Best of Citysearch
Recommend this business?
view & uploadphotos
- Neighborhoods:
- Downtown, West Village
At a Glance
?
90% ambiance
“Village favorite, Magnolia's got a pleasant staff and a wicked sense of cake decoration.”
68% dessert
“The frosting is sugary and one-note, and the cake is dry and tough (hello.”
50% drinks
“That's about a $1.74 more than they are worth Oh yeah and the coffee was cold.”
84% food quality
“In short: hype from people who long for a tasty cupcake but don't know what a good cupcake really is.”
100% menu variety
“There is a huge variety of cupcakes to choose from (I usually buy 4-6”
60% overall
“Good good this place”
66% return potential
“don't think I'll come back to Magnolia Bakery, mainly because I was really turned off on the service and the dry cupcakes.”
60% service
“For this very reason, it is not only wrong, it's amazing to me when I run across such pompous, unacceptable service.”
66% value
“the first time I had a cupcake from Magnolia, i was disappointed, the frosting was overly sweet and yes, absolutely disguisting, not worth 10 cents, let alone $1.75, however,i gave it a second chance, and they must have tweaked the recipe, because the fro”
57% wait time
“love homestyle desserts as long as they taste great and are halfway presentable, but these cupcakes are cute at best and fall flat in the taste department too.”
People also viewed
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.
Best of Citysearch
Won for:
Cupcakes
(2013)
Nominated for:
Breakfast
(2010)
Dessert Spot (2010)
Bakery (2009)
Takeout (2008)
Bakery (2005)
West Village Shop (2005)
Dessert Spot (2010)
Bakery (2009)
Takeout (2008)
Bakery (2005)
West Village Shop (2005)