The Boathouse Cafe

(212) 517-2233

E 72nd St & Park Dr N
New York, NY 10028 40.7711 -73.9638

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Upper East Side, Midtown, Lenox Hill

Price:

$$

Last updated 4.19.10

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

People Watching, Lunch Spot, Brunch, Outdoor Dining, View Dining

Cuisine:

New American

What People Are Saying About The Boathouse Cafe

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

This charming cafe sits in the midst of Central Park and serves more casual fare than its dressed-up sister restaurant.

ambiance
94.44000244140625% positive
  1. We were seated at a table right on the water outside and had a beautiful view of the pond.
  2. believe it is the most romantic dining spot in New York City.
  3. With an amazing ambience, good service and great weekend brunch what else can you ask for.
  4. great views, mediocre food, ultra-long wait
  5. How could you lose - great location and nice views.
  6. very pretty setting to have a meal, but unfortunately the service and food don't match the atmosphere.
  7. Such a romantic view of the boat pond and great items to choose from.
  8. It's a romantic and memorable location, but don't go there for any other reason.
  9. The food is fantastic, the decor is beautiful, the setting can't be beat.
dessert
33.3299994468689% positive
  1. Service is friendly but leisurely, and the foof the night we went was mostly superb: The shrimp were huge and perfectly cooked, the salads light and perfectly dressed, the crab cake appetizer the best I've had in NYC, the lobster exquisite.
  2. The service on our visit was absolutely awful - a waiter and two helpers couldn't get our orders right and ignored several pleas for basics such as water and beverage refills and utensils to eat desserts with.
  3. ve never tasted a crab cake so flavorful yet so light in texture!
drinks
66.66999816894531% positive
  1. The waiter service was terrible, I had to ask for coffee 3 or 4 times each time I wanted a refill.
  2. After the magical ride (thank you andres) we had drinks at the bar--the wine list was great, the bar staff was friendly and efficient.
  3. This was quickly forgotten by good drinks at the bar, a beautiful setting, and great service at the table.
food quality
60.71000099182129% positive
  1. The menu is great and the food is always delicious.
  2. The sirloin steak was inedible - but everything else was so good we were ready to overlook it.
  3. For the price range charged ($10 - 15 appetizers, $16 - 25 entrees) the food is merely adequate but nothing outstanding or memorable.
  4. average food, abysmal service
  5. No one liked their food so it was a huge embarssement, causing us to apologize for bringing them to The Boat House.
  6. We have been back to the Boathouse since and the food was great--how could it not be looking out over Bethesda Terrace?
  7. The food is undeniably good -- but not worth the wait.
  8. great views, mediocre food, ultra-long wait
  9. The food was NOT good.
  10. The food is fantastic, the decor is beautiful, the setting can't be beat.
  11. Service is friendly but leisurely, and the foof the night we went was mostly superb: The shrimp were huge and perfectly cooked, the salads light and perfectly dressed, the crab cake appetizer the best I've had in NYC, the lobster exquisite.
  12. ve never tasted a crab cake so flavorful yet so light in texture!
  13. Too bad the food was mediocre at best.
  14. very pretty setting to have a meal, but unfortunately the service and food don't match the atmosphere.
menu variety
100.0% positive
  1. The menu is great and the food is always delicious.
service
53.85000228881836% positive
  1. This restaurant provided the worst service that I ever experienced in my entire life.
  2. After the magical ride (thank you andres) we had drinks at the bar--the wine list was great, the bar staff was friendly and efficient.
  3. Service is friendly but leisurely, and the foof the night we went was mostly superb: The shrimp were huge and perfectly cooked, the salads light and perfectly dressed, the crab cake appetizer the best I've had in NYC, the lobster exquisite.
  4. With an amazing ambience, good service and great weekend brunch what else can you ask for.
  5. very pretty setting to have a meal, but unfortunately the service and food don't match the atmosphere.
  6. thought it was great - maybe I lucked out but our waiter was great.
  7. average food, abysmal service
  8. When I pointed this out to the waitress, she gave me a dirty look, but took it back to the kitchen- then brought out another plate that looked the same way.
  9. The service is attentive and friendly.
  10. The service on our visit was absolutely awful - a waiter and two helpers couldn't get our orders right and ignored several pleas for basics such as water and beverage refills and utensils to eat desserts with.
  11. This was quickly forgotten by good drinks at the bar, a beautiful setting, and great service at the table.
  12. This was not smart, it was hard for them to catch up with each table and service was slow.
  13. The waiter service was terrible, I had to ask for coffee 3 or 4 times each time I wanted a refill.
value
90.0% positive
  1. Service is friendly but leisurely, and the foof the night we went was mostly superb: The shrimp were huge and perfectly cooked, the salads light and perfectly dressed, the crab cake appetizer the best I've had in NYC, the lobster exquisite.
  2. The, my girlfriend took a bite and pulled out a huge walnut !
  3. No one liked their food so it was a huge embarssement, causing us to apologize for bringing them to The Boat House.
  4. For the price range charged ($10 - 15 appetizers, $16 - 25 entrees) the food is merely adequate but nothing outstanding or memorable.
  5. The food is undeniably good -- but not worth the wait.
wait time
50.0% positive
  1. FIVE minutes later he came over to me and asked, "Did you order the chcken paillard'?
  2. great views, mediocre food, ultra-long wait
  3. This was not smart, it was hard for them to catch up with each table and service was slow.
1 Star Rating: Poor

