(212) 719-5799

221 W 46TH St Ste 1
New York, NY 10036 40.7593 -73.9865

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Theater District - Times Square, Midtown

SOFIASNY.COM

Last updated 10.17.11

Category:

Catering, Restaurants

Catering Services:

Banquets

Cuisine:

Italian

ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. Great atmosphere.
dessert
100.0% positive
  1. love the food , service and that all to visable dessert display!
food quality
66.66999816894531% positive
  1. The food was execellent, the service very professional and all at a good value.
  2. And when it done, one dish was cold - so they nuked it.
  3. The food was absoutly exquisite and the wait staff was courteous and very helpful for all a very reasonable price.
  4. This restaurant is no better than the Olive Garden for authentic italian cuisine.
  5. the food was fantastic.
  6. The restaurant was drabby and loud, food was mediocre, the Napolean was not all that, and the wait staff was absent.
  7. Broadway's theater district has a great HIT in Sofia's the food is tasty, bountiful and ready when you need it to be so you can make that all too important curtain call.
  8. love the food , service and that all to visable dessert display!
  9. The best Italian food this side of Italy!
  10. good food, mediocre service
  11. The service was slow, but the food was excellent.
  12. very bad food, terrible service.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. great pre-theater place!
service
39.28999900817871% positive
  1. very bad food, terrible service.
  2. The restaurant was drabby and loud, food was mediocre, the Napolean was not all that, and the wait staff was absent.
  3. me and my husband thought it was brand new by the terrible service.
  4. The staff was rude and service was terrible.
  5. The food was absoutly exquisite and the wait staff was courteous and very helpful for all a very reasonable price.
  6. good food, mediocre service
  7. Our server was decent enough, but he did not pay attention to us, and he asked me questions in regards to my mother's order (um, she can speak for herself).
  8. The service was slow and quite rude.
  9. The service was slow, but the food was excellent.
  10. love the food , service and that all to visable dessert display!
  11. Service was extremely slow, my sister thought maybe because we were two women, but by the reviews I see, it's just the crappy service.
  12. the place was full and still the service was great.
  13. The food was execellent, the service very professional and all at a good value.
  14. was a server during college so I usually tip well but this was very poor service.
value
100.0% positive
  1. The food was absoutly exquisite and the wait staff was courteous and very helpful for all a very reasonable price.
  2. The food was execellent, the service very professional and all at a good value.
  3. You get good value and an above average dinner.
wait time
12.5% positive
  1. Service was very slow: our water glasses were rarely filled, and it took forever to get the check.
  2. Service was extremely slow, my sister thought maybe because we were two women, but by the reviews I see, it's just the crappy service.
  3. The service was slow and quite rude.
  4. The service was slow, but the food was excellent.
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/01/12

My Sinatra and Sofia's makes a fantastic evening

by Kampfire

Audiences of the Hit Off-Broadway show, My Sinatra, can enjoy a delicious prix-fixe meal of Italian fare upstairs in the restaurant, before or after the performance, as part of their ticket price: $105 premium and $85 general admission.

The “devil-may-care,” style and incomparable charm of Frank Sinatra surge through the microphone once again at Cary Hoffman’s “riveting” show, My Sinatra. This one man musical explores the sometimes strange, frequently hilarious, and always interesting life of Hoffman himself; A Sinatra idolizer with an unparalleled ability to channel the voice of Ol’ Blue Eyes. Throughout My Sinatra, Hoffman interweaves his personal tale of musical obsession with the star, telling his own hard to believe larger-than-life story, highlighting it with “mesmerizing” (The LA Times) performances of Sinatra’s greatest hits.

www.mysinatra <dot> com

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

12/20/11

theatre district-not a "tourist rap"

by shanatema

From the very first time we ate there, it was just pure luck! Our parking attendant(who by the way is a gem) raved about Sofias. We were 6 women going to the theatre and decided to just play it by ear! Boy were we lucky. It's hard to get 6 women to agree on anything, but we were all pleased by the food, ambiance, attention by the waiter and just a general feel good place. When in doubt it is always our go to place, especially on a cold winter night when you don't feel like fighting the crowds, and mot theatres are right there. Food is always top notch, plentiful, and when you want to share a meal it is always plated in the kitchen. They are always willing to do a separate "bar bill" as some people don't dink and don't want to pay for others. No problemo! I don't understand the "tourists" reviews and just felt that as a native I had to "defend" one of our own. Even a native Italian had nothing but high praise-and boy is she hard to please-espcially when her pasta is no aldente. Great choice for pre theatre or just if you want a great meal and don't want to pay big bucks! In fact we will be there this week pre-theatre with eight of us! Mange, and enjoy-you don't get to stay a NY restaurant or over 30 years for nothing!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

04/18/11

Surely you don't mean the jazz club below the restaurant?

by Prester John

I know nothing of the restaurant at street level. However 221 w. 46th st. is also the location of Sofia's Club Cachet which is downstairs from the restaurant and accessible thru the lobby of the Edison Hotel next door, So pardon me for setting the record straight to avoid confusing the 2.

This old, fairly well maintained nightclub is one of New York's greatest bargains. On Monday and Tuesday nights from 8-11 they have Vince Giordano's Nighthawk Orchestra, THE best hot jazz and dance band worldwide, his band being featured in the HBO series Boardwalk Empire.

Additionally the food is fairly inexpensive averaging $15.00 for an entree, which is also the cover charge. Well worth it in my opinion, for where else can you listen live to an 11 piece 1920's style hot dance and jazzband!!!

Fortunately there is a decent sized dance floor, a great bar at the farther end and courteous waitstaff with none of the attitude mentioned regarding the restaurant above.

No, I'm not a club owner, nor do I play one on TV, just an enthusiastic fan of live jazz.

2 Star Rating: Below Average

12/27/10

Incredibly Rude

by eastcoaster13

We went to this restaurant because it was next to our theater and, with a blizzard raging outside, we didn't have the energy to search further. The food here was decent, but the service was unforgivably rude. Aside from some often-experienced mistakes at tourist restaurants (forgetting to refill the water, taking plates before people were done), our waitor Dominic treated us as if our presence there was an offense to all of his sensibilities. He threw menus at us, when we asked for silverware to share dessert, he tossed down 3 forks for the five of us (they even bounced!), and rejected any attempt at pleasantries. He attempted to be a snob, but despite being from Phildelphia, we were not the country hicks he seemed to take us for and could tell he was mispronouncing the Italian names and knew nothing about Italian wine. In the end we complained to the manager, but after we saw how he treated other patrons he was "seating," I'm not sure it did much good.

1 Star Rating: Poor

07/08/09

Rude...Rude...Rude

by Bchac

I had the misfortune of going to this place last Wednesday. 7/1/09. The older gentleman "host" seemed to act as if we were doing him a favor by eating there. Service was extremely slow, my sister thought maybe because we were two women, but by the reviews I see, it's just the crappy service. The waiters keep the check books in the back of there pants so when I got the bill I also got the waiters butt sweat. I never complained once until I went to the bathroom. It looked like a toilet had overflown, wet toilet paper all over the floor and just plain gross. I said to the "host" as we were leaving "I think you should check the condition of the bathroom" he literally raised his shoulder and walked by me. I said "excuse me?", he then walked by me again giving me that cold shoulder movement. I have never experienced such rudeness - EVER!!! I am sorry to say that after I left I was so enraged by this I went back into the restaurant, spat on the floor and said "clean this up (explitive)!" Not my finest moment, but have to say it felt good. I would have rather gone to the pizzeria - the food would have been better, they would have be nicer and the place would have been cleaner.

Oh, and their bathrooms weren't handicapped compliant. Guess they care about people in wheelchairs as much as they do everone else!

  • Pros: Not one - oh yeah it was close to the theater.
  • Cons: Rude, Disgusting bathroom, incredibly slow service!

The Details on Sofia's

Place Categories:

  • terrible service
  • best italian food
  • inviting sofia
  • mediocre food
  • full place
  • good value
  • cold dish
  • rude staff
  • order fried calamari
  • love visable
  • best seat
  • decent server
  • worst resturant
  • great pretheater place
  • poor rating
  • authentic italian cuisine
  • good above average dinner
  • great atmosphere
  • decent alright
  • great hit
  • excellent play
  • poor acoustics
  • great italian restaurant
  • cold shoulder movement
  • very best trad jazz band
Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Curry Dream

66 W. 39th St, New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Libation

137 Ludlow St., New York, NY

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Blackstones Pub & Restaurant

245 E 55th St, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Garage Restaurant and Cafe

99 7th Avenue South, New York, NY

Advertisement