Best Of Citysearch
Restaurants
Bars & Clubs
Spa & Beauty
Hotels
Shopping
Guides
Mobile
Login
/
Join
More
Go!
Advertise With Us
New York, NY Metro
>
Manhattan
>
Restaurants
>
Sugar & Plumm
>
Menu
Sugar & Plumm
(212) 787-8778
377 Amsterdam Ave
,
New York
,
NY
|
Directions
10024
40.782497
-73.978614
View Website
Menu
Save
Best of Citysearch
Recommend this business?
Thumbs Up
Thumbs Down
?
not rated
yet
Menu for Sugar & Plumm
Breakfast
|
Brunch
|
Lunch
|
Dinner
|
Cocktails
|
Dessert
Breakfast
Non-Fat Greek Yogurt
Vanilla bean hudson valley yogurt, fresh berries, toasted almonds
Three Blue Heirloom Eggs
Brioche, sourdough, or 7-grain toast, house jam
Options: Sourdough, 7-grain toast
Benedicts
Poached eggs, house made rosemary focaccia, lemon hollandaise
Classic (Smoked Canadian Bacon)
House-Smoked Salmon
Lemon Spinach
Angus Beef Short Rib One
Steak and Eggs
Sliced creek stone flat iron, fresh avocado, cilantro mojo
Country Scramble
Organic egg, NY cheddar, tasso ham, shallot, marble potato, roasted Cubanelle salsa verde
Our Omelet
Mushroom, spinach, roasted tomato, NY cheddar
Your Omelet
Options: Cheddar, Muenster, Goat cheese, Spinach, Mushroom, Cipollini onion, Roasted tomato, Roasted pepper, House marinated olives, Ham, Nueske’s bacon, Pork banger, Chicken apple sausage, Egg whites
The Original Lemon Ricotta Pancake
Berry compote, lemon curd, vermont maple syrup
Sugar and Plum Crunch Toast
Brioche, strawberry compote, vanilla, mascarpone cheese
Signature Waffle Sandwiches
West Sidewich
Ny cheddar, neuske’s bacon, fried heirloom egg, vermont maple syrup
East Sidewich
Roasted mushroom, muenster cheese, fried heirloom egg, salsa verde
Coffee and Tea
Coffee
Cappuccino / Cafe Latte
Mocha Latte
Macchiato
Espresso
Americano
Red Eye
Iced Coffee
Extra Shot
Coffee and Tea
Tea
Iced Tea
Hot Chocolate
Fountain Soda
Floats
Fresh Made Lemonade
Juice
Milk
Chocolate Milk
Buck Wheat Crepes
Ham and Gruyere
Options: Blue heirloom egg
Spinach and Mushroom
NY muenster
House-Smoked Salmon
Creme fraiche, red onion, capers
House Smoked Chicken
Roasted vegetables
Shrimp & Avocado
Market greens, lemon vinaigrette
Savory Waffles
Chicken and Waffles
Smoked crispy free range chicken, vermont maple syrup, dairy farm butter
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Pulled Pork and Waffles
House-smoked 72-hour pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw, jalapeño
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Bacon, Egg, and Cheese
Neuske’s bacon, NY cheddar, fried heirloom egg, vermont maple syrup
Roasted Mushroom
NY muenster, cured tomato, baby arugula, sherry vinaigrette
Ham, Spinach, and Heirloom Egg
Gruyere fondue
Sweet Crepes and Waffles
Butter and Sugar
Dairy farm butter, natural sugar
Lemon, Butter, and Sugar
Dairy farm butter, lemon juice, natural sugar
Nutella
Options: Banana
Cajeta Caramel
Goats’ milk caramel, salted caramel ice cream, fresh whipped cream
Mixed Berry
Vanilla bean ice cream
Apple Tatin
Roasted apples, vanilla bean ice cream, salted caramel
Sides
Neuske's Bacon
Blue Eggs (2)
Chicken-Apple Sausage
Short Rib Hash
Simple Salad
Shoe String Fries
Seasonal Fruit and Berries
Marble Potato Hash
Brunch
Benedicts
Poached heirloom eggs, house made rosemary focaccia, lemon hollandaise
Classic (Smoked Canadian Bacon)
Lemon Spinach
House-Smoked Salmon
Angus Beef Short Rib
Shrimp and Grits
Poached heirloom egg, tasso ham, pan sauce
Hangover Helper
Heirloom egg, ny cheddar, all the breakfast meats, shallot, marble potato, roasted cubanelle salsa verde
Fog City Burger
Roasted cubanelle salsa verde, fried duck egg, ny muenster
Steak and Eggs
Creekstone flat iron, fresh avocado, cilantro mojo
Maine Lobster Roll
Meyer lemon aioli
Rock Shrimp Po’ Mi
Pickled carrots & cucumber, daikon, cilantro, chili aioli
