Creative Costume Company

(212) 564-5552

242 W 36th St 8th Fl (7th Avenue and 8th Avenue)
New York, NY 10018 40.7527 -73.991

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Garment District, Midtown

CREATIVECOSTUME.COM

Hours:

Oct 4-8 9:30am-5pm

Oct 11-22 9:30am-6pm

Oct 25-Oct 29 9:30am-7pm

All Saturdays 10am-5pm

Last updated 2.05.12

Category:

Costumes, Novelties, Theatrical Equipment & Supplies, Rental Services, Theatrical Makeup, Halloween Events, Costume Rental, Wholesale Theatrical Make-Up, Party Supplies

Payment Methods:

American Express, Cash, Visa, MasterCard

Editor's Tips

What People Are Saying About Creative Costume Company

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

In Short – Belles of the ball know this costume rental palace. A handy list catalouges thousands of guises, and the neat-and-tidy racks of elaborate finery are sorted by type and period--from 1400s medieval to 1960s mod--for easy browsing. Glamorous getups, ranging from $50 to $350 and in adult sizes only, include matching accessories like wigs, jewelry, boas or swords. Coordinated costumes for couples also abound. Pair up as famous duos like Aladdin and Jasmine, or the more risque Cop and Hooker.

Editor's Tips

The Extras:
Normal rental is 48 hours, but they can work with you to keep it for up to a week around Halloween.
Know Before You Go:
A full list of costumes is available on their website.
Save Money:
There is a 5 percent discount for rentals paid in cash, and alterations come free with rental.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. “They have variety and some great outfits- just don't expect them to be in great shape with service along with that.”
return potential
100.0% positive
  1. “The garment quality is fantastic, and they'll do on-site alterations to make it fit you - same day or come back later.”
service
62.5% positive
  1. “good costumes, horrible service”
  2. “service was only good when they were charging my credit card.”
  3. “They have variety and some great outfits- just don't expect them to be in great shape with service along with that.”
  4. “Maybe it was because it was a few days prior to Halloween, but the service was horrible.”
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/24/11

Warm Friendly Service with a smile!

by Chuck73 at Citysearch

Not sure about the negative posts but my experience was excellent. The employees were extremely helpful. Never felt rushed. I asked a bunch of questions and they walked around with me until I found the outfit I needed. Everyone in the place smiled and said hello when they walked past me which almost NEVER happens in New York. I felt welcome.

I will make this my destination if ever I need a costume. I highly recommend it!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/17/10

Every Year

by dsolo312 at Citysearch

I stumbled upon this shop a couple of years back through a friend and wow I was impressed. You can spend a whole day if you please looking and trying on costumes. They have everything.....and that is no exaggeration. If you have a company themed party or just a little get together I would definitely recommend stopping by this shop!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/08/10

Exactly what I wanted-a cool period costume

by Dee Rhodes at Citysearch

I am new to NY from LA and went here through a recommendation of a co- worker who said he has never seen anything that comes close to the authenticity of the period costumes that he saw here. My two big "MUST's" the authenticity ( I was invited to a huge NY museum crowd theme party), and cleanliness of the costumes. Wow- this place is great. Authentic and whimsical! They fitted my gown, had a great brand new (in the wrapper )wig for me-and even helped with accessories and shoes. Great help, cool dressing rooms, very cool space. Hello NY! See you next theme event....

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/01/10

I could never go anywhere else.

by Stacy89 at Citysearch

I have been renting from this company for years! They have EVERYTHING I have ever imagined, and costumes that one could never never think of.

The ladies have been more then personable and comforting. The individual attention I receive has made it a pleasure to shop. (Even years when it was a couple of days before Halloween, and the pressure was ON.)

The prices are always within my spending range, and I ALWAYS feel I'm receiving my moneys worth. I strongly recommend Creative Costume to anyone looking to have an exquisite Halloween this year!

(As far as people with negative reviews: think twice about your complaints, it may just be you.)

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/29/10

Great costumes at great prices

by CitySlicker84 at Citysearch

I go here every year for my Halloween costume. You will find many original costume ideas and it is very affordable compared to other NYC costume stores. I definately recommend Creative Costume for anyone dressing up this Halloween.

The Details on Creative Costume Company

Place Categories:

  • bad service
  • not great costumes
  • fantastic garment quality
  • terrible help
  • nice dressing rooms
  • great outfits