Reviews & Ratings for Chelsea Star Hotel - New York Hotels

09/06/07

Never Again!

by jotan23

after the cab driver stopped, i was looking very eagerly where the hotel is since he said that this is it.

to my surprise, the main entrance was a small door.. literally, just the door!!!

you have to ring the bell so it will open )if you don't have your hotel key yet) then after opening the door, there is the stairs welcoming you!!! too bad for those who have back problems because they don't have any elevators or bell boys to help you out!

okay so after reaching the top of the stairs, you have to go to the "lobby" which is a small room and you will have to wait for the receptionist who doesn't mind you at all...

the receptionists are the ones answering the phone, just in case you mistake a guest as one because they don't wear uniforms.

ok, after the long wait, they'll be asking for your name, etc, and check-in time is 3pm.

the location is about 3 blocks away from a subway station but it is located in a bad neighborhood.

anyway, let's talk about the rooms... we got a private suite with private bath.. thankfully! the room was smelly..not too nice indeed! no cabinets, just hangers, the chair was broken, the pillows flat. the carpet is soooooooo dirty.

you can also hear the conversations of the guests from the other room very very clearly.. especially when they're doing what they're supposed to be doing during a honeymoon... i think you get the picture. so it's really hard to sleep at night.

but then, to my surprise, the bathroom is clean.

BUT, the shower sometimes leaks every hour or so.

we paid 188.12 dollars for the room, no breakfast, no cabinets, no bell boys, no elevators, no safety deposit boxes (it is available at the counter for 5 dollars each), bad neighborhood, very dirty carpet, very noisy, but there's free WIFI access! hey! maybe that's all that's great about it :p

i would definitely NOt come back here...

i'd rather pay a few more bucks and get a better room, in a better place :>

• Pros: free WIFI, a few blocks from the subway
• Cons: very dirty, no cabinets, flat pillows, bedmites, bad neighborhood

Editorial Review

by Contributor

Boutique hotel located in Chelsea; laundry services and airport transportation available.

04/08/04

Absolute Delight

by travellotsandlots

I just went crazy over the decor of this hotel. This has to be the most entertaining place Ive stayed since I started my little tour of the east coast. Its very well priced and surprisingly comfortable. From what I understand, they just made lots of renovation, so this is basically a brand new hotel. I didnt know this, but Madonna used to live there. They even turned her room into theme room that you can actually stay in. Maybe next time!

Anyways, if you are looking for a comfortable and fun hotel at a great price you have to check into this place. Literally!

• Pros: Atmosphere, Price, Location

05/29/03

Adorable

by ctnyinny

I was spending a weekend in the city and needed somewhere cheap and small. This was so much more than I expected. From the minute you step in the door you feel at home. This place is adorable. The staff is great and the rooms are unique. This is a diamond in the rough.

• Pros: outdoor sitting area, friendly staff