(212) 744-1100
1561 2nd Ave
New York,
NY
10028
40.7749
-73.9542
Neighborhoods: Midtown, Yorkville
Reviews & Ratings for Spigolo
19 reviews
What users are saying:
01/13/09
Wonderfully Crafted Food - a Complete Gem
by sakumawiki
A reservation was absolutely necessary for a late Saturday dinner several weeks ago. The restaurant is tightly packed with two and four top tables ? and a four-stool bar ? all completely full when we arrived after 9:00. We weren?t immediately impressed, or particularly put off, by the decor and lighting, only wished we knew ahead of time to ask for a window table. Wine list is realistic ? with a good range of styles and prices. We opted to start with antipasti of baby octopus and an evening special of char tartare ? both of which were immensely flavorful - delicate and distinct at the same time. The octopus was tender and spiced enough to be lively and interesting but not overkill for a starter, and the char was fresh, light and perfect - if a little on the small side. We each ordered a primi ? one garganelli pasta and one seafood risotto ?del giorno? and were delighted that the main (pasta and rice) courses were as spectacular as the appetizers - simple, delicious and each with subtle flavor twist that made them memorable and all too easy to finish (such as an ingenious smattering of microscopically diced jalapeno in the risotto - fragrant and herblike - it seemed to help pronounce the seafood and cut the rich base at the same time) . We ended with airy and warm apple fritters, a dessert I?d be happy to call breakfast ? afternoon snack or just dessert again and again. I would highly recommend the restaurant ? stick to small groups and be ready for a tight fit and a bit of shouting. If, like we did, you can't seem to leave when dessert is done, try a glass of the camomile infused grappa - it's brilliant!
- Pros: Great service, wine list, exceptional food
- Cons: crowded, small tables, loud room
07/04/07
Winning UES Italian
by charlesmstam
I had a positive experience at this restaurant. The food was very good and the service friendly. GIven the lack of good restaurants in the neighborhood, it was very refreshing to eat here. The decor was casual, which seemed out of place given the hefty tabs. Yet the food is worth the price. The menu seemed rather limited to me, but overall a great place on the UES worth making the trip to.
- Pros: Excellent Italian Food and Dessert Menu, Friendly Service
- Cons: Not Cheap, Service Was Rushed At Times
11/20/06
Nice ambience, friendly staff
by caro67
I discovered Spigolo with a friend of mine. The place is utterly charming, the staff is friendly, the menu choice is good. We were served quickly (perhaps a little more time could have lapsed between our appetizer and the entree). Food was good, I had the beet salad and it was really tasty, then had fish and that was equally good. I love the fact that the dishes have normal portions, and are not American-size. I will definitely go back.
- Pros: the decor, the staff, the food
- Cons: none
11/12/06
Best Italian on UES
by scorpio81
I called a week before to make reservations and only the 5.30 time slot was open, usually I don't eat dinner on mountain time but the space is small and seats maybe 30 so you take what you get. I can't say enough good things about this place. The menu and wine list are simple and concise, got a great Italian red for 39 and the dessert wines are not to be missed particularly the "chardonnay". My date and I split the risotto appetizer and it just melted in our mouths. He had a perfectly cooked strip steak and I had the sole. We never spoke whilst eating unless to say "you've gotta try this". All night long oohs and mmms were the words of choice. The panna cotta was firm yet creamy and had blackberries sprinkled around that complimented the creaminess. For two with a bottle, app, two entrees, dessert and after dinner drinks the bill came to 160 (without tip). Usually 30 dollar entrees would trigger the miser in me to run but the food was worth it. I got more out of Spigolo than expected and will definitely be back.
- Pros: FOOD
08/21/06
Perfect summer outdoor dinner experience.
by yrcritic
Excellent! You can taste that the dish was prepared just for you and the service is there to allow you to enjoy it. At Spigolo, there is a large enough portion for you to enjoy your meal and no one to rush you through it. Everything we ordered was fabulous! The food and overall dining experience reflects both pride in the quality of their dishes and genuine desire for their guests to have a casual, enjoyable dining experience. I would agree with the other comments that it is a bit pricy, but the prices should not be a bar to eating here!
- Pros: fresh, delicious, innovative menu
- Cons: pricy
08/15/06
Prices to high !! Service so so .. Food below mediocre!!
by megjdm
Just dont waste you time their are much better choices locally that have much better pricing and with much better food. This location has long been looking for the right people to serve this area, but once again the food gods have failed. It would seem heather and I beleive dave would be better served by changing their career choice
- Pros: Nice and quite.
- Cons: prices are out of wack for the food.
06/01/06
not worth the hype!
by nust06
considering you have to wait for weeks to get a reservation it is not worth it, other than the service nothing stands out. the food was average, the room was cramped and awkward for everyone-customers and servers. i was expecting something much more based off of all their good press but was disappointed. service was great however- friendly, professional, and on top of everything. it takes more than just a cute couple with a "cute restaurant" to last in new york, good luck spigolo!
- Pros: service
- Cons: over priced, over rated, unoriginal food
03/28/06
A New Upper East Side Success
by stewart910
Invited by friends to discuss business, I checked out the bar first, and didn't give my nme which was known to the owners Scott & Heather. Even as a stranger, the service at the bar was excellent as was the wait staff who continuously checked back to see if I was okay while waiting for my party. The food is exceptional, as are the desserts which are all created by Heather, while Scott oversees the kitchen's menu. I'd go back in New York Minute.
- Pros: extremely courteous, Excellent wines, outrageous food
03/06/06
Way overpriced
by nancygail
The food was decent, nothing special. The $11 salad was unbelievably small. It's a tiny place, with no special decor. Entrees approaching $30 are entirely unjustified.
- Pros: food was decent
- Cons: prices too high
02/25/06
Nice place, poor value
by efz4
It is always nice to see quality restaurants appear on the Upper East Side--after four years in the neighborhood we get tired of always going downtown for good food. But while the space is lovely, the staff is very friendly, and there are some nice dishes, the bill at Spigolo is about 20% higher than it should be given the quality/alternatives. The grilled strip was fine (and came with unique potato creations) but the grilled salmon was truly mediocre; the pasta was very oily, and the arugula/orange salad was overly simple (for $11). I hope that Spigolo stays open and am thrilled that it seems to be busy often, but we wont be quite won over until the owners can make the quality match the prices (or vice versa). As stated in a previous review, it definitely does not [yet] deserve a 26 from Zagat!
- Pros: friendly environment, nice decor, interesting menu
- Cons: high prices, some mediocre food
Join Us on Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter