Elio's Restaurant

(212) 772-2242

1621 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10028 40.7768 -73.9527

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Midtown, Yorkville

What People Are Saying About Elio's Restaurant

The Editor

Karen Hudes

Citysearch

The Scene – Dark wood, landscape paintings and Old-World sconces hint at the classic attitude of this Italian favorite, which attracts its share of families, middle-aged friends and the occasional celebrity. Warm, golden light flatters everyone, though the high noise level can distract from conversation. Service is professional and well-timed, performed by cordial, professional waiters. – – The Food – The cooking offers more satisfaction than surprise. Bresaola valtellina, a thin layer of dried beef over arugula, has a delicate texture and zesty flavor, and the shrimp…

1 Star Rating: Poor

12/18/08

TASTELESS FOOD

by sunsun99

We used to be regulars for years since service used to be great and delighting food. This last two years we have been going there less frequently becuase the FOOD is TASTELESS compared to what it used to be. We ordered a plate of calamari as our appetizer and were disappointed by the flavor of the sauce. The calamari were like rubers with sauce with no flavor. As my main course, I ordered the Fettuccine Amatriciana. Again no FLAVOR and the pasta looked like a flour-ball. I thought the pasta was handmade but could have heard the waiter incorrectly. My friend's fish had a rooten smell and TASTELESS SAUCE. I would not go back anymore and would not recommend to anybody!

What happened, the CHEF lost the TOUCH!

  • Pros: NONE
  • Cons: TASTELESS FOOD, OVERPRICED
1 Star Rating: Poor

10/22/08

What lies beneath!

by gastroreviewer

We are not the types to write reviews, but take note of this one....Decent food (which is why we gave it one star -- even if we could give it zero stars we wouldn't) but deceptively overpriced. We blew well over 100 dineros on a shared bowel of pasta and veal meatballs, a glass of mediocre house wine, a martini, an artichoke app, and a bland Caesar salad. It was more like a Cesaraen salad, for when the bill came, replete with hidden charges for sharing an entree or for a "warm appetizer" or for perhaps just not being a member of the mob, it felt like childbirth without an epidural. Bottom line = skip it. You can find better food for far less in that hood. The ambience is cozy. But

  • Pros: Decent fare
  • Cons: Extreme price, deceptive menu pricing shannanigans
2 Star Rating: Below Average

09/27/07

Horrible service, over priced food

by alesia_star

I hate to write anything bad about a place, but Elio's was a waste of $114 for two people at dinner. We were seated and given menus 10 minuets later, we asked for water and never got it, we ordered a glass of red wine and a scotch ($36 bar tab), asked for parm on our soup twice before it came.... Our waiter was MIA almost the entire night. We had to keep asking other waiters for assistance. They charged $32 for a tiny filet of sole dipped in egg and pan fried. The "special" sausage and pasta dish for $26 was a step-up from Hamburger Helper. The vegetables were all very fresh and prepared wonderfully ad the soup was excellent. The bread was very good as well. I just hate spending good money to eat out and not getting good service. This was my second trip to Elio's and will be my last.

  • Pros: Soup, bread, veggies
  • Cons: price and service

The Details on Elio's Restaurant

Save Time:

The risotto takes 30 minutes to prepare, so be sure to order it early.

Where to Sit:

For a more casual bite, the restaurant also serves food at the bar.

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

American Express, Visa, MasterCard

Cuisine:

Italian

Lists In Manhattan

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Elio's Restaurant

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

1 Star Rating: Poor

Sushi Seki

1143 1st Ave, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

A Voce Columbus

10 Columbus Circle, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Ninja New York

25 Hudson St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

AYZA Wine & Chocolate Bar

11 W 31st St, New York, NY

Advertisement