Shaffer City Oyster Bar & Grill
New York, NY 10010
Phone: (212) 255-9827
- Price:
- $$$$
- Cross Street:
- 5th Avenue
- Directions:
- N, R; F; 1, 9 at 23rd St
- Best of Citysearch:
- Seafood 2006
- Hours:
- Mon-Fri 12pm-4pm, 5pm-10:30pm, Sat 5pm-10:30pm
Editorial Review for Shaffer City Oyster Bar & Grill – by Kara Hoffman
The Scene
A small unassuming facade hides the seafood treasures inside. Nautically themed decor of replica boats and maritime paintings line the walls, creating a true Cape Cod feel. A free-standing fireplace warms the back room and lighted candles are places on white tablecloths. Servers are knowledgeable and extremely helpful.
The Food
The menu embraces a subtle Asian theme throughout. Oyster choices consist of selected Atlantic and Pacific varieties, including the Long Island-raised Shaffer Cove oyster unique to the restaurant. Shrimp dumplings with a curried Thai sauce provide an interesting mix of sweet and salty. The pan-seared scallops over asparagus mushroom ragout are divinely enhanced with truffle cream. Seared tuna and wasabi mashed potatoes drizzled with orange coriander reduction are also flavorful. End the meal with the tangy lemon tart.
Editorial content is independent of paid advertisers. Any expenses are paid for by Citysearch.
Insider Tips
What to DrinkThe extensive wine list offers a nice selection of both national and international wines. The Duckpond Cellars pinot gris nicely complements the oyster selections.
User Reviews for Shaffer City Oyster Bar & Grill
01/25/2008 Posted by radamady
I'm relatively new to raw oysters, and I was extremely pleased with the seperate descriptive menu. The decor was inelegant but cozy and romantic. The lighting and brassieres really contributed to the ambience. The service was outstanding. Our waitress was humorous and patient, and the bus staff were attentive and prompt. And the oysters themselves were exactly what I was looking for. Each one was like taking a swim in the ocean. Looking forward to going back.
Pros: A great experience overall. Romantic and fun.
Cons: A bit pricey, but a great deal for oysters.
12/05/2007 Posted by bethany22
I have to say, I stumbled in on a whim one afternoon waiting for my boyfriend to get off work, and fell in love! Not only are the bartenders extremely friendly and attentive, but they know all about the oysters and assist in your selections. The first time we had Gabe, very nice, and the second time it was an Asian girl, I don't know her name (sorry!). She was especially sweet, but they were both pretty cool. I must disagree with the review below me, I found the owner to be delightful! Not only is he hilarious, but he remembered me from the time I came in before, which is always nice. The oysters are awesome, and half price wine for happy hour. Can't think of a better place to unwind after a day at the office, will be back for sure!
Pros: great service, great food!
Cons: get there early for happy hour, bar fills up quick!
Users Like You Also Viewed
Crave on 42nd
650 W 42nd St
New York, NY 10036
The Sea Grill
19 W 49th St
New York, NY 10020