Daily House-Smoked Fish and Bagel
Brooklyn cream cheese, red onion, capers
Our Omelet
Mushroom, spinach, roasted tomato, ny cheddar
The Original Lemon Ricotta Pancakes
Berry compote, lemon curd, vermont maple syrup
Sugar and Plumm Crunch Toast
Brioche, strawberry compote, vanilla, mascarpone cheese
Pastry Basket for the Table
Dairy farm butter, seasonal house-made jams
Options: Per person, Two person
Salads
Roasted Beet Salad
Baby beets, fresh ricotta cheese, petite greens, lemon oil, vinegar
Spinach
Goat cheese, dehydrated raspberries, sherry vinaigrette
Rabbit Season
Confit rabbit, soft poached egg, wild rocket, carrot, haricot vert, orange cider vinaigrette, pistachio, petite mint
Whole Grain
Baby greens, chickpea, organic grains, heirloom radish, mushroom, cured tomato, haricot vert, cipollini onion, house marinated greek olives, lemon vinaigrette
Cobb Wedge
Baby iceberg, house-smoked chicken, maytag blue cheese, heirloom cherry tomatoes, organic egg, avocado, neuske’s bacon, buttermilk-ranch dressing
Sides
Short Rib Hash
Neuske's Bacon
Heirloom Eggs (2)
Chicken-Apple Sausage
Anson Mill Grits
Bagel Brooklyn Cream Cheese
Simple Salad
Shoe String Fries
Seasonal Fruit and Berries
Marble Potato Hash
Buckwheat Crepes
Ham and Gruyere
Options: Heirloom egg, Scrambled, Sunny side up
Spinach and Mushroom
Ny muenster
House-Smoked Salmon
Creme fraiche, red onion, capers
House Smoked Chicken
Roasted vegetables
Shrimp and Avocado
Market greens, lemon vinaigrette
Savory Waffles
Chicken and Waffles
Crispy free-range chicken, vermont maple syrup, dairy farm butter
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Pulled Pork and Waffles
House-smoked 72-hr pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw, jalapeño
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Bacon, Egg and Cheese
Neuske’s bacon, ny cheddar, fried heirloom egg, vermont maple syrup
Roasted Mushroom
Ny muenster, cured tomato, baby arugula, sherry vinaigrette
Ham, Spinach, and Heirloom Egg
Gruyere fondue
Sweet Crepes and Waffles
Butter and Sugar
Dairy farm butter, natural sugar
Lemon, Butter, and Sugar
Dairy farm butter, lemon juice, natural sugar
Nutella
Options: Banana
Cajeta Caramel
Goats’ milk caramel, salted caramel ice cream, fresh whipped cream
Mixed Berry
Vanilla bean ice cream
Apple Tatin
Roasted apples, vanilla bean ice cream, salted caramel
Signature Milkshakes
The Candy Shop
Vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles, candy man’s choice
Hot Chocolate
Shake toasted mini marshmallows
Spiced Pumpkin
Pumpkin and vanilla ice cream, gingersnaps, cinnamon
Grasshopper
Mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate sauce, peppermint patty
Double Chocolate Espresso
Chocolate ice cream, double shot of espresso, dark chocolate-covered espresso beans
Options: Ice cream, Double shot of espresso, Dark chocolate
Waffle & Bacon Shake
Vanilla ice cream, vermont maple syrup, candied bacon, mini waffle
Plain Jane Shakes
Options: Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate
Adult Milkshakes
Frozen Eggnog
Vanilla ice cream, maple-pecan rum, cinnamon, nutmeg
Spiked Snowball
Vanilla ice cream, coffee liqueur, bailey’s
The Ginger Bread Man
Pumpkin gingersnap ice cream, maple-pecan rum
Lunch
Chicken Noodle Soup
Free range
Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
Salads
Simple
Baby greens, heirloom radish, lemon vinaigrette
Yummus
Grilled pita, house marinated olives, guss’ pickles, heirloom radish
Roasted Beet Salad
Baby beets, fresh ricotta cheese, petite greens, lemon oil, vinegar
Spinach
Goat cheese, dehydrated raspberries, sherry vinaigrette
Whole Grain
Baby greens, chickpea, organic grains, heirloom radish, mushroom, cured tomato, haricot vert, cipollini onion, house marinated greek olives, lemon vinaigrette
