205 E 81ST St, New York, NY | Directions 1002840.775537 -73.956007
Neighborhoods: Midtown, Yorkville
Rude, rude owner and waiter, horrible food. Stay away! – After living on the UES for several years, and always passing this place, we decided to try it. Big mistake. All of our food: appetizer, salad and 2 pasta dishes were terrible and overpriced. When we sent one of the entrees back because it was inedible, the waiter argued with us and then they tried to charge us for it. When we told the owner that we couldn't even eat it and sent it back whole, he argued with us as well. He even yelled at us at our table. Service like this is appalling no matter where you go, but especially considering the prices they charge. Don't waste your time or money. There are plenty of other places on the UES and elsewhere in this city.
Rudest Staff Ever - Walked Out – Sorry if this is re-post (having computer trouble):
I took two out-of-town friends in on a Sunday afternoon at 1pm. A man who must have been the owner treated us so poorly that we walked out without ordering.
After rudely asking us what we were doing there, and finally seating us, he screamed at us that the place "wasn't a cafeteria" when we asked if he was serving cappuccino. He then tried to apologize feebly that he thought we weren't going to order food. He made us so uncomfortable that we left, and his attitude was "good riddance."
With his over-priced menu, un-friendly atmosphere, and hideous commedia dell'arte paintings on the wall,s you can get much better Italian fare with a much nicer staff just about anywhere else. I will never eat here, and neither will any of my friends, family, or co-workers.
Ordinary at best. Average food with bad service. – I have lived on the UES for 4 years and with so many restaruants on the UES, there is no way we would go back to this one. Atmosphere is tired and stuffy. The ceiling has nice bronze colored tiles and know this because had time to study it while waiting an HOUR for my food (which was ordinary at best). I had the fettuccine bolognese. Seriously, you can get a better meal at most any italian restaurant on the UES. The waiters speak bearly any english and ours was less then apologetic after such a long wait. Bottom line - if you want a unique experience with good food and great service, don't go to Quattro Gatti. I should have went to the food emporium across the street and cooked at home.
Very average – The food was very avearge. My group had a range of appetizers and pasta dishes and none stood out as either especially good or especially bad. The service was generally disinterested--not terrible, but also not terribly helpful. The atmosphere is a bit odd, with surrealist paintings clashing badly with the otherwise muted decor. The wine list is very nice, but given the underwhelming overall experience I'd rather buy a bottle of wine from a store and make pasta at home. There are better Italian places in the neighborhood that charge the same amount or less, so there isn't really any reason to come here.
Know what you are getting – I went to order the $15 pasta Bolognese (as recommeded in a previous post), and the thick accented waiter told me- with much gusto- that the Bolognese was a boring standard menu item, and I must order one of the two daily pasta specials... So, I order the tagliatelli with truffles.
Although I expected the special to be slightly more expensive than the standard menu items, I was SHOCKED when the bill came and the Tagliatelli dish was a hefty $70! No kidding, $70 for a pasta dish.
If I wanted to spend $70 on a menu item I would have gone to Babbo, Nobu, or any other celebrity chef restaurant, not a local 81st street Italian restaurant.
I feel like I got ripped off. If you order a special, make sure to ask what it costs.
Four Cheers for Quattro Gatti! – Yes, it's true, it's better to be a regular here. But that's easy to accomplish once you're addicted to the Pasta Bolognese, which my husband and I recommend with the homemade Papardelle pasta. We have been eating at this charming neighborhood spot for two years and have only strayed from our addiction twice - both times being pleased - yet we can't get enough of the Bolognese! Mario was our favorite waiter - he welcomed us by name, like guests in a friend's home - but he is sadly gone and we have yet to bond as closely with anyone else (one of the waiters is admittedly a little grumpy, but that can be overcome with smiles). Nevertheless, "Quattro Gatti" still offers a satisfying meal, in a pleasant ambience, at a reasonable price. In good weather, sit outside, and you will be momentarily transported to Italia!
only for regulars – Okay, Id rather pour my own wine anyway, and lack of a cooler for the white wine is no big thing. And the abrupt attitude of the waiter could be just considered professional. And I didnt mind that they seemed most attentive to people they knew. And when they brought two veal marsalas instead of one marsala and one veal medallions and the server refused to deal with it, we felt we could live with it. But when we were charged accordingly and politely tried to have the bill adjusted and were told in a nasty and condescending tone that we didnt know what we were talking about --- even though both plates featured identical scaloppini with identical mushroom and identical wine sauce --- I decided it was just not a nice place, at least for newcomers.
cute place, excellent food – Even the Italians from Italy vote that the food here is not so commercial and quite similiar to the cuisine they are used to at home and back in Italy, best choice for true diners with a real palate for quality food and ability to distinguish between fresh fish and meat, and commercial volume italian pasta! The food was excellent, very fresh fish and meat, excellent wines, great desserts, nothing is dissapointing int his cute upper east side italian run place, even the service and ambiance is very charming! great for a date, except be prepared for the damage on the wallet after a three course meal, it can get a little high on the price side, but definitely worth it! wouldnt recommend any other itaian restaurants in that neighbrhood,e xcept buon gusto
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Quattro Gatti Restaurant Inc on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.