08/17/09

DO NOT EAT HERE

by hungry09

I ate at the location on 6th Ave, just a few blocks south of the Best Buy. Felt a bit nauseous a few hours later, and this ended up lasting over a week! Clearly, their meat was undercooked, as I was not able to resume normal eating for this period. I would advise anyone looking for a burger to try a different place.

10/02/08

Yummy!

by BlueIcePrincess

I love the Chicago burger!!! the place wasnt packed but yet again it was 9PM; the service was a bit slow but the wait was worth it!

My burger was to die for - the onion rings weren't that great so I ended up eating my friends fries! :-)

love love love it!!!

• Pros: public transporation,
• Cons: slow service, stay away from onion rings

08/05/08

Not much better than McDonalds

by voldar

We tried this after reading many good reviews and frankly their was nothing I liked about this restaurant. The burger was not great. It feels like McDonalds. The establishment was dirty and the staff did not really care. if you want a quick good burger try Good Burger, Zip Burger or myriad other places before this mediocre restaurant.

01/08/08

YUMMY.

by msdecember

my mom and i went after not being able to get a table at mrkt next door... weren't really looking to find anything to eat since she and i both were on a limited diet.. she found a garden salad that was probably nothing to scream about even though she enjoyed it.. but i got a veggie burger that was to die for!! it came with cucumber dill yogurt sauce and since i'm very "saucy".. i was in heaven with the unlimited toppings that were available.

• Pros: great veggie burger, great unlimited toppings
• Cons: seats are sort of dirty, overpriced

09/29/07

Worst burger ever!

by dani43

We read reviews of this place and we were excited to go to New York Burger Co. to get natural, no preservatives ingredients in the meat, etc. But the fries were horrible, the burger and bread were dry. Any diner in the city will serve you a much better burger. If you are looking for a healthy and juicy burger go to Better Burger, they are the best. Besides, NY Burger Co is supposed to close at 10:45 according to Citysearch. We were still eating at 10:20 when one of the employees started to sweep the floor and the table with the same broom! Disgusting! To be sweeping up while customers are still eating is not only offensive but it likely breaks health codes. Sorry, but we're not going back...

07/17/07

I ROCK this place at least 3 TIMES A WEEK!!

by jova1231

I love this place!! The burgers are great and I love the fact they have everything (Toppings, grill, sandwich construction) out in plain site! Seems like they have nothing to hide. Thank God they deliver up here, too!! I see a good amount of people ordering salads too, which I enjoy also.

You can keep your frozen, microwaved dollar menu!! LOL

• Pros: Great Food, Delivery

06/21/07

DON"T FALL FOR IT!!

by foodfreakny

I know burgers and this ain't no burger! tastes like chuck, looks like cooked chuck, "HOW MUCH DO THAY WANT FOR THIS??? WHAT? - are they joaking? are we choaking? please, DON'T DO IT !!

05/02/07

Go to McDonald's or Jackson Hole

by DepecheNYC

You'll get better deal from any other fast food restaurants. However, if you want some decent/good burgers then go to Jackson Hole instead of this place. This place is too pricy to be fast food restaurant. It's not really restaurant/diner like either. I wouldn't go again.

• Pros: Unlimited sauces and soda?
• Cons: Pricy, slow service

04/25/07

Pricey but SO worth it

by aacoombs

Not sure what that person down there was talking about (burger sat under a heat lamp for 15-20 min) because everytime we've gone our burgers were made when we ordered them. A little pricey for burgers but its SO worth it. You actually feel like you're eating meat and not gross oil-soaked patties. We keep going everytime we're hungry and in Chelsea.

• Pros: burgers are delish

01/10/07

great burgers, wonderful ethics

by zdevil

good tasty burgers. wish it delivered to my office. high quality cheeses and toppings. and no guilt about how the cows suffered.

• Pros: great food, great ethics
• Cons: a bit pricey