Trattoria Dopo Teatro

Recommends

Ali Pasha

Joined 3 years ago

amazing experience. We had reservations and were seated promptly. They had an extensive, well-selected wine list from Italy and the world. The homemade bread was delicious and so were the pasta dishes and the pizza. Service was attentive and friendly. It was a great experience all around.

Recommends

NYCService

Joined 6 years ago

Excellent Food and Service

Doesn't Recommend

bagus56

Joined 7 years ago

Trattoria Forgetaboutit. Had reservation for over 1 week and they sat us at the bar,when the upstairs was somewhat empty.(strike one) The appetizers were nice portions the tuna tartar very fresh but the roasted artichokes were not roasted( right from the can). The risotto with sepia and black ink was very good, except sepia is cuttlefish NOT calamari.The main course was Osso Bucco which was very salty as was the Roasted StuFfed Veal Chop(strike two). Upon ordering a bottle of Pinot Noir I was informed they were out of this lable, after giving them another Pinot Noir I was later(much later) told that they were out of Pinot Noir and I was offered a bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon( was told that this was close to what I ordered)(strike three). The coffee was luke warm and the tarte was so-so.There were a few other items that would be a waste of your time, as would going to this restaurant(?) in the first place. I know my restaurants and this is not one to go to.

Recommends

Alexis Korman

Joined 5 years ago

Citysearch Editorial Review. Due to its prime Theater District location, this cavernous Italian eatery is often overlooked by locals, and is instead frequented by tourists trying to zip in and out before a show. What a shame, considering that it turns out super-satisfying homemade pasta dishes--like rich gorgonzola gnocchi and perfectly cooked pappardelle--that encourage leisurely dining with a glass of vino. The restaurant’s multiple private rooms, wine cellar and unique (if Disney-esque) interior garden, complete with waterfall, make a trip to Trattoria Dopo Teatro a transporting experience.

Recommends

MMay

Joined 4 years ago

Amazing dinner : ). We were a party of 8 on a Thursday night going to the theater, so I was a little worried about the experience, but they made our night. The hostess was very friendly and sat us right away at a very nice round table in the dinning room. The waiter was so attentive and nice despite the fact that he had his hands full with lots of other tables. He was a very nice Italian guy named Roberto, ask for him when you go, the guy is great and knows a lot about food and wine. He helped us to choose a great bottle for the table of Chianti classico that complemented our dishes perfectly. Well and than comes the food, simply amazing! We had the ossobuco, better than I've ever had! My husband still raves about his sea bass, it was crispy and delicious. My sister had an amazing pasta with rabbit ragout. I had this delicious salad with shredded apples, blue cheese, sun dried tomatoes and speck. Oh, you get the idea... Everyone of my guests was raving about the food. Needless to say, I'm planning another dinner there and recommend the restaurant very highly. We made the play and really had a wonderful experience! Thank you guys : )

Recommends

Italia1

Joined 4 years ago

Delizioso. The first time I've been to Dopo Teatro I ordered a plate of pasta and it was delicious! I love this restaurant and I would recommend it to anyone! The food, service, and design is amazing! I also met the chef and he looked like a wonderful cook and was very sweet to me and my boyfriend. After that night I've been there more then 20 times! It is a wonderful restaurant and it is located in a the heart of Manhattan! I've also been there for New Years and even though it was extremely crowded the service was still amazing and the food was DELICIOUS!

The only thing I can say is that I love this restaurant and would recommend it to anyone!

Recommends

Jony

Joined 4 years ago

Very Good. I like this place, but I think that it should have more light, because I coudn't see the menu even with a cell phone. It's a very good place though, i really love it.

Doesn't Recommend

Deveeight

Joined 4 years ago

One Star is still being generous. I went here with my girlfriend for dinner thinking we would be treated for a nice meal, boy were we wrong. The waiter kept looking at us like it was a bother just to do what he was suppose to do and that was just take our order. The service was bad, the food was just as bad. Me and my girlfriend couldn't decide which one was worse the service or the food. We couldn't flag him down for water or even when we had to get the check. The only glorifying thing was seeing the waiters look on his face when we left him a penny tip. Like he expected more for not doing his Job. Take it from me there are plenty of other spots that you can go to for authentic Italian cuisine for half the price

Recommends

Bob454

Joined 4 years ago

Tasty Italian. We went here before a Broadway show. Everyone loved their meal. The food was prepared very nicely and served by friendly people. The atmosphere was quite nice and we'd go back again.

Doesn't Recommend

jbridget

Joined 5 years ago

WORST PLACE EVER~!!!!. Do NOT come here!!! Worst food and service I may have EVER experienced! Sat for at least an hour while ALL the waiters working refused to make eye contact! Finally someone took our order but soon after, even the appetizers came before the waiter realized AND THEN served us our bottle of wine. Most unimpressive food and ridiculous service ever... I would give this establishment negative ratings!!!!!!!!!