizing as the main menu.
  9. been going there for 3 years excellent restaurant, great food price fix went up from 25 to 28 is my only problem service is nice
  10. Three Star dining at $25 or Under prices, an excellent waitstaff (most have been there since its opening), attractive intimate room, creative menu, inexpensive wine list & a desserts that rival most patisseries, LaVagna is the best dining deal in Manhatta
  11. This is another one of those overpriced East Village restaurants that thinks it's better than it is.
  12. the neighborhood surrounding it might have been a little sketchy, especially for out-of-towners, but it was well worth it.
  13. service is attentive, eager and kind, and the food is simply fantastic, especially given how low the prices are.
1 Star Rating: Poor

04/16/12

the attitude of the waitress was terrible.

by SUN2010

I went to this restaurant with my friend last Friday night.

It was my first time to visit this restaurant and I was kinda excited since the reviews were pretty good.

I and my friend were waiting for a waiter who could take us to the table, but nobody came to us. my friend said "excuse me" to the waitress who was a white female with a blond bobhair but she didn't even say hello and totally ignored us and passed us by to serve the other tables in the outside. we were disconcerted a bit ,so I couldn't say anything. actually, I was kinda shocked.

she saw us again when she came back inside the restaurant, and I saw She threw a look of contempt at us. I felt like the reason why she ignored us might be that we were Asian females.

of course, she would say "I am not a racist or something", but I don't know why she did it to us.

even though she was not a racist, her attitude was terrible as a waitress.

Did she forget what she had to do as a waitress because she was an idiot?

The owner must lay off her before their reputation gets worse.

3 Star Rating: Average

10/14/11

The place was nice.

by FlorenceAndrea

I really loved the setting of the place, I love the ambiance. Me and my husband went here for our anniversary; the lighting and the decorations, it felt romantic. The place was near perfect for the occasion. However, the food was not that good. On average, I must say. But the prices were good, reasonable in congruence with the food. It was nice :)

4 Star Rating: Recommended

01/28/10

Romantic and intimate Italian Dining

by Athena Chang , Citysearch Contributor

Came here for my anniversary with my BF and they have pre-fix special for $30 per person from 6 to 7 PM. First of all, I really love the decor; it is romantic and dark lit, perfect for dates.

The food is excellent too. We picked different dishes for all courses. I really love the pan-seared scallops; the puree sauce is very sweet and savory and scallops totally soaked up the juice. My entree, Black pepper Crusted Tuna tastes fresh and tender as well. It came in 3 big pieces of Yellowfin tuna.

Finally, the desserts were outstanding. My panna Cotta is so soft and vanilla-ish. My BF's Warm Fruit Crisp was warm, sweet and it goes very well with their Vanilla Ice cream.

I want to come back to try out their Rigatoni and Chocolate Moose cake.

  • Pros: Romantic & Fine italian Dining
4 Star Rating: Recommended

03/02/09

good eats

by bjones77

Solid, inexpensive northern italian food, good wine list, great neighborhood vibe. Loved the braised rabbit pappardelle.

  • Pros: Example: best croissants in town
  • Cons: What are the drawbacks?
3 Star Rating: Average

09/30/08

Not Good..

by Carloma

I wasn't thrilled by this. I am sometimes overwhelmed by prix fixe dinners. But this one was not my favorite of all the ones I have been to. It was awhile ago, before I started blogging, so I cannot remember all teh details of the meal. But I do remember being decidedly underwhelmed

The Details on Lavagna

Place Categories:

  • great inventive food
  • favorite restaurant
  • eager average service
  • very nice ambiance
  • mediocre food
  • very enjoyable experience
  • favorite pasta dish
  • great wine
  • warm chocolate cake
  • very nice angel hair pasta
  • great nothing
  • nice ambience
  • great food price fix
  • great staff
  • warm fruit crisp
  • mediocre service
  • very nice decor
  • not disappoint lavagna
  • romantic italian dining
  • cozy little place
  • good arugula salad
  • great date place
  • great italian place
  • otherwise perfect meal
  • love vinegar
Advertisement

Featured In

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement