Southwestern/Tex-Mex restaurant with one of the largest selections of premium tequilas in the U.S.
(646) 789-4474
1633 2nd Ave
(Between 85th Street and 86th Street)
New York,
NY
10028
40.777
-73.9525
Neighborhoods: Yorkville, Midtown
Hours:
Mon-Wed 4pm-1am
Thu 4pm-2am
Sat 10am-3am
Sun 10am-1am
Price:
$$
Mustang Grill
Last updated 11.20.09
What People Are Saying About Mustang Grill
The Owner
Mustang Grill
Owner
Mustang Grill is a trendy Southwestern restaurant in New York City and features exceptional and creative regional cuisines. There is a lively bar with a selection of over 100 different premium tequilas. Mustang also has one of the largest cigar selections in Manhattan, with over 50 hand-rolled imported cigars. The restaurant boasts nine big screen TVs, outdoor dining and private party rooms. Other features include Monday Night Lobster and Karaoke from 9:30pm to close, Tuesday Night Paella and Thursday through Saturday live DJ's. Visit Mustang Grill for breakfast, brunch, lunch or dinner.
The Editor
Contributor
Citysearch
Southwestern and Tex-Mex cuisine, plus more than 100 tequilas, outdoor dining, big-screen TVs, cigars for sale and more.
HORRIBLE SERVICE
by RynYoder at Citysearch
This neighborhood tequila house/grille is literally two blocks away from my apt, smack dab in the middle of (in my opinion) one of the most exciting and up and coming neighborhoods on the fabulous island of Manhattan. I will admit, I have given this place a visit once or twice for drinks during the summer when it was still tolerable to sit outside. Unfortunately, the service was less than desirable this time around.
This evening, I brought my dad to Mustangs to grab a quick bite and a drink only to apologize at the end of the meal for an unacceptable experience. Not only did our server disregard our table and not take our order in a timely fashion, he stood at the table directly next to ours and proceeded to chat with them about random topics for over 20 minutes (and I’m not embellishing) when he had yet to even take our order. I soon got the attention of the manager, thinking that he would defuse this problem and perhaps speed up the process of our meal, yet he seemed to care less than our server did about the level of service that we were receiving.
It’s unfortunate that our neighborhood is forced to put up with this type of establishment that does nothing more than take up space in the middle of our upbeat little strip. My advice? Beef up the customer service, and tackle some serious issues of laziness.
- Pros: Great plates, fantastic selection of Tequilla
- Cons: Draft beer was warm, staff was unattentive...
DEEP-SIX THE DJ!!!
by vhurtado at Citysearch
Overall I'm content with my visits to Mustang but their tunes selections SUX!!! I don't mind listening to Allman Brothers, Grateful Dead, the Doors, the Clash, Rolling Stones. But do we have to hear the same ol same ol EVERY DAY over the... last several months???? The joint used to play a variety of music during the happy hours, including good Latin songs. Maybe I need to wear an ipod while sipping my margaritas.Read More
- Pros: Attractive crowd, great margaritas, happy hour, good food
- Cons: Their happy hour music needs to DIE!!!
Great Food and Great Drinks!
by nycwino at Citysearch
My boyfriend and I eat regularly here. This is one of the best "quick eats" places on second avenue. The bloody mary's are great (very spicy) and I highly recommend the shrimp with chorizo rice (Mmm tasty). The only problem is that they have a high turnaround of servers (with good reason too, because there are only a few that are actually pleasant). At other restaurants that we regularly go to, we feel at home but not here. We continue to go back because of the food and drinks, but have never felt that welcomed. I recommend checking this place out for the food, but dont' have high expectations for service.
- Pros: Food, drinks and location
- Cons: service and remembering who is a regular
The Details on Mustang Grill
When To Go:
Live Dj's spin from Wednesday through Saturday nights.
Private Rooms:
Mustang Grill is available for office parties, bachelor parties, showers and other special events.
Category:
Restaurants, Christmas Events, Bars & Pubs
Payment Methods:
American Express, Visa, Discover, Diners Club, MasterCard
Restaurant Special Features:
Late Night Dining, Lunch Spot, Romantic Dining, Brunch, Outdoor Dining, Margaritas, Group Dining, Happy Hour, Private Parties
Musical Instrument Products:
Cuisine:
Event Planning Services:
Message from Mustang Grill
- Brunch
- Private Parties
- Hand-Rolled Imported Cigars
Mustang Grill is a trendy Southwestern restaurant in New York City and features exceptional and creative regional cuisines. There is a lively bar with a selection of over 100 different premium tequilas. Mustang also has one of the largest cigar selections in Manhattan, with over 50 hand-rolled imported cigars.
The restaurant boasts nine big screen TVs, outdoor dining and private party rooms. Other features include Monday Night Lobster and Karaoke from 9:30pm to close, Tuesday Night Paella and Thursday through Saturday live DJ's.
Visit Mustang Grill for breakfast, brunch, lunch or dinner.










Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter