- Reservation
-
Mon-Thu 5:30pm-10pm Fri-Sat 5:15pm-11:15pm Sun 11:30am-2pm, 5:30-9:30pm
- Menu
- Save
Best of Citysearch
Recommend this business?
view & uploadphotos
- Neighborhoods:
- Downtown, West Village
- Categories:
- Restaurants, Restaurants
- Price:
- $$$$
- Cuisine:
- New American, Seafood
- Restaurant Special Features:
- Payment Methods:
View Less
At a Glance
?
94% ambiance
“The restaurant is very romantic in an overdone sort of way.”
79% dessert
“deserts were slow to order as waiters passed us twice, even with the menus closed.”
87% drinks
“Our server was most helpful in our wine selections.”
85% food quality
“The food was good, but not for the price we paid for it.”
76% menu variety
“the food was GREAT and they have a great selection of wines.”
91% overall
“However, the service was the best I've ever had at a restaurant (although that's the way it should have been since we paid a lot for the food).”
92% return potential
“would go there again in a heartbeat and would reccomend it to everyone who wants to have a great & wonderful evening.”
87% service
“The service was slow to respond, patronizing - a $90 prix fixe menu and we were offered a mushroom tart as a substitute to a meat course?”
60% value
“Definately would recommend for a special occasion, but beware-a bit too expensive for small portions.”
60% wait time
“We waited at the bar for 15 minutes to be seated when the restaurant was only half full.”
Write a Tip for
One if by Land, Two if by…
From The Owner of One if by Land, Two if by Sea
About One if by Land, Two if by Sea
-
Wine Spectator Award
-
AAA Four Diamond Award
-
The Michelin Guide
Located in Aaron Burr's landmark carriage house & tucked away in the heart of the Village, One if by Land, Two if by Sea is renowned for
impeccable service & exceptional seasonal American cuisine served in a very romantic setting. Chef Colt Taylor hits the mark with his inventive interpretation of New American cuisine. Choose from a 3 course prix-fixe or chef's tasting menu available with or without wine pairing.
Candle light, fresh flowers, fireplaces & live piano music contribute to the alluring ambiance. Open 7 nights for dinner and on weekends for Live Jazz Brunch. Visit the lovely bar area where great cocktails made with premium ingredients are served. Experience the ultimate romantic evening replete with fresh roses & lilting, live piano music.
Available for private parties.
…
View Less
One If By Land
@oneifbylandnyc
Good Morning NYC! Don't forget that our friends & family 25% off ends on April 30th. So that means you still have some time! #fb
Reply
Retweet
Favorite
Apr 25, 2012
What Our Expert Scouts Say
November 02, 2012
It's a little passe today, but the city's perennial "most romantic restaurant" hasn't gotten any less beautiful, nor its fireplace any less transporting. The food isn't the final word in high gastronomy, but it's very good, and resists fads in a commendable way. NYC needs more places like this, not less.
0
Heart
Tips for One if by Land, Two if by Sea
February 13, 2012
Please Leave..... The entire dinner was really nothing to write home about. It was a pre fixe menu (valentine's weekend) so I won't judge too harshly. It was all pretty much ruined however when the maitre de came over to my table and asked if I wouldn't mind having my after dinner drinks at the bar because there was a couple waiting to be seated. I told him I really wish he would have just asked the waiter at what point we were in our meal. He would've realized I had already asked for my check. Really unforgivable and embarassing considering I asked for the check the minute they cleared our desert plates. I didn't even order coffee. Way to ruin my 7 yr anniversary with my girlfriend. I won't over analyze their motives. Just a very unfortunate experience.
0
Heart
July 27, 2011
Great place for a special dinner.
Been here many times before. I have been to the best places in NY and the worst. I try not to let reviewers sway me since you never know their motives. The place is overpriced but the food is great. Never been disappointed.
As to the last reviewer, The city gives out ratings on cleanliness not the quality of the food. How can you put health concious and foie gras in the same sentence?? How did the bass taste?? Pate never looks appetizing, but how was the taste?? Health concious?? Scary!
0
Heart
June 07, 2011
Amongst the worst meals ever.
It is difficult to describe the effects of food on a person's palate. My wife and I approached this restaurant due to the promise of a romantic ambience and appropriate decor reflective of our dedication and love to each other.
The service was average and the waitress was not engaging in any manner. I cannot recommend the food as the foie gras appeared to be a slab of butter without texture or flavor. The striped bass was dropped in a plate that was shaped like a cymbal, which permitted clanging noise to occur when I reached into this dish to cut into the fish. The rabbit and pork pate was cut into cubes and was not very appetizing.
We are all health conscious and this restaurant does not deliver on proper food. Although it gets an A for food quality by the city of NY, I wonder how the restaurant was able to acquire this food rating.
The bar, piano, and lounge area are nice to sit and enjoy a cocktail. The Pouilly-Fuisse wine was good and the beauty of the dining experience ended there.
All in all, a bad establishment with too much publicity. The name is confusing, too. Sorry.
0
Heart
May 14, 2011
Outstanding. This is one of my favorite restaurants in the village. I first came here 15 years ago and instantly fell in love with it. The Beef Wellington is wonderful, but no matter the dish, it will be prepared to your satisfaction. The service is always personal and attentive. It's located in an old carriage house and the decor is beautiful. Very romantic.
0
Heart
February 28, 2011
The Disney World of romantic restaurants!. Awesome, took my wife recently ... we've been married awhile; this really helped rekindle things!
0
Heart
February 19, 2011
going back.....?. food is as good as i expected based on some reviews. services are better than food level. going back...? maybe...
0
Heart
February 02, 2011
ROMANTIC?. Dined here during restaurant week in NYC. I was super excited because of all the good reviews...but what a disappointment. The restaurant was noisy, the food substandard and the prices outrageous. The only positive was the service is very good. Definately will not be returning.
0
Heart
January 12, 2011
romantic. Great place for a romantic moment. The food is good but a little pricey. It's ok if you want to try a different ambience.
0
Heart
December 28, 2010
If you propose here...your a jackass.
This is the kind of place that looks authentic through the window but when you get in you'll see that it resembles more of a 1970's basement refurbish ( with faux brickwork and sheetrock walls that were done over) than an intimate late 1700's eatery. Disneyland does a better job of recreating the era. The bartender was nice, but the waiter was an absentee drone who could care less if we were alive.
The food was decent but of course completely overpriced...unfortunately the service and ambience does not make up the difference. Paul Revere is turning in his grave
0
Heart
Write a Tip for
One if by Land, Two if by…
People also viewed
Related Guides
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.
Best of Citysearch
Won for:
Romantic Restaurant
(2013)Romantic Date Spot (2008)
Romantic Restaurant (2007)
Special Occasion Dining (2007)
Nominated for:
Date Spot
(2011)
Fine Dining (2010)
Seafood (2010)
Fireside Dining (2009)
Romantic Restaurant (2009)
Fireside Dining (2007)
Fireside Dining (2005)
Special Occasion Dining (2005)
Fine Dining (2010)
Seafood (2010)
Fireside Dining (2009)
Romantic Restaurant (2009)
Fireside Dining (2007)
Fireside Dining (2005)
Special Occasion Dining (2005)