save

Naples 45

200 Park Avenue, New York, NY | Map it  

10166 40.752910 -73.977809

(212) 972-7000 | View Website

4

out of 5

4 Star Rating: Recommended

30 Reviews

Sign in to Write a Review

My Rating

Great for Holiday After Work Drinks - Pizzas - Fresh Salads - Pastas - Cocktails

Features

Neighborhoods:
Midtown Center, Midtown
Cuisine:
Italian, Pizza
Categories:
Restaurants

View More

Payment Methods:
MasterCard, Discover, Visa, American Express, Diners Club
Restaurant Special Features:
Lunch Spot

View Less

Review Highlights

ambiance
100%
“While the food was decent and the service was good, I wouldn't recommend it if you are looking for outdoor seating with any kind of ambience.”
dessert
100%
“The cheesecake was also quite pleasant.”
drinks
100%
“The wine was wonderful and the pizza (which was free) was even better than the wine.”
food quality
95%
“If you're not into pizza, there are over 10 Piccoli Piatti for sharing and my boyfriend loves the pasta options.”
View More
menu variety
100%
“If you're not into pizza, there are over 10 Piccoli Piatti for sharing and my boyfriend loves the pasta options.”
overall
87%
“had take out but it was quite good, not sure how expensive this place is but it's not a bad place to go.”
service
78%
“The service is a little spotty, albeit our server was very nice.”
value
54%
“had take out but it was quite good, not sure how expensive this place is but it's not a bad place to go.”
wait time
50%
“We were having drinks and a series of apps and pizza at their really nice long bar.” View Less

Reviews for Naples 45

TKM

Member since Aug, 2009 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
TKM
Joined 3 years ago
1.0
August 24, 2009

TERRIBLE SERVICE, TERRIBLE ATTITUDE. I had the unfortunate pleasure of being asked to step outside and wait for food that had been purchased because a disgruntled patron decided to walk up to me and a friend and tell us that the seats we were sitting in were for people who were eating, he would have had a valid point if there werent several additional seats for him to sit in and if we werent waiting for our food!

When we told him he was incredibly rude, he proceeded to be nasty with us, while the entire wait and cooking staff in the go portion of the restauraunt watched.

Thier solution was then to ask us to just wait outside because the altercation was disturbing others...

I will never go back to this restauraunt because I never want to run into the nasty man again for the fear that I might whip his ANGLE SIDE SIDE on sight, and the management team handled the situation poorly, because if they would have intervened when he approached us, we would have never had to address him directly.

View More View Less
0

mdagesq

Member since Nov, 2006 View Profile
3Reviews
0Photos
Joined 6 years ago
4.0
December 11, 2008

Real Italian style pizza.. Really, really good pizza. Takes me back to Italy. Pretty pricey, but this is Manhattan. Nice decor. Service just OK.

0

mabascal7

Member since Mar, 2007 View Profile
3Reviews
0Photos
Joined 5 years ago
3.0
January 10, 2008

Coincidences of Life?. I have never eaten at Naples 45, but I found it surprisingly funny that two different users writting a review could thing exactly the same. If you look at llauren234's text ("Authentic Neapolitan Pizza") and sps424's ("Best Pizza in New York") is really amazing to see how 2 different individuals could think the same way and express it with exactly the sames words (albeit the Title) about the restaurant. Funny coincidence. Or maybe some management insider trying to boost this place reputation for a lack of a better thing to do.... or a lack of customers... maybe. Just a thought. BTW, these users had the same recomendations about other places reviewed here in Citisearch.

View More View Less
0

jsp424

Member since Aug, 2007 View Profile
26Reviews
0Photos
Joined 5 years ago
5.0
October 25, 2007

Best Pizza in New York!. Naples 45 is definitely the best pizza in New York! My office is in the Met Life building, and I go there all the time for the authentic pizza. Its not your typical, greasy NY slice. The cheese is the freshest youll find and the crust is flawlessly cooked. They make rectangular pizzas exactly like the pizziolis do in Naples, Italy, and have received a seal of approval for authenticity. If youre not a pizza fan, the salads are full of tasty ingredients, and my boyfriends a huge fan of the pasta dishes. They also have a shop full of gourmet delights, and they deliver!

View More View Less
0

mel0714

Member since Jan, 2006 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 6 years ago
1.0
September 21, 2007

Terrible. I had the misfortune of chosing this restaurant for a business lunch. Service was mediocre as was the food. The major problem was that they ended up charging my credit card A FEW TIMES OVER with various incorrect charges.

In trying to correct the situation, I had to make countless phone calls, leave unanswered messages and faxes to the corporate office. Situation has still yet to be corrected

AVOID, AVOID, AVOID!!

View More View Less
0

See more reviews for Naples 45