Cobb Wedge
Baby iceberg, house-smoked chicken, maytag blue cheese, heirloom cherry tomatoes, organic egg, avocado, neuske’s bacon, buttermilk- ranch dressing
Rabbit Season
Confit rabbit, soft poached egg, wild rocket, carrot, haricot vert, orange-cider vinaigrette, pistachio, petite mint
Panini
House-Smoked Salmon
Cream cheese, capers, red onion, roasted tomato, baby greens
American
Root beer braised beef short rib, baby greens, cured tomato, onion, peppadew, cilantro mojo
Roasted Eggplant
Baby arugula, cured tomato, red pepper spread, yummus
House-Smoked Chicken
Boursin spread, neuske’s bacon, red pepper, baby arugula, tomato jam
Cuban
House-smoked 72-hour pork, ham, swiss, house mustard, lemon-garlic mojo
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Big Kids
Angus Foot Long
Custom made foot-long all black angus beef hot dog, house mustard, relish, onion
Classic Cheeseburger
NY cheddar, lettuce, tomato, pickle, special sauce, sesame bun
Fog City Burger
Roasted cubanelle salsa verde, NY muenster, fried duck egg
Cheese and Mac
Local artisan cheese, golden bread crumbs
Options: Neuske’s bacon
Maine Lobster Roll
Meyer lemon aioli
Buckwheat Crêpes
Ham and Gruyere
Add an heirloom egg, scrambled or sunny side-up
Options: Heirloom egg, Scrambled, Sunny side-up
Spinach and Mushroom
NY muenster
House Smoked Salmon
Crème fraiche, red onion, capers
House-Smoked Chicken
Roasted vegetables
Shrimp and Avocado
Market greens, lemon vinaigrette
Savory Waffles
Chicken and Waffles
Crispy free-range chicken, vermont maple syrup, dairy farm butter
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Pulled Pork and Waffles
House smoked 72-hour pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw, jalapeño
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Bacon, Egg, and Cheese
Neuske’s bacon, ny cheddar, fried heirloom egg, vermont maple syrup
Roasted Mushroom
Ny muenster, cured tomato, baby arugula, sherry vinaigrette
Ham, Spinach, and Heirloom Egg
Gruyere fondue
Specialty Milkshakes
The Candy Shop
Vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles, candy man’s choice
Hot Chocolate Shake
Toasted mini marshmallows
Spiced Pumpkin
Pumpkin and vanilla ice cream, gingersnaps, cinnamon
Grasshopper
Mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate sauce, peppermint patty
Double Chocolate Espresso
Chocolate ice cream, double shot of espresso, dark chocolate-covered espresso beans
Waffle & Bacon Shake
Vanilla ice cream, vermont maple syrup, candied bacon, mini waffle
Plain Jane Shakes
Options: Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate
Side Dishes
Guss’ Pickles
Haricot Vert
Shoe String Fries
Neuske's Bacon
Lemon Spinach
Heirloom Beans and Roasted Vegetables
Seasonal Fruit and Berries
Dinner
Appetizers
Salmon Belly Ceviche
Heirloom tomato, melon, cilantro, citrus
Pulled Pork Buns
House smoked 72-hour pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw
Shrimp and Grits
Tasso ham, pan sauce
House Smoked Wings
Free-range, peanuts, green onion, dry rub
Mini Grilled Cheese
Pain de mie, ny muenster, cheddar, roasted mushrooms
“Fish and Chips”
Rock shrimp, bay scallops, maine lobster, purple potato chips, sauce louie
Hamachi Crudo
Cucamelon, grapefruit, burnt coriander vinaigrette
Classic Sliders
American cheese, lettuce, pickle, special sauce, sesame bun
Yummus
Grilled pita, house-marinated olives, guss’ pickles, heirloom radish
Classic Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup
Free range
Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
Salads
Simple
Baby greens, heirloom radish, lemon vinaigrette
Roasted Beet Salad
Baby beets, fresh ricotta cheese, petite greens, lemon oil, vinegar
Spinach
Goat cheese, dehydrated raspberries, sherry vinaigrette
