(718) 442-9401
524 Port Richmond Ave
Staten Island,
NY
10302
40.6301
-74.1404
Neighborhood: Elm Park
What People Are Saying About Denino's Pizzeria Tavern
The Editor
Contributor
Citysearch
The Scene – Run by the original founders and their descendants since 1937, this working-class tavern caters to people on and off Staten Island, including Brooklynites and folks from Bayonne, a short bridge ride away. Families abound, often with small children in tow. Decor is strictly utilitarian, and service--most likely by a member of the extended family--is friendly, brisk but unhurried. – – The Food – Oh, what a pie! Dissect the 16-inch plain rounds, and every component measures up: the thin yet supportive bread-dough crusts, tangy rich red sauce and cheese so…
06/12/09
Very nice pie....
by captsteve
I've been here twice and thought it was great both times. Would definatly go back. The pies always come out quick ard are perfectly cooked.
- Pros: Great Crust
03/29/09
Just okay
by mangiafa
How this place continues to be rated best pizza on SI is beyond me. Joe & Pat's is way better all around. Yes, it's a different style of pizza but taste is taste. I guess at $11 a pie it's a bargain these days. Salvatore of Soho on Hylan has an excellent coal fired pie too. $18 for the pie but a delicious pie.
- Pros: Good crust
- Cons: Too much cheese, not enough sauce.. Mediocre taste
02/03/09
Poor pizza
by criticB
It was our first (and last) time there. The place was jammed and this seemed to jive with the "legend" that they had fantastic pizza. It was a long wait for our table. The green salad was very generous in size and fresh . We ordered two pies, a sausage/meatball and a mushroom/onion; they were terrible. There was barely any flavor, the entire crust was over cooked to a hard crisp and ingredients appeared to be used very sparingly. We debated sending them back but the pies on nearby tables appeared to be in the same shape and we were not hopeful for a significant improvement. The waitress had no problem getting us $drinks$ but took forever with 2 reminders to get us water. Perhaps they were legends in their time but that time has passed.
- Pros: Generous fresh garden salad
- Cons: bad pizza, long wait, difficult parking
The Details on Denino's Pizzeria Tavern
Bar Snacks:
You could be in for a wait of up to 1 1/2 hours for a table on Friday nights. Luckily, the bar's stocked with everything you need to chill out: a TV, a cold pitcher (or cocktails, if you so desire), and a full menu.
Party Central:
Although none of the 150-seat restaurant and bar space is available for rental, the owners will open a private space next door as early as the summer of 2003.
Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter