Rosa Mexicano Restaurant

(212) 753-7407

1063 First Avenue
New York, NY 10022 40.7589 -73.9625

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Midtown, Sutton Place

ROSAMEXICANO.COM

What People Are Saying About Rosa Mexicano Restaurant

The Editor

Allison Austin

Citysearch

The Scene – There are two distinct personalities to the place: The loud, seemingly always-crowded bar with hanging paper decorations and dim lighting, and the two main dining areas, where the noise level and decor is notably more subdued. Service is swift, competent and helpful, though sometimes less than subtle about certain expectations, like upgrading to a double order of guacamole. – – The Food – Order the guacamole--it's quite good and made tableside with fresh lime, cilantro and jalapeno. Pork taquitos are great, but the shrimp and tuna seviche is…

1 Star Rating: Poor

10/30/09

Overrated & Overpriced

by anicunni

I went to Rosa Mexicano for the first (and last time) and left feeling really disappointed. For starters, anyone who knows me knows I love Mexican food. But this place just didn't do it for me. The selection lacks in what I would consider authentic cuisine and tries too hard to be chic. We ordered our food and I couldn't get over how SMALL the portions were! AND how PRICEY these small portions were! We had a couple of drinks and 3 appetizers and our bill came out to $75! Worse, the food was just so so, not good and definitely not great.. as far as Mexican food goes, on the bland side. The worst part of it all? We were still hungry and craving some good food by the time we left. How sad is that?

  • Cons: small portions, high prices
1 Star Rating: Poor

10/27/09

Not a place for vegetarians

by mihikae

Rosa has been my favorite mexican restaurant for 2 years now and I constantly rave about it and recommend it to friends. However I went to Rosa last Wed and was astonished with how bad their service was. I brought a very good friend of mine that was vegetarian and called beforehand to let them know that 2 of the people in our party were vegetarian.

When we got there and got around to ordering, our waiter was extremely rude and unaccommodating. My friend asked for a quesidilla with her choice of filling she was promptly told that the chef would not accommodate requests not on the menu. We asked our server to check if the chef would make an exception considering she was vegetarian and there wasn't anything but a veggie starter on available on the menu. When he returned he said the chef agreed to make the vegetarian quesidilla however would charge us $28 (this was more than the meat entrees on the menu). We agreed to pay the additional and asked him if the dish would taste good, this was when he told my friend that since she was vegetarian everything would taste good. I was so angry at his comment!

This is certainly the last time I'll be visiting Rosa or recommending it to anyone!! There are more than enough mexican restaurants in the city to never have to step into this establishment again.

  • Cons: Bad service
2 Star Rating: Below Average

03/21/09

What a rippppppppppppppppppp

by fafafafoooood

So, I went here on a date. She had an enchalada dish with shrimp and i had somethign from the grill. My dish consisted of a skewer with chroizo sausage and beef, they probably used half a chroizo... So all in all it was 1 skweer with 4 beef cubes and 3 pieces of chroizo. For starters of course we had an order of guac, asked for it to be made spicy which was ok, they made it table side.

We each had 1 drink, mine a beer and she had a frozen concoction that was not bad. All in all, with tip the bill was 2 dollars shy of $100. I am very big on money these days, btu have no problem shelling it out for a great eatery; after all, I'm a true food lover!

Bottom line is this, I only wish I had been before so i could have gone DOWNTOWN to a much better establishment such as Mole or Mercadito where we would have had much more bing for the buck food, ambiance, and money wise. Hey, even dos caminos woudl have been better!

Sorry Rosa mexicano, but aside from the 2 stars for the service, you guys stink!

  • Pros: good service
  • Cons: super over priced

The Details on Rosa Mexicano Restaurant

What to Drink:

The house margarita is a tasty blended pomegranate concoction, but there's also homemade sangria and michelada, a classic Mexican drink made with lime juice, Worcestershire sauce and Tabasco, topped off with beer.

Category:

Restaurants

Cuisine:

Mexican

Lists In Manhattan

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Rosa Mexicano Restaurant

Rosa Mexicano Restaurant

1063 First Avenue
New York, NY 10022

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

AYZA Wine & Chocolate Bar

11 W 31st St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Honey

243 W 14th St, New York, NY

2 Star Rating: Below Average

Mesa Grill

102 5th Ave, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Pasticcio Ristorante and Wine Bar

447 3RD Ave, New York, NY

Advertisement