Whole Grain
Baby greens, chickpea, organic grains, heirloom radish, mushroom, cured tomato, haricot vert, cipollini onion, house-marinated greek olives, lemon vinaigrette
Cobb Wedge
Baby iceberg, house-smoked chicken, maytag blue cheese, heirloom cherry tomatoes, organic egg, avocado, neuske’s bacon, buttermilk-ranch dressing
Rabbit Season
Confit rabbit, soft-poached egg, wild rocket, carrot, haricot vert, orange-cider vinaigrette, pistachio, petite mint
Entrees
Free-Range Chicken Breast
Lemon spinach, confit garlic, shallot pan sauce
Crispy Skin Salmon
Lemon hollandaise, haricot vert
Creekstone Farms Sliced Flat Iron Steak 8 Oz
Fresh avocado, cilantro mojo
Line-Caught Striped Bass
Roasted vegetable, heirloom beans, lemon oil
Root Beer-Braised Bone-in Shor
Angus beef short rib, heirloom carrots
Big Kids
Angus Foot Long
Custom made foot-long all black angus beef hot dog, house mustard, relish, onion
Classic Cheeseburger
NY cheddar, lettuce, tomato, pickle, special sauce, sesame bun
Fog City Burger
Roasted cubanelle salsa verde, NY muenster, fried duck egg
Cheese and Mac
Local artisan cheese, golden bread crumbs
Options: Neuske’s bacon, Tasso ham
Maine Lobster Roll
Meyer lemon aioli
Chicken and Waffles
Crispy free-range chicken, vermont maple syrup, dairy farm butter
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Pulled Pork and Waffles
House-smoked 72-hour pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw, jalapeño
Options: Fried heirloom egg
Side Dishes
Guss’ Half Sour Pickles
Haricot Vert
Shoe-String Fries
Lemon Spinach
Heirloom Beans and Roasted Vegetables
Roasted Marble Potatoes
Cocktails
Sugar and Plumm Signature Cocktails
Plummtini
Vodka, house made white plum jam, fresh lemon juice and vanilla, topped with prosecco
Adult Iced Tea
Tea infused vodka, house-made iced tea and lemonade garnished with fresh herbs
Adult Iced Coffee
Aged jamaican rum, orange curcao, cold brew coffee, vanilla syrup, whipped cream
Orange Pomegranate Martini
Citrus infused vodka, lime juice, pomegranate juice, orange curacao
Mango Collins
Vodka, fresh lemon juice, mango puree, topped with club soda
Dominicana Espresso Martini
Aged jamaican rum, coffee liqueur, chilled espresso, whipped cream
The Sugar Plumm
Fig, cherry, & apricot infused tequila, house-made plum syrup, pomegranate and fresh lime juice
Vacation
House infused pecan maple brown butter rum, fresh banana, cocoa, housemaid vanilla ice cream
Stay-Cation
Bacon infused bourbon, house-made vanilla ice cream, chocolate, cold brew coffee
Updated Classic Classics
Prince Thoas Collins
Gin, fresh lemon juice, prosecco, fresh berries
Classic Martini
Choice of vodka or gin, stirred, shaken, dry, bone dry or dirty
Options: Vodka, Gin, Stirred, Shaken, Dry, Bone dry, Dirty
Manhattan
Choice of bourbon or rye, bitters, Italian sweet vermouth, cocoa
Options: Bourbon, Rye, Bitters, Italian sweet vermouth, Cocoa
Bellini
House made peach puree, fresh lemon juice, prosecco
Old Fashioned
House infused bacon bourbon, chocolate bitters
Bloody Mary
Choice of vodka or gin
Sparkling and Rose by the Glass
Sparkling, Gloria Ferrer Brut Cuvee Sonoma, California, USA, N/V
Rose, Petite Cassagne Costieres De Nimes, France, 2011
White Wines by the Glass
Grenache Blanc, Chapoutier, Belleruche Blanc Rhone, France, 2010
Chardonnay, Chanson Vire Clesse Burgundy, France 2010
Pinot Gigio, Pighin Friuli, Italy, 2010
Sauvignon Blanc, Wildrock Marlborough, New Zealand, 2009
Red Wines by the Glass
Chianti, Tiziano Tuscany, Italy, 2008
Malbec, Cuarto Dominio-Tolentino Mendoza, Argentina, 2011
Cabernet Sauvignon, Chateau St. Jean California, USA, 2009
Pinot Noir, Acrobat Oregon, USA, 2010
Half Bottles
Chardonnay, Cakebread (375Ml) Napa Valley, USA, 2010