07/07/11

The Worst Service Ever

by Dvaccaro

The waiter was soooo rude and he added a 15% gratuity for party of 2 without telling us. I overlooked it and tipped an additional $13 on a $60 check. The waiter ended up receiving a $22 dollar tip for horrible service and the second I signed the check he picked it up from the table while we were still finishing our glass of wine so he new what he was doing. I feel ripped off and violated by the waiter and he was soooo rude it's really upsetting. I tried to call the restaurant and it goes straight to voicemail that is full. I am guessing it full of complaints from customers that have been ripped off and violated. Read your itemized bill very carefully if you ever go there.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/06/11

Bryan Kalman organized an amazing event at the Boathouse!

by fein

Bryan Kalman organized our Corporate Outing in June at the Boathouse and it was a terrific success. We had followed hom from Tavern on the Green and was delighted not only with him but the service at the Boathouse. The room and views were spectacular, and the personalized service Bryan Kalman offered us to make each detail come through was remarkable. Cant wait to do it again in June 2012!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

05/26/09

Fantastic Brunch

by BrunchGirl

I always enjoy coming to the Boathouse for Saturday or Sunday brunch in the summertime. Although you can't make a reservation, to grab a glass of champagne at the bar while waiting, sitting right on the water makes it worth it. The menu is great and the food is always delicious. I try to get here as often as possible and recommend it to anyone who is looking for a wonderful brunch place in great weather

  • Pros: Great Menu
  • Cons: Always so busy
4 Star Rating: Recommended

09/26/08

Enjoy a lovely lunch at the cafe!

by aerogal619

We were seated at a table right on the water outside and had a beautiful view of the pond. I really enjoy fine dining when I?m on vacation and the Boathouse did not disappoint. I shared the Lump Crab Cake, with marinated cucumbers and caper remoulade. I?ve never tasted a crab cake so flavorful yet so light in texture! It was wonderful. We also shared the Pan Roasted halibut, with braised leeks, sunchoke and crab sauce. It was worth the $27 and was still a healthy portion to share. We shared a sauvignon blanc and a bottle of flat water to top off a lovely lunch! We got there just as the restaurant opened, so the waiters were all triple sat. This was not smart, it was hard for them to catch up with each table and service was slow.

  • Pros: great view, calm setting
  • Cons: service is pretentious and unfriendly
2 Star Rating: Below Average

09/14/08

Great View Horrible Food and Service

by searchcity

On a beautiful day to be able to sit overlooking the lake while eating brunch is wonderful. But you would be better off bringing your own food and sitting on the grass, rather than eating here. We were seated promptly on a Saturday for seven people which was surprising. NO ONE came over to us for over five minutes which was unbelieveable. We kept asking men walking by to fill our water glasses. I finally had to grab a man's arm and request water. The waiter came over and took our orders. FIVE minutes later he came over to me and asked, "Did you order the chcken paillard'? Is he kidding? When are food came, six people got what they ordered, one did not, The waiter said he would bring the correct order but the person took what he got, not wishing to make a scene. HORRIBLE SERVICE. The food was NOT good. My dish came out with a salad with no dressing. It never should have left the kitchen that way. No one liked their food so it was a huge embarssement, causing us to apologize for bringing them to The Boat House. While the owners run Bryant and Cooper and River Bay flawlessly we cannot figure out why they are failing at The Boat House.

  • Pros: The View
  • Cons: Service Food

The Details on The Boathouse Cafe

Place Categories:

  • terrible waiter service
  • mediocre food
  • beautiful view
  • bad experience
  • memorable location
  • perfectly dressed shrimp
  • beautiful setting
  • favorite brunch place
  • efficient bar staff
  • wonderful eating brunch
  • most romantic dining spot
  • mediocre ultralong wait
  • perfect summer
  • outstanding nothing
  • great waiter
  • huge walnut
  • flat water
  • huge embarssement
  • very bad breath
  • bad foot
  • dirty look
  • beautiful decor
  • good drinks
  • friendly service
  • inedible fried calamari
Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement