Slaughtered Lamb Pub

(212) 627-5262

182 W. 4th St.
New York, NY 99999 40.7324 -74.0019

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: West Village, Downtown

Last updated 12.31.09

ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. Me and my buddies always had a great time, great drinks and great atmosphere But what happened to the female manager i think her name was Kelly?
  2. It is a cozy place with 3 fireplaces and great beer.
  3. Great beer from all over and a really cozy old puib like atmosphere.
  4. Great music and comfortable atmosphere.
  5. nice fireplace and cozy woodwork.
  6. finally a place I can go enjoy friendly conversation have beer and a burger and have fun.
drinks
88.00000190734863% positive
  1. It is a cozy place with 3 fireplaces and great beer.
  2. After you eventually get your mediocre burger, fries and flat beer, you'll over tip the waitress just because you feel sorry they have to spend so much time in there.
  3. Food is OK, prices are average, and beer is good everywhere.
  4. Me and my buddies always had a great time, great drinks and great atmosphere But what happened to the female manager i think her name was Kelly?
  5. Great neighborhood, horrible place, bad food, flat beer, poor service.
  6. loved my burger and beer.
  7. The drinks were strong, service good, and plenty of space to sit down.
  8. Cozy Pub with great beer list and great burgers.
  9. The perfect place to go for a great beer and a sandwich.
  10. Great bar!
  11. Big beer selection and friendly staff.
  12. finally a place I can go enjoy friendly conversation have beer and a burger and have fun.
  13. They have 3 fireplaces, great music, the food was very good and 100 kinds of beer.
  14. Great beer from all over and a really cozy old puib like atmosphere.
  15. Was just there Sat nite played a couple games of billiards had a few beers and a burger(tasty burger).
food quality
74.43999767303467% positive
  1. Cozy Pub with great beer list and great burgers.
  2. loved my burger and beer.
  3. After you eventually get your mediocre burger, fries and flat beer, you'll over tip the waitress just because you feel sorry they have to spend so much time in there.
  4. The food itself was decent tasting, but 3-4hrs later I was home on the bowl, fully believing that I was very seriously ill, and I am not out of the woods yet.
  5. finally a place I can go enjoy friendly conversation have beer and a burger and have fun.
  6. The perfect place to go for a great beer and a sandwich.
  7. Great neighborhood, horrible place, bad food, flat beer, poor service.
  8. They have 3 fireplaces, great music, the food was very good and 100 kinds of beer.
  9. Was just there Sat nite played a couple games of billiards had a few beers and a burger(tasty burger).
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. Big beer selection and friendly staff.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. great place
service
76.25% positive
  1. Cool staff too!
  2. Me and my buddies always had a great time, great drinks and great atmosphere But what happened to the female manager i think her name was Kelly?
  3. Great neighborhood, horrible place, bad food, flat beer, poor service.
  4. Definately some of the best service I have had in the city, At least with out spending way too much money.
  5. After you eventually get your mediocre burger, fries and flat beer, you'll over tip the waitress just because you feel sorry they have to spend so much time in there.
  6. The bartenders were all nice and we got served right away, no waiting for you to get their attention, no attitude.
  7. There are tables outside which are very inviting but don't fall for it, like the poor fellows on the awning, you'll probably die of thirst or hunger waiting for service.
  8. The drinks were strong, service good, and plenty of space to sit down.
  9. ginger was the best bartender, ginger its rob with the mickey mouse shirt lol.
  10. love the staff!
  11. The staff were the best!
  12. They always have the best sporting events on their T.V.'s and the service is friendly and without that city attitude.
  13. Big beer selection and friendly staff.
  14. The service was appalling - our main courses arrived 1.5 hours after we sat down.
  15. finally a place I can go enjoy friendly conversation have beer and a burger and have fun.
  16. The service was good without being fake and overly pretentious.
value
66.66999816894531% positive
  1. Definately some of the best service I have had in the city, At least with out spending way too much money.
  2. To top it off, the evening was overpriced.
  3. Food is OK, prices are average, and beer is good everywhere.
1 Star Rating: Poor

02/15/09

Eating here resulted in violent illness

by mikexc3

Don't ever eat here! I am dead serious, the past 24hrs have been nearly the worst I can remember in my whole life. All thanks to this dive! The waitress was a space cadet from start to finish. My date and I each had a Brooklyn Lager, both were rather warm(not supposed to be). The head on the bear looked funny, like the glasses hadn't been cleaned properly. We didn't think anything of it. The food itself was decent tasting, but 3-4hrs later I was home on the bowl, fully believing that I was very seriously ill, and I am not out of the woods yet. We both shared the appetizer and her entree, neither of us finished our food, perhaps it was hitting us that fast, and our bodies were telling us to give up on the foul food.

My date told me today that as soon as she got inside her apt, that she hurled. Thankfully neither of us were sick until we said goodnight, but, we felt miserable, not fun for Valentines day.

Personally I just won't go back to a place that provided half assed service and food/drink that was questionable to say the least. I plan to file suit. I lost a sick day for this! Anyone know the direct line for the board of health?

  • Pros: None unless you are into Werewolves
  • Cons: I became violently ill from eating here
1 Star Rating: Poor

05/21/08

Dont eat here

by kevinuk

We came to this pub in August 2007 as i had always wanted to go there as they sell Enlish beer.

before i go in to one i must say the year before we had drinks and everything was fine.

We decided to eat on a week day about 7.30 ,only 2 tables were eating including us.

All the meals were either cold ,not cooked or overcooked and i mean rock hard.

I had sausage and mash ,the sausage you could use to poll volt it was that hard ,the mash was just a wet mess.

When we told the waitress she said it was not her fault, i said you could see the state of the food would you eat it? she said No.

First i was not going to pay but thought i better but would not leave any tip.

We left the money in the jar excluding tip,my wife then saw her take $10 out for a tip and chased us up the street saying they were $10 light.

My wife gave her the $10 even though we new what she was up to.

NEVER AGAIN.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/24/08

Great bar!

by lbrownlady

We came here after dining in the area for some drinks. What loads of fun. So casual and good old fun with the staff. The staff were the best! Thanks for the great time. They made it a point to make sure everyone in there were having a great time. I can't remember the last bar that would do that. They usually just want your money and thats it. I will definitely come back.

  • Pros: fun staff
  • Cons: can't think of anything
3 Star Rating: Average

01/01/08

Cheap drinks, fast!

by nguyensuzan

Stopped in for a drink while we were waiting for our table next door at Perilla. We got a pint of Stella and a Stoli and Soda for $12. The crowd was mostly men around 24 yrs. old. It was New year's eve around 8:30 and they were far from busy.

I liked the charm of the place. The bartenders and waitresses were not the usual NY type (primped and made-up). Just average girls having a good time. The service was good without being fake and overly pretentious.

I would come here again. The drinks were strong, service good, and plenty of space to sit down.

Especially good if you don't want to get dressed up to got out.

  • Pros: Strong drinks
  • Cons: Musty building
2 Star Rating: Below Average

11/30/07

Disappointed

by sandy951

We went to The Slaughtered Lamb on a recommendation. When we first walked in, I was immediately overwhelmed by a horrible smell. We sat at the only pub table open and it was sticky from the last customer. No one offered to clean it and the waitress never approached us so we could place an order. She kept walking passed us as she was busy tending to people in the restaurant part of the pub. We had to go to the bar to get drinks. When I needed to use the bathroom, I could not believe how small it was. It was more like a small linen closet. You could not turn around in there and I bumped my arm on the hand drier as soon as I stood up from using the toliet. Girls, this is definitely not a bathroom to go in as a group. HeHe In fact, 2 people can not even fit in the hall were the bathrooms are located. I had to back up as I was trying to get into the ladies room to let a guy pass as he was exiting the men's room. To top it off, the famous dungeon was closed. What a disappointment. We had 2 drinks and ended up leaving.

  • Pros: Can't think of any
  • Cons: Smells, poor service and tiniest bathroom I have ever seen

The Details on Slaughtered Lamb Pub

Place Categories:

  • great beer
  • cool place
  • good service
  • great burgers
  • friendly staff
  • comfortable atmosphere
  • very good pub food
  • great music
  • bad food
  • nice fireplace
  • great sandwich
  • great sexy bartenders
  • great drinks
  • friendly conversation
  • poor fellows
  • horrible smell
  • liked charm
  • best sporting events
  • worst past 24hrs
  • rather warm brooklyn lager
  • perfect escape
  • famous dungeon
  • great bar
  • all nice bartender
  • great neighborhood
Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

The Carriage House

219 East 59th Street,, New York,, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

La Zarza Lounge

166 First Ave, New York, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Broadway Comedy Club

318 W 53rd St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Katra

217 Bowery, New York, NY

Advertisement