Cabernet Sauvignon, Napanook (375Ml), Napa Valley, USA, 2009
Champagne by the Bottle
Veuve Cliquot Reims, France, N/V
White Wines by the Bottle
Sancerre, Landgloi-Chateau Sancerre, France, 2011
Sauvignon Blanc, Groth Napa Valley, USA, 2011
Sancerre, La Poussie Sancerre, France, 2009
Riesling, Molitor Mosel, Germany, 2011
Pinot Grigio, Colterenzio Alto Adige, Italy, 2011
Chardonnay, Stags Leap Winery Stags Leap District, USA 2010
Cardonnay, Beringer Vineyards Napa Valley, USA, 2010
Chardonnay, Domaine Ferret Pouilly-Fuisse, France, 2009
Chardonnay, Far Niente Napa Valley, USA, 2010
Red Wines by the Bottle
Cabernet Sauvignon, Beuhler Napa Valley, USA, 2010
Cabernet Sauvignon, Sequoia Grove Napa Valley, USA, 2009
Malbec, Alta Vista Terroir Selection Mendoza, Argentina 2009
Pinot Noir, Sequana Santa Lucia Highlands, California 2009
Syrah, Cotes Du Rhone Delas Rhone, France 2010
Merlot, B De Loudenne Bordeaux, France 2010
Super Tuscan, Braccale, Biondi Santi Tuscany, Italy 2010
Super Tuscan, Tenuta Di Castiglione Tuscany, Italy 2009
Cabernet Sauvignon, Silver Oak Alexander Valley, USA, 2007
Dessert
Brownie a La Mode
Homemade brownie, warm chocolate sauce, salted caramel, vanilla ice cream, fresh whipped cream
Chocolate Mousse
Duo of valrhona milk chocolate and bittersweet chocolate mousse, fresh whipped cream, chocolate shavings
Crackling Baked Alaska
Chocolate ice cream, cashews, chocolate cake, poprocks, caramel-chocolate sauce, rhum flambé
Tdf Cheesecake
Classic cheesecake, mandarin orange segments, creamsicle ice cream, torn mint
Pie of the Day
Slice of our daily selection with ice cream and whipped cream
Earthquake in a Fishbowl
Heaven/hell cake, cheesecake, key lime pie, brooklyn blackout cake, butterscotch pudding, vanilla, chocolate and salted caramel ice cream, whipped cream
Adult Milkshakes
Frozen Eggnog
Vanilla ice cream, maple-pecan rum, cinnamon, nutmeg
Spiked Snowball
Vanilla ice cream, coffee liqueur, bailey’s
The Ginger Bread Man
Pumpkin-gingersnap ice cream, maple-pecan rum
Sweet Crêpes and Waffles
Butter and Sugar
Lemon, Butter, and Sugar
Nutella
Options: Banana
Cajeta Caramel
Goats’ milk caramel, salted caramel ice cream, whipped cream
Mixed Berry
Vanilla bean ice cream
Apple Tatin
Roasted apples, vanilla bean ice cream, salted caramel
Signature Sundaes
The S’More
Chocolate ice cream, marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate sauce
The Jack Tripper
Vanilla ice cream, house butterscotch, chocolate sauce, crushed peanuts, brownie and blondie bites
Apple Pie
Vanilla ice cream, apple pie filling, salted caramel, streusel crust
The Turtle
Vanilla ice cream, salted caramel sauce, chocolate sauce, sugared pecans
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin ice cream, cheesecake, gingersnaps, salted caramel
Classic Banana Split
Fresh bananas, vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, crushed pineapple, strawberry syrup, chocolate sauce and chopped peanuts
Specialty Milkshakes
The Candy Shop
Vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles, candy man’s choice
Hot Chocolate Shake
Toasted mini marshmallows
Spiced Pumpkin
Pumpkin and vanilla ice cream, gingersnaps, cinnamon
Grasshopper
Mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate sauce, peppermint patty
Double Chocolate Espresso
Chocolate ice cream, double shot of espresso, dark chocolate-covered espresso beans
Waffle & Bacon Shake
Vanilla ice cream, vermont maple syrup, candied bacon, mini waffle
Plain Jane Shakes
Options: Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate
Best of Citysearch
Nominated for:
Family Friendly Restaurant
(2013)
Change City
New York City
Los Angeles
Houston
Chicago
Atlanta
Seattle
Portland
Philadelphia
Austin
San Francisco
More…
Best of Citysearch
