Best of Citysearch
view & uploadphotos
- Neighborhoods:
- West Village, Downtown
At a Glance
?
92% ambiance
“There is a happening bar scene and a romantic, wine cellar where one can enjoy an intimate dinner or private party.”
100% dessert
“Everything from the way Katie managed our event and gave us the best recommendations for our dinner, to the personal service we received from her, Freddy and Tony that evening, to the mouth watering appetizers, entrees and desserts.”
92% drinks
“We attended a special event in the wine cellar that was enhanced by the terrific food, friendly and attentive waitstaff and delicious wine and cocktails.”
83% food quality
“went to Macelleria several times, because the food is quite good and I like the location, but the service was never excellent.”
100% menu variety
“The staff is very attentive and engaging and the selection of Italian wine is phenominal.”
100% overall
“almost like they try to brainwash you that this is the best experience of your life eating at their restaurant.”
75% service
“Thanks to their delicious rustic Italian and a staff that went out of their way to make us happy (including bringing latecomers their appetizers long after our meal had begun), I would reccomend them to anyone looking for the perfect place to go, whether ”
85% value
“favorite inexpensive wine, Wyndham Estate Bin 555 Shiraz, retails for about $9.99 at most NYC liquor stores.”
100% wait time
“Thanks to their delicious rustic Italian and a staff that went out of their way to make us happy (including bringing latecomers their appetizers long after our meal had begun), I would reccomend them to anyone looking for the perfect place to go, whether ”
Deals
People also viewed
Related Guides
Your Friends
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Citysearch Mobile
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.
Best of Citysearch
Won for:
Steak
(2007)
Nominated for:
Brunch
(2010)
Business Lunch and Dinner Restaurant (2010)
Fine Dining (2010)
French Fries (2010)
Group Dining (2010)
Burger (2010)
Italian Food (2010)
Lunch Spot (2010)
Outdoor Dining (2010)
Restaurant (2010)
Romantic Restaurant (2010)
Steak (2010)
Wine List (2010)
Steak (2005)
Business Lunch and Dinner Restaurant (2010)
Fine Dining (2010)
French Fries (2010)
Group Dining (2010)
Burger (2010)
Italian Food (2010)
Lunch Spot (2010)
Outdoor Dining (2010)
Restaurant (2010)
Romantic Restaurant (2010)
Steak (2010)
Wine List (2010)
Steak (2005)