Reviews & Ratings for Pizza Suprema

03/30/12

Pizza is decent!!!

by gailk84

Popular atmosphere. Pizza is decent! Very like me!!!

03/17/12

BEST pizza in NYC, by far

by Briana786

This pizza is beyond amazing. Right amount of cheese, sauce and every other ingredient. If your by penn station/MSG- this is a must g. Got the top 10 BEST pizza restaurants in NYC https://files.nyu.edu/jdy215/public/

01/11/12

Good pizza

by ztwgenwmj

I have had the privilege of finding this little jewel of a pizzeria. The prices are excellent for delivery or carry-out. The pizza quality is quite good given the low budget busting prices. I would recommend this pizzeria as a good pizza with a super value.

07/09/11

Great Pizza

by JoeMoralli

I visited NYC for 1 day. I tried Pizza Suprema after searching the internet for good NY style pizza.

Awesome pizza at a good price.

Perfect crust, sauce and toppings.

I had a slice of white pizza and pepperoni pizza for $7.75. Huge slices.

I don't see how this could be improved.

Please keep it up. I will eat here every time I visit NYC.

If a restaurant like this existed in Northern VA, Pizza Hut, Dominos and Papa Johns would immediately be out of business.

05/22/11

joannas restaurant

by joannas2001

kdfkllllllllllllllll

03/07/11

Best pizza ever!

by The pig

I work several blocks from Pizza Suprema. Almost weekly,

a group from work heads for lunch together and even though there are numerous pizza joints in the area, we always choose Pizza Suprema. Their upside down pizza is out of this world. And their sauce is just yummy no matter which pizza you get. I would recommend Pizza Suprema anytime you are in the 34th Street area in the Big

Apple.

The Pig

02/24/11

Excellent service

by raphaelnet2003

Excellent spot for anyone. You get value for your time and money.

11/18/10

Friends posting positive comments don't make reviews legit

by FoxyDaisy

I got suspicious when this little regular pizzeria, like the thousand others around NYC have so much positive, if any reviews...more so than sit-down restaurants with waiters.

I ordered a slice and sausage roll. My highest praises reached an "eh... I had better". First of all, the plain slice was this sloppy hot mess with enough oil dripping out to fuel a small car. That also helped the whole cheese layer to smush out. The taste? I've had better but it wasnt awful. The sausage roll was the same, the marinara sauce that it came with was bland and watered down.

The pizzeria itself blatantly displayed all the printouts of its positive reviews from citysearch and other review sites. So much so, it makes me wonder if this was their plan all along. And whether if these reviews are legit due to the extreme high numbers of reviews and positive reviews.

No one is gonna take the trouble to go online to citysearch and write a colorful review about their quick lunch break.

Scroll down to 3/24/10 and 3/14/10 and you'll see what I mean about the illegitimate reviews here

08/02/10

Pizza Lovers Pizza

by Lindacooper

Happen to be driving by the family was hungry, the kids and myself are pizza lovers, this seemed like the place to go. Great pizza, nice place to dine and all were happy. The brothers are the perfect hosts. Thanks guys.

07/16/10

amazing

by jakebloom64

if you are looking for the best pizza in the world look no further it's right here !