Heidelberg Restaurant

12/24/09

Overrated

by NJ Analyst at Citysearch

This is a casual restaurant with adequate (not great) food and decent German beer. Perhaps the neighborhood (Upper East Side) is the reason why the prices are high for the food. Bread was stale. Portions were small for the prices. I had Jaegerschnitzel and a beer and the tab came to over $30 before the tip. On the other hand, the waitress was very polite but in most places outside of NYC this is the norm. I can do better in NJ.

• Pros: Beer, service
• Cons: Food is overpriced

08/26/09

Lip off Restaurant

by I hate HEIDELBERGE at Citysearch

We sat at the bar and asked bar menu

The bartender at the bar did not know bar menu and anyone else knew it

They charged two times more than bar menu and did not say sorry for it

This is the worst restaurant ever and should be closed this kind of lip off restaurant.

Worst restaurant forever!!

• Pros: Worst restaurant of Germany
• Cons: Lip off Menu

04/19/09

Awful service - don't bother

by nrggirl at Citysearch

If you want to wait an hour for a beer, two for food, and never order a second beer - by all means eat here. Their service is consistently awful (read reviews anywhere about the place) and it's really not worth getting frustrated about it your whole meal. There are better German places in NYC with infinitely better service. Run! Run far away!

• Pros: decent food
• Cons: waitresses could care less that you exist