(212) 242-4300

363 W 16th St
New York, NY 10011 40.742 -74.0032

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhoods: Chelsea, Midtown

THEMARITIMEHOTEL.COM

Reviews & Ratings for Maritime Hotel

3 Star Rating: Average

11 reviews

What users are saying:

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/21/05

Great pizza and outdoor seating

by jbhein12 at Citysearch

I was impressed by the thin crust pizza they served. It's some of the best in the Meatpacking district. The atmosphere was great, especially in the outdoor seating. The drink selection was above average, and the service was solid. I would definitely go back.

  • Pros: outdoor seating, pizza
1 Star Rating: Poor

06/23/07

Do not be misled

by wif2 at Citysearch

While I cannot complain about the beautiful atmosphere and trendy decor, I must tell you, IT IS NOT WORTH IT. Bouncers are rude and discriminatory, table service is horrible, bartenders barely know the recipes to mix drinks, and the prices are outrageous. You are better off at any other bar in the city (and trust me, I have been to plenty). The Maritime hotel is completely misleading. Don?t let it fool you?.

3 Star Rating: Average

04/25/07

Worst Service

by erikanyc at Citysearch

I went to the Maritime to enjoy the nice weather and get some drinks with a few of my friends. We sat there from 6-8pm and literally saw the waitress twice. It was impossible to get drinks she took forever, we could never find her. Then to top the bill was wrong and it took her an hour to fix it. They really need to get more help for the outside area immediatley.

1 Star Rating: Poor

04/24/07

NEED NEW STAFF

by ileanaa2k at Citysearch

I normally do not post a review but I just had to after last night. We wanted to be outside to enjoy NYC's first 80 degree weather in 2007. If it wasn't for the weather and great company I was with the night would of been a nightmare.

The drinks were terrible. The Mojitos had old limes and old mint leaves. After the bad mojito I switched to a Cosmo and that wasn't any better. My friends also hated their drinks, so decided to switch to beer and they were HOT. Seemed like it just came out the stock room.

To top it off the service was also terrible. We couldn't find our waitress half the night and it took forever to get a drink and food. I been here a couple of times and this is by FAR the worse experience I had. I won't be going here for a while.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

11/01/06

Trendy

by enajo at Citysearch

If you're looking for a good, trendy, outdoor, see-and-be-seen hotel bar, this is the place. It's loud and crowded, but the service isn't that bad, and it's not uncommon to spot celebrities.

  • Pros: Very trendy, very chic
  • Cons: Loud and crowded
2 Star Rating: Below Average

07/10/06

Over charged and under-serviced!

by karahughett at Citysearch

I have never experienced such bad service in my life. When we decided to celebrate a special occasion at the Maritime lounge we quickly learned that was a mistake! When our server was asked, "What's in this martini?" she quickly snapped back, "I don't know, whatever it says that's in there." Besides the additude we received from the moment we walked in the door from the hostess, we were overcharged and our server tried to pull a fast one and keep $50 that we asked her to apply to the bill. When she returned to collect the credit card receipts (which she broke the server cardinal rule,) she looked at them and asked, "Is this right?"

Overall, I will never be returning to The Maritime and will make sure to tell everyone that I know about our experience because I know that 'word of mouth' is a powerful tool.

3 Star Rating: Average

06/14/06

Just Order Drinks.....

by lajames at Citysearch

Don't expect too much and you won't be let down. The outdoor seating and ambiance makes it a nice place to sit over a drink and chat with friends. Don't bother ordering food because it's overpriced and the quality is terrible. Service is a bit slow, but it's a good place to sit and relax if you're with friends.

  • Pros: Good Ambiance
  • Cons: Bad Food, Slow Service
3.5 Star Rating: Average

07/08/04

This nautical hotel lounge offers the romance of a cruise ship, without the risk of seasickness.

by Kara Zuaro at Citysearch

The Scene
The retro decor of this quaint hotel lobby features a kitschy seafaring mural, soothing navy-blue accents and enough dark-wood paneling to suggest that the Love Boat has dropped anchor in Chelsea. A roaring fire heats up patrons in the winter months, but the warm weather lures visitors to an outdoor terrace, where spherical Chinese lanterns hang from above, and strings of blue lights spruce up neatly potted trees.

The Draw
A young, professional crowd snags open-air seating or lingers on the vintage-style armchairs and sofas, and short-skirted waitresses deliver Mediterranean-inspired drinks and snacks from the hotel's Italian bistro, La Bottega. Thin-crusted pizza with imported mozzarella pairs well with the vino alla salvia--rose wine infused with sage and topped with a twist of lemon. The prosecco, or sparkling wine, mixed with fresh mandarin orange juice tastes as sweet and refreshing as the sun and sand on foreign shores.

1 Star Rating: Poor

07/02/04

Not fun!

by foodie6 at Citysearch

Service was terrible!! For the prices they charge for teeny drinks ($10+) they could be a little much more accomodating. We had to ask 3 times for menus, wait 15 minutes for drinks. Everyone working there seemed confused about their jobs/tables. There are better places in the neighborhood. The scene wasn't worth it. Young professionals- new to NYC/ tourists.

  • Pros: outside- no view
  • Cons: , horrible service
1 Star Rating: Poor

06/20/04

ugh!

by aeschatz at Citysearch

Went to the bar last night because it was a fantastic, beatiful day and we wanted to sit outside. The service was SO awful, and it wasn't even that busy! Our drinks arrived and they too were lame - they must make their margaritas from a mix (yuck!). Then the biggest shocker of all - THE CHECK - our 2 drinks were $30!!! I know it's a hip spot for drinks, but PLEASE! For that price the service and drinks should be excellent.

  • Pros: nice outdoor seating
  • Cons: , poorly made drinks, price

Showing 1-10 of 11 reviews

Advertisement

Lists In Manhattan

Recent Reviews In Manhattan

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Hotel Giraffe

365 Park Ave S, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

The Bowery Hotel

335 Bowery, New York City, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Hotel Roger Williams

131 Madison Ave, New York, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Hotel Caribe

515 W 145TH St, New York, NY

Advertisement