“The decor is good, but then you'll have to pay for it.”
“And the desserts are great too.”
“We ended up order probably three dozen oysters from the raw bar as well as an appetizer and a fish entree from the kitchen.”
“The food is great and you do pay alot for it.”
“The wine list is very extensive and has some good values.”
“Don't expect a superb dinner here, but it is a great place to run in and grab a bowl of chowder or some terrific oysters.”
“While it was a decent dining experience, I probably won't go back for the food unless it's just to for a beer and some oysters at the bar.”
“Our waiter could have been more attentive but he was by no means as terrible as some of the other reviews make out the wait service to be.”
“It provides 4 separate types of seating to fit your mood (counter, dining room, quiet back room, and oyster bar itself), has easily the largest and most varied selection of fresh oysters in the city, and has a menu that meets virtually every seafood lover”
“The mediocre food and poor service was not worth the 40 minute wait at lunch.”
This place takes you back in time. Oysters and a martini, yes please! Great place to visit if you're traveling.
New Enland clam chowder paradise.... ...the best New England clam chowder in the City, hands down. The chowder never changes and never varies - it is always fresh and delicious! A+ Have it at the counter with oyster crackers and a glass of cold tea. Heaven for less than 10 bucks...
Fried Oysters were a disgrace to the establishment's name.
I have been a loyal customer for almost ten years, but tonight made me question my loyalty.
After ordering my usual fried oyster platter, I was shocked to be presented with a few whole oysters and about two dozen tiny fried bits that were dredged up from the bottom of the fryer. When I take guests from out of town here, I don't expect a huge pile of oysters, but the ones I receive I expect to be of high quality -- medium sized and plump. Tonight was a disappointment.
To the credit of our server, he did agree to take the charge off our bill after I sent the plate back. Still, the next time I want to treat my guests to a top-notch New-York fried-oyster experience, I will look elsewhere... sadly.
Always sit in the back of GCOB by the bar, otherwise you will be overrun by tourists.
Still a NYC landmark and still the best oysters that you can find without travelling to the west coast, but over the years the waitstaff quality has dropped - they are less knowledgeable about the oysters, more into rushing you out than caring about your experience and not as cordial.
However, the food still holds up to what it was and the underground speakeasy feeling exists.
I am not a beer drinker, but when I do drink it's always dark.
Highly recommend: Turbo Dog Dark Ale with your oysters and ipswich clams.
no longer a landmark. I used to love this place but something's gone wrong over the yrs. Maybe the location and tourist cache will be enough to keep it going forever which is probably a big part of the problem. The food is no longer great and the service even much less so. skip it, go elsewhere
Get the Shrimp Pan Roast!.
Did a great walking tour of Grand Central Terminal (we love you, Justin Ferate!) and ended up smack-dab in front of the Oyster Bar. Tummies grumbling, we decided to belly-up to the bar and enjoy.
I haven't had a good pan roast in years so I ordered the shrimp pan roast. Anything that starts with a base of cream, well, I'm all over that. Decadent. Nothing could better describe each and every bite of that pan roast. Perfectly seasoned, the shrimp perfectly cooked, it was truly a thing of beauty and my tastebuds sang out. We loved sitting at the bar so we could see oysters, pan roasts and stews being prepped/made to order. Very cool! It's a don't miss when you're in the neighborhood, especially on a chilly day.
best oysters. I love going to this place with my mom. We both are big fans of seafood and they have a great selection here. I especially love their oysters and the fact that they have such a great variety of oysters to choose from!!
Humiliating Experience. I've been going to the Oyster Bar for 10+ years and have never had an experience so bad or humiliating as the one I had today at lunch. After waiting 45 minutes for our food, we got 1 of the 2 dozen oysters we ordered and were missing the panroast. The oysters we did get were an incorrect order and looked as if they had been sitting out open for quite a while. When I complained I was met with a resounding "Aaawwww" from the entire bar staff. Upon complaining to the management they nitpicked our check and were inept at resolving or addressing the problem. Sadly I feel as though this is a NY Classic in name only anymore and in all my years of eating in NY have never had an entire waitstaff humiliate me in such a way. This ranks in the top two worst dining experiences I've ever had in NY. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone.
Just Great. a ny classic - you'll never go wrong here. a bit more on the formal side but very very tasty. i've had several seafood dishes here, all of which were top notch. will have to revisit to provide more specific commentary.
I am in love with this place! We came last week and mixed green salag with beefsteak tomato- - SUPER GOOD! You have to get it when you go! I had the broiled Florida red grouper filet with
peekytoe crabm and pancetta eat wine sauce, 5 grain rice and tiramisu and it was AMAZING! My friend had the lobster and it was just as good (but mine was better). I cannot wait to come back!
yUMMYYY. moderately hung over on a sunday? Well go somewhere else, can't help you. I want the window seat at Grand Central ! You can't have it. Sitting here with the friendly staff, yummy crab, and wine just made my day.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!