Magic Mark is at the Dugout..
I moved to Staten Island from the city in 2009 and am now a regular at the Dugout. The food is great and there's a lot to choose from. They have at least six big screens and will put your game on if you ask. Beer and drink specials, bands, DJs and the occasional promotion when they give stuff away. I've never seen a fight in there and they got a huge patio area in front to smoke or just hang out when the weather is nice. I love this place.
This place is dreadful. I was looking forward to trying their burgers, but after being in there forever in the dark and having the bartender completely ignore us when it wasn't even that busy I gave up. You would find better service next door at lunchbox. Its cleaner, brighter, smells better, food is great and people are actually there to serve you.